- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes AxisQ, a post-training quantization framework for COD. Its core claim is that the useful allocation axis for bit precision changes with feature depth. Shallow stages benefit more from channel-domain allocation, while deep stages from local-frequency domain allocation. AxisQ realizes this via task-sensitive channel costs (empirical-Fisher), COD-aware frequency costs (COD-GGN), and an auxiliary boundary-aware Hessian reconstruction. Experiments span 2 backbones across 4 benchmarks with 5 precision settings and compare with multiple PTQ baselines. The results shows the largest gains under W2A2 setting, reaching 12.7% weighted-F improvement on CFRN.
Critical strengths
- The improvements are uniform and consistent across all settings and achieve large margins on the hardest setting.
- Treating per-channel and per-frequency not as a fixed setting but as a depth-adaptive choice is a modest but real contribution.
Critical weaknesses
- The central motivation is weakly supported. The sensitivity concentrates in channels is evidenced only by Figure 2. The figure only convers one selected COD image without any dataset-level aggregation. Therefore the generalizable claim is stated far beyond its evidence.
- The complex components seem contribute near-zero gain. COD-GGN occupies a lot 篇幅, yet accounts for only 0.008 in Table 3. The boundary-aware Hessian is worse. The gains are carried by the conceptually simple mixed-domain, while the two complex components add little measurable benefit despite their heavy derivation.
Questions for authors
- Can you provide some statistics for the channel/frequency concentration in Figure 2? For example the distribution, mean and variance across COD10k dataset?
- The largest gains are at W2A2, but deployment timing covers only W4A4. Is there any hardware path on which 2-bit activations yield real speedup, or is W2A2 purely a simulation result?
- Given Table 6 shows no change, what is the intended justification for retaining the boundary-aware Hessian component?
- The method uses many fixed hyperparameters (γ=0.30, β=0.10, α=2, η=0.1, =2). How sensitive are results to them?