- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper investigates cross-session identity leakage in motor-imagery EEG systems and proposes a Riemannian covariance-space transformation to suppress subject identity while preserving task-relevant information. Although the results are promising and the paper is well written and easy to follow, the paper has very limited machine learning novelty. The proposed method is mainly a reuse of well-developed Riemannian alignment under distribution shifts to extract domain-invariant information for cross-subject decoding. In my opinion, these are two questions within the same spirit, so the paper's contribution to the ML community is insufficient.
Critical strengths
S1: The identity leakage issue exists in real-world applications, and adapting Riemannian alignment shows promising results.
Critical weaknesses
W1: This paper has very limited novelty related to the machine learning community. Its main contribution is to introduce the well-developed Riemannian alignment for distribution shifts in a new setting.
As Riemannian alignment under distribution shifts aims to extract domain-invariant information, the identity issue is straightforward to solve.
While the optional stages contribute little, the main contribution is again from Riemannian alignment.
I don't see any potential impact of this paper on the machine learning community at ICLR.
W2: This paper studied a general identity leakage problem but only tested on motor imagery, ignoring other BCI tasks that share the same identity leakage issue (e.g., SSVEP) [1].
[1] Meng, Lubin, et al. "User identity protection in EEG-based brain–computer interfaces." IEEE transactions on neural systems and rehabilitation engineering 31 (2023): 3576-3586.
Questions for authors
What's the contribution of the paper other than introducing Riemannian alignment to the identity leakage setting?
Why focus only on motor imagery data? Is there any specific reason not to consider other BCI tasks that could share the same issue?