- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces Temporal Perspective Learning (TPL), an off-policy actor-critic framework that conditions both the actor and critic on a temporal weighting of future rewards. The central premise is that learning a family of policies under diverse temporal perspectives—each emphasizing different reward horizons—can improve the performance of a designated reference policy under standard exponential discounting. To render this tractable, the authors construct a residual-basis mixture family grounded in the residual decomposition of TD(Δ), where each perspective is parameterized by a simplex-valued vector α that recombines short-horizon and incremental-horizon value components. The reference perspective corresponds to the simplex centroid, which exactly recovers the exponential kernel. Training proceeds off-policy: only the reference-conditioned policy interacts with the environment, while all perspectives are trained from a shared replay buffer. Experiments span 24 continuous-control tasks from AdroitHand, DMControl-Hard, and HumanoidBench, with additional integrations into Simba and TD-MPC2, and a preliminary Atari 100k evaluation. Ablations examine the roles of perspective conditioning, mixture family design, and perspective diversity.
Critical strengths
- The paper identifies a genuine limitation of standard discounting—its inability to simultaneously prioritize short-term reactivity and long-term foresight—and proposes a principled mechanism to address it. Conditioning both actor and critic on the temporal weighting, rather than merely reweighting returns under a fixed policy, is a subtle but consequential distinction. This design allows auxiliary perspectives to shape the reference policy through shared parameters, and the residual-basis construction ensures that the reference objective is recovered exactly at the centroid. The theoretical scaffolding in Appendix I, particularly the reference performance bound under policy switching, provides useful intuition even if not fully operationalized.
- The evaluation covers three diverse continuous-control suites with 24 tasks, four seeds per task, and comparisons against SAC, SAC+TD(Δ), CompQ, and MR.Q. The integration experiments with Simba and TD-MPC2 demonstrate that the framework is not tied to a single backbone. The ablation results, while not uniformly conclusive, do indicate that the full TPL configuration outperforms variants lacking perspective conditioning or residual diversity. The reported improvements, particularly on HBench-Periodic and several HumanoidBench tasks, are non-trivial and suggest that the approach captures something beyond noise.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper states that exact prediction of Q_{w_α}^{π_θ^α} does not guarantee monotonic policy improvement when the update is used for non-exponential perspectives, and Appendix I.2 provides a counterexample where greedy improvement fails. This is a material gap: the central mechanism—using recombined residual values to update the actor—lacks a general improvement guarantee, and the paper does not offer an alternative surrogate with theoretical backing.
- Table 1 shows that Full TPL substantially outperforms No conditioning (0.55 vs. 0.30), but this comparison conflates the presence of auxiliary perspectives with the presence of a residual critic architecture and additional parameters. The Homogeneous horizon basis variant, which retains conditioning but removes temporal distinctions among components, scores 0.24—lower than No conditioning—suggesting that the mere existence of multiple components can be detrimental without meaningful temporal separation. However, the paper does not isolate whether the gains stem from temporal diversity per se or from increased model capacity and auxiliary gradient signals.
- MR.Q is included, but other contemporary off-policy algorithms with strong performance on continuous control—such as BRO, QSM, or even well-tuned REDQ variants—are absent. More importantly, the baseline SAC+TD(Δ) is implemented as an off-policy variant by the authors, which may not reflect the original method’s best configuration. The paper reports that TPL uses separate critic heads and adaptive residual bases, and while Table 2 shows these contribute only marginally on HBench-Periodic, the interaction between these design choices and the baseline implementations is not fully disentangled.
- Table 2 indicates that removing both mechanisms reduces HBench-Periodic performance from 0.55 to 0.54—a negligible difference given the confidence intervals. Yet these components add architectural complexity and hyperparameters (e.g., horizon update frequency, dual gradient descent).
- The reported aggregate metrics (Mean HNS 0.793 vs. 0.553 for SAC) are based on a single variant, four seeds, and omit comparison to modern sample-efficient discrete-control methods.
Questions for authors
- The paper acknowledges that the actor surrogate lacks a monotonic improvement guarantee for non-exponential perspectives. Could the authors provide a more detailed characterization of the conditions under which the joint update remains stable? Specifically, does the shared-parameter architecture impose an implicit regularization that mitigates the failure mode in Example I.2, and can this be quantified empirically or theoretically?
- In the ablation of perspective diversity (Figure 4b), performance increases monotonically with λ, the simplex contraction parameter. Does this trend continue beyond λ = 1, i.e., would training with perspectives sampled from a broader distribution than Dirichlet(1) yield further gains, or does the simplex constraint impose a natural ceiling?
- The residual-basis construction requires a sequence of discount factors γ_1 < … < γ_L. The adaptive horizon mechanism adjusts these during training, but the initialization and update frequency are fixed (G = 500). How sensitive is performance to these hyperparameters, and does the adaptive mechanism ever converge to a degenerate grid where one component dominates?
- The comparison against SAC+TD(Δ) uses an off-policy implementation authored by the present authors. Could the authors provide a sanity check against the original TD(Δ) results on a subset of tasks, or at minimum, clarify whether the off-policy adaptation required any hyperparameter tuning that might disadvantage the baseline?
6 comments
Response to Reviewer TSh1 (2/3)
TSh1-3. Controlled Setup for No Conditioning and Comparison with TD(Δ) Implementations
Controlled setup for No conditioning. No conditioning is an ablation that fixes the training perspective to the reference condition while retaining TPL's architecture and all other training settings. Thus, the performance difference from Full TPL is attributable to auxiliary perspective learning, with other factors controlled.
Configuration of SAC+TD(Δ). SAC+TD(Δ) applies the residual decomposition of the original TD(Δ) to SAC's one-step target. It does not incorporate the design components in Appendix A of TPL and uses shared critic heads and a fixed basis, as in the original TD(Δ). To improve learning, we added layer normalization, as in the baseline SAC.
The specific configurations of each baseline and ablation are as follows:
| Component | TPL | No conditioning | SAC+TD(Δ) | PPO+TD(Δ) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perspective training | Diverse conditions | Reference only | Reference only | Reference only |
| Residual critic | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Critic architecture | Separate heads | Separate heads | Shared heads | Shared heads |
| Residual CDQ bias correction | Yes | Yes | No | Not applicable |
| Adaptive basis | Yes | Yes | No | No |
| Training regime | Off-policy | Off-policy | Off-policy | On-policy |
| Number of parameters | 2.5M | 2.5M | 0.7M | 0.02M |
Comparison with the original on-policy configuration. As a sanity check against the original TD(Δ) configuration, we evaluated PPO+TD(Δ), based on the original authors' code, under the same budget of 1M transitions. (4 seeds)
| Method | AdroitHand | DMControl-Hard | HumanoidBench |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAC+TD(Δ) | 0.76 [0.75, 0.78] | 0.55 [0.53, 0.57] | 0.54 [0.52, 0.55] |
| PPO+TD(Δ) | 0.09 [0.06, 0.13] | 0.05 [0.05, 0.06] | 0.05 [0.05, 0.06] |
| PPO+TD(Δ) (0.38M parameters) | 0.07 [0.03, 0.11] | 0.04 [0.04, 0.04] | 0.03 [0.03, 0.04] |
PPO+TD(Δ) performed worse than SAC+TD(Δ) under the same transition budget.
TSh1-4. Effect of Expanding Perspective Diversity with
Following your suggestion, we expanded the perspective sampling range around the reference beyond the simplex ():
In this case, some perspective coefficients can become negative, and the kernel can also take negative values over some intervals.
| HBench-Periodic (3 tasks, 4 seeds) | |
|---|---|
| 0 | 0.30 [0.28, 0.31] |
| 0.25 | 0.40 [0.37, 0.43] |
| 0.5 | 0.45 [0.37, 0.53] |
| 0.75 | 0.48 [0.41, 0.56] |
| 1.0 (default) | 0.55 [0.44, 0.66] |
| 1.25 | 0.55 [0.47, 0.61] |
| 1.5 | 0.60 [0.49, 0.71] |
| 1.75 | 0.37 [0.22, 0.52] |
| 2.0 | 0.27 [0.12, 0.44] |
At and , mean performance was 0.55 and 0.60, respectively, matching or exceeding the original value of 0.55 at . In contrast, performance decreased substantially at . This shows that perspectives outside the simplex, which allow negative , can still be useful for learning, but excessively broad sampling ranges can degrade performance.
We have added the definition of the perspective expansion range and the experimental results to Appendix M of the revised manuscript.
Response to Reviewer TSh1 (3/3)
TSh1-5. Sensitivity of Adaptive Horizons to Update Interval and Initialization
To assess the hyperparameter sensitivity of the adaptive horizons, we varied the update interval and initialization separately.
Update interval. We evaluated values ranging from 10 to 1000. (4 seeds)
| Update interval | HBench-Periodic (3 tasks) |
|---|---|
| 10 | 0.51 [0.45, 0.58] |
| 100 | 0.54 [0.49, 0.60] |
| 500 (default) | 0.55 [0.44, 0.66] |
| 1000 | 0.54 [0.47, 0.60] |
Mean performance remained within the range of 0.51–0.55. This indicates that the adaptive horizons are not highly sensitive to the update interval.
Basis initialization. We replaced the default Doubling initialization () with Tripling () or Linear initialization () and also compared configurations without the adaptive basis.
| Basis initialization | Adaptive basis | HBench-Periodic (3 tasks) |
|---|---|---|
| Doubling (default) | Yes | 0.55 [0.44, 0.66] |
| Tripling | Yes | 0.54 [0.46, 0.62] |
| Tripling | No | 0.41 [0.38, 0.45] |
| Linear | Yes | 0.46 [0.40, 0.51] |
| Linear | No | 0.42 [0.34, 0.50] |
Tripling achieved a mean performance of 0.54, similar to the default Doubling result of 0.55, while Linear achieved a lower mean of 0.46. Using the adaptive basis increased mean performance from 0.41 to 0.54 for Tripling and from 0.42 to 0.46 for Linear.
Grid convergence. The grids converged to different configurations depending on the environment, and no degenerate grids were observed. These differences across environments are also reflected in the kernel mass results for one-hot perspectives in Response to Reviewer nBbP-1.
The adaptive basis is designed to reduce the need for manual horizon tuning and regulate learning signals across residual components. The results above on update intervals and grid convergence support the practical stability of this adaptive configuration.
We have incorporated the update interval and initialization experiments into Appendix J.4, and the grid convergence and kernel mass diagnostics into Appendix J.3 of the revised manuscript.
TSh1-6. Comparisons with Recent Algorithms
The original continuous control comparisons focused on multi-horizon prediction and auxiliary learning methods. In Section 5.6, we instead evaluated the benefits of incorporating TPL into recent methods, namely Simba and TD-MPC2.
Direct comparisons on continuous control. To strengthen the direct comparisons with recent algorithms, we present additional results for BRO[1] and QSM[2], obtained using their official code, alongside the Simba and TD-MPC2 results included in the manuscript. (4 seeds)
| Method | HBench-Periodic (3 tasks) |
|---|---|
| TPL | 0.55 [0.44, 0.66] |
| Mr.Q | 0.32 [0.30, 0.33] |
| Simba | 0.43 [0.41, 0.45] |
| TD-MPC2 | 0.40 [0.36, 0.45] |
| BRO | 0.31 [0.29, 0.34] |
| QSM | 0.07 [0.06, 0.09] |
- For BRO, we evaluated the version with 2.6M total trainable parameters (the 1.14M-parameter critic version in the paper) and the default replay ratio of 10.
- For QSM, we followed the official implementation and hyperparameters.
TPL achieved higher mean performance than the additional baselines, demonstrating its competitiveness in direct comparisons with recent algorithms.
Atari-100k comparisons. The Atari-100k results in the original Appendix K are a preliminary evaluation of applicability to environments with image observations and discrete actions, and their performance is lower than that of recent methods. The table below presents the aggregate human-normalized scores (HNS) from our existing evaluation, together with the published results for SPR, SR-SPR, and BBF reported in Table A.1 of the BBF paper [3].
| Method | Mean HNS | Median HNS | IQM HNS |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAC | 0.553 | 0.186 | 0.237 |
| SAC+TPL | 0.793 | 0.232 | 0.390 |
| SPR | 0.616 | 0.396 | 0.337 |
| SR-SPR | 1.272 | 0.685 | 0.631 |
| BBF | 2.247 | 0.917 | 1.045 |
In Appendix O of the revised manuscript, we have added the published results for SPR, SR-SPR, and BBF to enable comparisons of both aggregate metrics and per-game results.
We thank you again for your valuable feedback. We would be happy to provide further clarification or address any additional questions you may have.
References
[1] Michal Nauman, Mateusz Ostaszewski, Krzysztof Jankowski, Piotr Miłoś, and Marek Cygan. “Bigger, Regularized, Optimistic: Scaling for Compute and Sample-Efficient Continuous Control.” NeurIPS, 2024.
[2] Michael Psenka, Alejandro Escontrela, Pieter Abbeel, and Yi Ma. “Learning a Diffusion Model Policy from Rewards via Q-Score Matching.” ICML, 2024.
[3] Max Schwarzer, Johan Samir Obando Ceron, Aaron Courville, Marc G. Bellemare, Rishabh Agarwal, and Pablo Samuel Castro. “Bigger, Better, Faster: Human-level Atari with human-level efficiency.” ICML, 2023.
Response to Reviewer TSh1 (1/3)
We sincerely thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback. Below, we address your key concerns through additional experiments and analyses that further clarify the strengths and limitations of TPL.
TSh1-1. Learning Stability of Non-Exponential Temporal Perspectives
TPL aims to improve reference policy learning by jointly learning diverse perspectives within a shared model, rather than guaranteeing individual policy improvement for each non-exponential temporal perspective. Our current analysis has not established a useful theoretical property showing that this shared structure alleviates the policy improvement issue for individual perspectives. Instead, we empirically analyzed whether the joint update used in practice is compatible with improving the reference objective.
In Response to Reviewer YTjr-1, we analyzed gradient alignment for individual perspectives and their one-step transfer to the reference actor loss. Although negative transfer was observed for some perspectives far from the reference, the gradient of the full P(α) mixture had cosine similarities of 0.78 and 0.90 with the reference gradient at the 200k and 1M checkpoints, respectively, with a conflict rate of 0% at both checkpoints. Furthermore, after applying actor updates of the same magnitude, the reference actor loss measured on a separate evaluation batch decreased by 1.01 [0.71, 1.30] and 0.71 [0.37, 0.99].
These results do not guarantee monotonic policy improvement for individual non-exponential perspectives or the general stability of joint training. However, they provide empirical evidence that, even when some perspectives produce negative gradients, the overall update combined according to the actual training distribution acts to reduce the reference actor loss. This supports TPL's design, which targets improved reference performance through joint learning rather than individual improvement of auxiliary perspectives.
TSh1-2. A Modified Objective with a Policy Improvement Guarantee for Non-Exponential Temporal Perspectives
Original TPL jointly learns policies with each perspective held fixed. Under a non-exponential kernel, the relative weights assigned to the remaining rewards change over time, so an actor update based on value evaluation at a fixed perspective may not yield policy improvement. As an alternative that addresses this issue, we present a modified objective in which the perspective shifts over time, together with a policy improvement guarantee.
Shifted-perspective variant. Motivated by the reviewer's question, we revisited the structure of the residual kernel and found that a kernel shifted by one step can also be represented within the same family of residual basis mixtures: wα(t+1)=s(α)wF(α)(t). Here, F(α) is the perspective shifted by one step, and s(α) is a scale factor. Following this transformation, we change the conditioning of the bootstrapped next Q-value in the residual TD target of Eq. (14) from
\quad\longrightarrow\quad \widehat Q_{\bar{ψ}}^{(ℓ)}(s',a',F(α)),$$ and sample the next action from $a'∼π_θ^{F(α)}(·∣ s')$. The critic therefore evaluates a policy whose perspective shifts over time as follows, and the modified objective is formulated to maximize the return of this shifting policy: $$α_{t+1}=F(α_t), \qquad a_t∼π_θ^{α_t}(·∣ s_t).$$ **Policy improvement guarantee.** Under the reward-only formulation in the main text, combining an exact critic with exact greedy improvement at every state–perspective pair ensures that the shifted-policy return evaluated under the initial kernel does not decrease. Consequently, the mixture objective obtained by averaging this return over initial states and perspectives is also non-decreasing. **Experimental results.** We compared the two methods on the three HBench-Periodic tasks using the same training budget. (4 seeds) | Method | HBench-Periodic (3 tasks) | | --- | ---: | | Original TPL | 0.55 [0.44, 0.66] | | Shifted-perspective variant | 0.48 [0.40, 0.57] | The shifted variant had a lower observed mean, and the reported intervals overlapped. This variant provides a construction with a policy improvement guarantee under the conditions stated above and may facilitate extensions to deterministic policies or discrete action spaces. TPL focuses on jointly learning policies for **fixed** temporal perspectives to capture the differences among perspectives. In contrast, this variant evaluates and improves policies whose internal perspectives gradually converge toward the reference perspective over time. Analyzing how this difference in objectives affects the final reference policy, and exploring ways to combine the two formulations for more effective transfer to the reference, are interesting directions for future work. We have added the shifted-perspective objective, policy improvement theorem, proof, and experimental results to **Appendix N** of the revised manuscript.