- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CroMoGen, a training-free framework for retargeting cross-embodiment mobile manipulation demonstrations. Using the object motion from the demonstration as a reference, the method generates executable robot trajectories through grasp pose adaptation for the target robot, joint optimization of the base and arm trajectories, and collision detection and repair. The paper evaluates human-to-robot and robot-to-robot cross-embodiment transfer on ParaHome and RoboCasa, and validates the executability of the generated trajectories via real-world experiments with a Spot robot.
Critical strengths
-
Cross-embodiment experimental validation is extensive. The paper evaluates human-to-robot and robot-to-robot demonstration transfer on ParaHome and RoboCasa across three morphologically distinct mobile manipulators, and provides real-world execution results.
-
The demonstration generation success rate shows a clear advantage. By jointly planning base and arm motions, CroMoGen significantly outperforms baselines across multiple tasks, proving the practical value of full kinematic and collision constraints for cross-embodiment transfer.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is clearly insufficient. CroMoGen primarily integrates existing techniques for grasp generation, inverse kinematics, dynamic programming, and collision detection, and the concept of joint base-arm planning is not new. Lacking sufficient ablation studies and direct comparisons with existing joint planning methods, the paper struggles to demonstrate substantial algorithmic contributions beyond mere engineering integration.
-
Experimental validation remains inadequate. The paper only compares against a few demonstration generation methods, lacking thorough comparisons with recent joint planning approaches. Furthermore, the method relies on known scene geometry and task-specific rules, and the real-world experiments cover limited tasks, which is insufficient to fully validate its generalization and practical applicability.
Questions for authors
-
The methodological novelty is weak. What is CroMoGen's core algorithmic innovation compared to existing joint base-arm planning methods? Could direct comparisons with these related methods be provided?
-
Can you provide ablation results that independently remove the contact pose adaptation, joint trajectory planning, and collision repair modules to quantify their respective contributions to the generation success rate?
-
Can you provide planning time distributions and timeout rates across different tasks and robots to evaluate the method's efficiency for large-scale demonstration data generation?
-
The current real-world experiments only cover a cup relocation task using an earlier planner version. Can you provide execution success rates for the final method across a broader range of real-world tasks?
4 comments
Response to reviewer r67n [2/3]
W1, Q1, W2
We thank the reviewer for their constructive feedback. We want to clarify that we are focusing on cross-morphology demonstration synthesis to generate training data for imitation learning models (such as VLA models). To address W1, W2, and Q1, we provide answers from the following perspectives:
I. Research contributions
1) CroMoGen generates a training dataset for a target robot from a human or another robot’s demonstration, without re-collecting data on the target robot. Prior work on demonstration synthesis mostly focuses on cases where the target robot and the demonstration motion source have the same or similar morphologies.
2) Our central question is what to preserve and what to recompute when the source and target morphologies differ. The MimicGen-based baselines and MoMaGen, our closest demonstration-synthesis baselines, reuse demonstrated end-effector motion relative to the object during contact. CroMoGen instead uses demonstrated object motion as the reference and recomputes both the contacts and the coordinated base–arm motion for the target robot, without requiring correspondence between the source and target bodies.
3) Many mobile manipulation methods separate base repositioning from manipulation. CroMoGen jointly replans base and arm motion during object interaction which can be especially important when transferring demonstrations across morphologies.
4) In Appendix A, Table 1, we provide a detailed comparison table for clarifying CroMoGen’s contributions.
CroMoGen advances human-to-robot and robot-to-robot synthesis without requiring joint-to-joint correspondence. We do not claim joint planning, IK, or dynamic programming themselves as new techniques. To clarify contributions, we have updated the introduction.
II. Baseline choices
Because our research problem is to generate a mobile-manipulation dataset for a target robot from a human or another robot’s demonstration, we compare our method with the established demonstration-synthesis methods: MimicGen, WBCMimicGen, and MoMaGen. We are aware that there are methods for humanoid demonstration synthesis, but those methods are specifically designed for humanoids and do not address our full setting, which includes non-humanoid targets.
We also compared CroMoGen with AutoMoMa (CVPR 2026), which generates whole-body mobile manipulation trajectories from task goals without source demonstrations. This compares demonstration retargeting with goal-based planning. On the same 1,587 cases, CroMoGen achieves 62.7% execution success rate versus 38.6% for AutoMoMa, an improvement of 24.1 percentage points (Appendix J.2).
We would also like to receive feedback from the reviewer indicating which baseline methods or planning optimizer alternatives we should consider.
III. Ablation Study of CroMoGen
To motivate each design choice, we added component ablations in Sec. 5.3. We separately disabled the following 4 components of CroMoGen to analyze the performance:
- Repair and refinement: without any repair or frame insertion, 26.2% of all cases succeed with the initial route, compared with 66.6% success rate for the full CroMoGen pipeline.
- Adaptive planning-frame insertion: Disabling frame insertion while retaining collision repair reduces execution success rate from 66.6% to 48.1%.
- Coupled base-arm planning: Decoupling base-arm planning by first planning the base route and then planning the arm motion reduces the success rate from 66.6% to 35.3%.
- Target-specific grasp adaptation: Using the demonstrator’s grasp instead of an adapted grasp reduces the success rate from 56.2% to 10.6% on the cup-task cases.
These results show that each component is important.
IV. Base-arm planner choice of CroMoGen
Our main comparisons evaluate complete demonstration-synthesis methods. We additionally examine our search design using cuRobo, a fast, GPU-accelerated motion-planning framework also used by MoMaGen. We replace parts of our route search with cuRobo-based planners that jointly plan the base and arm (Appendix E.1, Table 5). Averaged over three runs on 80 Spot cup-task cases, CroMoGen achieves 41.2% execution success rate, compared with 15.8%, 23.8%, and 29.6% for cuRobo’s pose planner, cuRobo candidates with greedy selection, and cuRobo candidates with our DP, respectively.
V. Known scene geometry and task-specific rules
Known scene geometry and task-specific contact rules are explicit assumptions of our method, stated in Section 6. These assumptions are consistent with established demonstration-synthesis approaches: MoMaGen also uses ground-truth object poses and geometry, while both MoMaGen and MimicGen use object-centric subtask annotations. These requirements concern data generation. The VLA policies trained on our demonstrations act from camera images and robot state.
Response to reviewer r67n [3/3]
Q2
Can you provide ablation results that independently remove the contact pose adaptation, joint trajectory planning, and collision repair modules to quantify their respective contributions to the generation success rate?
We added component ablations Sec. 5.3 and Appendix E.1, Fig. 9. In the ablation study, we separately disabled the following 4 components:
- Repair and refinement: without any repair or frame insertion, 26.2% of all cases succeed with the initial route, compared to the full CroMoGen pipeline success rate of 66.6%.
- Adaptive planning-frame insertion: Disabling frame insertion while retaining collision repair reduces execution success rate from 66.6% to 48.1%.
- Coupled base–arm planning: We decoupled the base-arm planning by first planning the base route and then planning arm motion. This reduces success rate from 66.6% to 35.3%.
- Target-specific grasp adaptation: Using the demonstrator’s grasp instead of an adapted grasp reduces success rate from 56.2% to 10.6% on the cup-task cases.
These results show that each component is important.
Q3
Can you provide planning time distributions and timeout rates across different tasks and robots to evaluate the method's efficiency for large-scale demonstration data generation?
We have added these details to the paper: Figure 10 in Appendix F reports success rates against planning time for every method, and Table 6 (Appendix F) reports CroMoGen’s median and 90th-percentile planning times and timeout rates for each task and robot. We also compare CroMoGen and the baseline methods’ planning times in Appendix F, showing the tradeoff between planning time and successful demonstration generation.
Q4
The current real-world experiments only cover a cup relocation task using an earlier planner version. Can you provide execution success rates for the final method across a broader range of real-world tasks?
In our original submission the text “On a physical Spot, 12 of 16 selected cup-transport plans from an earlier planner revision succeed” is misleading: the results in the original submission and now also in the revised version are valid. This was an error by us due to rushed writing. We apologize.
Our comparative performance claims rest on the simulation results which are quite comprehensive. We compare with three demonstration generators in five variants: MimicGen, WBCMimicGen and MoMaGen. The last two were published at ICLR 2026. They are designed for robot demonstrations. All methods are compared across 1,587 human-to-robot cases, 720 robot-to-robot cases and 1,191 RoboCasa cases. Between robots, the best retargeting baseline succeeds in 22.5% of the 480 cross-robot cases, and CroMoGen in 70.8%. CroMoGen also runs on all 529 human demonstrations and three robots, 1,587 cases, with 62.7% success rate. For the comparison with joint planners, see our answer to Q1.
Furthermore, the comparisons between our method and baselines in physics simulation utilize friction grasps instead of commonly utilized assisted grasping (Appendix D, including D.1). The purpose of the method is to generate training data, and the revised paper adds policy learning in closed-loop simulation to show the utility of the generated data (Sec. 5.5). For VLA training and evaluation details, see Appendix I.
Thank you for the new ablations and planner comparisons. They address several of my main concerns, so I am raising my rating from 1 to 2. I am not yet confident enough to recommend acceptance.
Response to reviewer r67n [1/3]
We thank the reviewer for their detailed feedback and for recognizing the breadth of our cross-embodiment evaluation and the performance gains over baselines. CroMoGen focuses on cross-morphology demonstration synthesis for mobile manipulation: generating training data for a target robot from human or other-robot demonstrations, without collecting new demonstrations on that robot. Below, we clarify our contributions and baseline choices, including comparisons with demonstration-based generators and AutoMoMa. We present new component ablations (Sec. 5.3), VLA policy-learning experiments (Sec. 5.5), and controlled comparisons with cuRobo-based whole-body planners (Appendix E.1) to substantiate our design choices and evaluate the usefulness of the generated training data. Please see our responses to the weaknesses and questions below.