- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Target-Driven Information Bottleneck (TDIB) framework for infrared small target detection under degradation. The method introduces Target-Driven Selective Retention (TDSR), which combines a frozen invertible encoder and a variational bottleneck to preserve target information through spatially weighted KL divergence and local inverse reconstruction. Inference-Aligned Ranking (IAR) uses posterior sampling to improve prediction consistency and candidate box ranking. The authors also construct IR-DegradeX with multiple degradation settings. Experiments show improvements in overall AP, particularly at stricter IoU thresholds.
Critical strengths
- The idea of selective information retention is interesting. It provides a different perspective from conventional image restoration and feature purification methods for degraded infrared small target detection.
- The method design is reasonable. TDSR focuses on preserving target information, while IAR uses posterior sampling to improve prediction consistency and candidate ranking.
- The experiments include multiple degradation settings, multi-seed ablations, and representation analysis. The results show improvements in overall AP, particularly at stricter IoU thresholds.
Critical weaknesses
- TDSR reduces information compression in target regions but does not explicitly distinguish ordinary backgrounds from target-like clutter. Whether this design can effectively suppress false alarms needs further verification. Besides, some background context may be useful for distinguishing real targets from clutters. Strong background compression may remove such information.
- IAR combines posterior drift and localization quality for candidate ranking. However, the posterior drift values in Figure 4 are relatively small, making r_i=q_i\exp(-d_i) very close to q_i. Whether posterior drift provides additional benefits beyond localization quality is unclear. Besides, the ablation results show that consistency supervision reduces prediction disagreement and localization jitter but slightly decreases AP. The relationship between prediction stability and detection performance needs further explanation.
- The experiments are mainly conducted on IR-DegradeX, where the training and test sets use the same synthetic degradation operators. Generalization to unseen degradations and real-world interference remains unclear. Besides, the results mainly report overall AP under different degradation combinations. More detailed evaluations of individual degradation types, Precision, Recall are needed to clarify the sources of performance improvements.
Questions for authors
Refer to weakness.
6 comments
Reply 2/2: Individual degradations and real-image generalization
W3. Operator-level AP, precision/recall, and generalization. We added results for the seven single-degradation groups in the 300-image IR-DegradeX L1 test split. Entries are COCO box AP and precision/recall at IoU 0.50 with validation-selected thresholds. “Best baseline” is the highest per-operator AP among JFD³, NS-FPN, and UIU-Net; the strongest baseline varies by operator.
| Operator (images) | TDIB AP | Best baseline AP | TDIB precision / recall (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gaussian blur (49) | 68.26 | 66.31 | 97.92 / 95.92 |
| Motion blur (64) | 69.52 | 68.68 | 98.36 / 93.75 |
| Infrared haze (54) | 71.28 | 71.08 | 100 / 100 |
| Gain nonuniformity (49) | 64.61 | 64.76 | 100 / 97.96 |
| Gaussian noise (28) | 68.54 | 68.79 | 100 / 100 |
| Fixed-pattern stripes (30) | 67.46 | 68.65 | 100 / 100 |
| Bias field (26) | 67.87 | 69.05 | 100 / 96.15 |
Across the seven operators, TDIB achieves the highest average AP (68.22) and the best worst-operator AP (64.61), compared with 67.55/63.44 for JFD³, 66.17/61.09 for NS-FPN, and 65.28/60.91 for UIU-Net. TDIB leads on Gaussian blur, motion blur, and infrared haze and remains close to the per-operator best elsewhere. Its drop from the operator mean to the worst operator is also the smallest (3.61 AP, versus 4.11–5.08 for the baselines). TDIB therefore shows the most uniform performance across degradation types, rather than depending on one favorable operator. The revised appendix reports AP and precision/recall for all four methods on each operator. (Appendix 9.2, Tables 16–17)
We further evaluated independent real-image generalization on IRBlurUAV. All methods were adapted and selected using only synthetic IRBlurUAV data; the 4,118 real frames were held out for testing.
| Method | Real test AP / AP50 / AP75 (4,118 frames) |
|---|---|
| TDIB | 15.00 / 48.99 / 3.85 |
| JFD³ | 13.13 / 44.06 / 2.10 |
| NS-FPN | 12.41 / 41.06 / 3.04 |
| UIU-Net | 9.03 / 35.87 / 1.18 |
These frames are captured by infrared sensors rather than generated by synthetic operators, so their blur includes sensor and scene effects that simulation can only approximate; none was used for adaptation or model selection. TDIB leads in AP, AP50, and AP75 on real images, improving AP by 1.87 points over the strongest alternative. Together with the seven-operator results, this provides complementary evidence across constructed degradation processes and independently acquired infrared imagery. (Sec. 4.2, Table 2; Appendices 9.2 and 10.1)
After reading the repsonse, I still concerned about the generalization capability of this method. Although the authors subsequently expanded their evaluation to include results on IRBlurUAV, these datasets are not commonly used in this field. I suggest that the authors validate the performance on IRSTD-1K and NUAA-SARST datasets(for degraded scenarios, you can introduce noise or other forms of interference into these datasets). Consequently, I am maintaining my previous score.
Reply 1/2: Background clutter, posterior drift, and IAR
W1. Target-like clutter, background context, and false alarms. TDSR allocates compression pressure according to annotated target regions rather than intensity or contrast. Bright target-like clutter therefore receives no automatic target-level protection, while background structure can remain available when useful for discrimination. Detection supervision determines which retained responses become target predictions.
We tested whether useful context survives selection using 740 target/background patch pairs matched in size, intensity, and local contrast. Full TDIB reconstructs target and matched-background patches with average errors of 0.078 and 0.136 gray levels, versus 3.666 and 4.524 without local fidelity (A2). Figure 9 shows that retained information need not elicit a high detection response: visible date characters retain nearly the same raw posterior KL as the UAV (20.82 vs. 21.86) but receive a peak detection score of 0.0044 vs. 0.8237 for the target. On the test FROC curves at matched 95% Pd (855/900 targets), Full produces 16 false boxes (0.0178/image), versus 11 (0.0122/image) for A1 (uniform rate), while improving Macro AP from 67.92 to 68.19. These results show that TDSR preserves background context without requiring it to produce target-like detector responses. (Sec. 4.3; Appendix 12.3, Tables 28–29 and Fig. 9)
W2. Posterior drift and candidate ranking. To isolate drift, we replaced the reliability target r=qexp(−d) with localization quality q alone, keeping assignment and all other losses unchanged:
Drift discounting improves AP in all three seeds (+0.40 AP on average) and reduces the standard deviation from 0.54 to 0.07. It therefore adds useful supervision beyond localization quality alone. Fig. 4 reports the dimensionless drift of Eq. (5), computed from the original predictions with center displacement normalized by the target diagonal. Drift stays below 0.007 for all three illustrated candidates, so r remains close to q. Both q and r favor c4 over c3, whereas the mean-path score ranks c3 first; the ranking loss addresses this disagreement. The figure illustrates how reliability supervision is constructed in one example, while the three-seed control above measures the contribution of drift discounting to detection. Reliability is a training target, not test-time reranking.
Consistency controls a different property. Across three seeds, adding consistency to A3 decreases classification JS from 35.39 to 11.03 (×10⁻⁶) and box jitter from 0.0256 to 0.0183 px, while AP stays nearly unchanged (67.89 → 67.82). Stable predictions are not necessarily correctly ranked. The controlled 2×2 ablation makes their complementarity explicit:
With consistency, ranking contributes +0.343 AP; without it, ranking changes AP by −0.422. Consistency makes predictions robust to posterior variation, while drift-discounted ranking teaches which candidate should receive the higher deployed score. Their combination turns posterior variation into more reliable single-path detection, which is the purpose of IAR. (Sec. 4.3; Appendix 11.2, Tables 23–24; Appendices 12.4 and 12.6)