- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work models a bimanual robot using point clouds. It then establishes contact relationships between the two robotic arms, as well as between the arms and the contacted objects, to achieve collision avoidance. The method is simple and effective, and the paper is very clearly written, as discussed in the first point of the Strengths section. However, the weaknesses are also obvious. The experimental design is unreasonable, and there is no cost analysis, which makes this work incomplete. In addition, the novelty is limited.
Critical strengths
The paper is quite readable. The writing is clear, and the logic flows smoothly. It is easy for readers to understand, and there are no apparent signs of AI-assisted writing. I can see that the authors have put large efforts into writing the manuscript. In particular, the narrative logic in Sections 1 (Introduction) and 2 (Related Work) is very rigorous. Figures 1 to 3 appear to be hand-drawn. Although they are not as polished or visually appealing as AI-assisted figures, they convey the ideas very clearly. There is no unnecessary or irrelevant content, allowing readers to easily understand the authors' method. The method section is not packaged with complicated formulas. It is written very concisely, and the explanations of each formula are sufficient. In addition, the design of the method's architecture is also simple. This may indicate that the authors' method is simple and effective.
Critical weaknesses
1.The experimental design is unreasonable, and the real-robot experiments are too simple.
2.The evaluation metrics are not reasonably designed. Since the work focuses on collisions, it is difficult to analyze the problem when all the metrics are task success rates. The paper also lacks related analysis.
3.The approach used for collision detection is actually already quite mature. I do not think the novelty is sufficient. In addition, if there is only a single joint angle, is a topological point cloud really necessary?
4.The experimental section lacks a cost analysis of the architecture.
Questions for authors
1.This work is somewhat similar to Motion Policy Networks (Adam Fishman et al., CoRL 2023). What is the difference between this work and the idea of using scene point clouds to learn collision-free motions in that paper?
The following are some minor suggestions, not questions:
1.In line 160, "bimanual-spatial feature" is used, but Figure 2 uses "bi-spatial feature". I suggest using consistent terminology to make it clearer for readers.
2.There is no need to include the results for all categories in Table 1. I also suggest including the publication years of the compared methods in the table. This would allow readers to directly see the relationship between how recent the methods are and their performance.
3.The title of this work contains "Beyond Joint Angles". Although this is correct, I do not think it summarizes the motivation of this work very well. It might be more appropriate to remove this phrase or revise the title. Of course, I am willing to hear the authors' rebuttal.