- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Based on the observation that "target pixels sequentially alter the brightness of surrounding pixels, whereas noise fluctuations occur only at individual pixels," the authors developed two modules, TMM and LSA, to enable rapid detection.
Critical strengths
The detection speed is high. This is a strong starting point, as current multi-frame detection methods indeed require more lightweight and efficient solutions, and only such approaches can be more effectively deployed in practice. This constitutes a sound and promising foundation for the work.
Critical weaknesses
At first glance, this paper appears to be well organized; however, upon closer examination, its readability is poor. The abstract and introduction do not clearly articulate the research problem itself, and the content appears to be a restatement of existing methods. The methodology section is particularly difficult to follow and lacks logical coherence.
- The motivation presented in the introduction has already been extensively discussed in the literature, and it does not require further elaboration here. The references you cite already address this point. As such, this does not constitute the specific motivation for your study.
- The writing of this paper requires comprehensive refinement, as the current text is quite difficult to read. Although the author’s intent is discernible, the argument only becomes clear after reading the entire manuscript and then revisiting it from the beginning. Moreover, the paper lacks a central thesis that effectively synthesizes its main points. It is recommended that the author revise the manuscript to improve clarity and coherence.
- I have not been able to identify the motivation for TTM and LSA in the key sections. Why is that? The methods section appears to be a restatement of the introduction.
Questions for authors
- What is the motivation behind the TMM and LSA?
- What is the rationale behind setting the hyperparameters in the objective function in this manner?
- How does LSA aggregate motion trajectories? I notice that the network architecture employs a depthwise convolution, which I find difficult to understand.
- Spatial and temporal features are modeled separately, and temporal motion context is utilized to guide spatial feature extraction. This approach has been adopted by many authors, and the key distinction among them—such as in methods like MOCID—lies in how the temporal context is integrated and how the spatial features are subsequently refined.
There are a few minor issues, such as text overlapping with figure; it is recommended that the entire document be checked for such problems.