acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TAIRL: Optimizing Multi-Turn Open-Ended Dialogue via Temporal Patterns in Human Feedback

Abstract

Multi-turn open-ended dialogue (MOD) is a core scenario in human-machine interaction, where subjective factors such as emotion, interest, knowledge, and topic shift play a decisive role in dialogue quality. However, many interactive reinforcement learning (RL) methods use human feedback as turn-level scalar supervision, leaving its temporal structure underexplored. Motivated by an empirical analysis of human feedback in financial-domain MOD, we propose TAIRL, a temporal-aware interactive RL framework that models three recurring feedback patterns: turn-point concentration, asymmetric timing, and adaptive frequency. TAIRL operationalizes these patterns through TW, ALR, and AER. In an offline-feedback-driven simulator trained from 4,287 real human feedback samples, TAIRL reduces simulator convergence turns by 36–45% and improves sample efficiency by approximately 50% over several RL baselines. On held-out human-evaluated financial dialogues with Qwen2.5-7B, TAIRL-enhanced methods also improve final task success and user-experience metrics, including a 22.8% relative improvement in user satisfaction and a 56% relative improvement in emotional alignment. The proposed mechanisms are lightweight and can be integrated into PPO, GRPO, REINFORCE, and TAMER-style interactive learning. These results suggest that temporal feedback structure is a useful design signal for improving interactive RL in MOD, while broader cross-domain validation remains an important direction for future work. The code and data are available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/TAIRL-2957.

Primary area:
alignment, fairness, safety, privacy, and societal considerations
Keywords:
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback, Temporal Feedback Patterns, Interactive Reinforcement Learning, Multi-Turn Dialogue, Policy Optimization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_4LWeOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TAIRL, a temporal-aware interactive reinforcement learning framework for multi-turn open-ended dialogue. The authors analyze human feedback in financial-domain dialogues and identify three temporal patterns: turn-point concentration, asymmetric feedback timing, and adaptive feedback frequency. Based on these observations, the paper introduces three mechanisms: temporally-guided dynamic weighting (TDW), which emphasizes feedback near dialogue state transitions; asymmetric learning rate (ALR), which assigns larger update coefficients to negative feedback; and adaptive experience replay (AER), which prioritizes experiences collected during low-performance periods or important state transitions. The proposed framework is integrated with several existing RL methods, including PPO, GRPO, REINFORCE, and TAMER. Experiments are conducted on four dialogue datasets covering financial, medical, and home-service scenarios. Using a feedback simulator trained on real human annotations and a held-out human evaluation set, the authors report improvements in task success, learning efficiency, training stability, and user experience.

Critical strengths
  1. Meaningful research motivation based on human feedback patterns. The paper investigates temporal characteristics of human feedback that may be overlooked when feedback is treated only as a scalar reward. The empirical analysis of feedback concentration, response delay, and frequency provides a useful perspective on improving learning from human interactions. This is important because feedback timing and dialogue state transitions may contain useful information beyond the numerical reward value, especially in multi-turn interactions.
  2. Modular framework with promising empirical results. TAIRL is designed to integrate with several existing policy optimization algorithms without replacing their underlying optimization frameworks. The proposed mechanisms are relatively lightweight and can potentially be applied to different interactive RL settings. The experiments report improvements across multiple algorithms, language models, and dialogue datasets. The inclusion of ablation studies and held-out human evaluations further strengthens the empirical investigation.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited evidence for the specific benefits of temporal modeling and the claimed synergy between components. Although the three mechanisms are motivated by temporal patterns in human feedback, their implementations primarily involve gradient weighting and prioritized experience replay. In particular, ALR assigns different update coefficients according to feedback polarity, but does not directly incorporate the observed feedback delay. Therefore, it is unclear whether its improvement comes from exploiting temporal characteristics or simply from assigning larger weights to negative feedback. Furthermore, TDW, ALR, and AER appear to be relatively independent optimization mechanisms. Although AER incorporates temporal weights from TDW, the current leave-one-out ablation studies do not fully establish whether their combination produces benefits beyond those of independently effective weighting strategies. Since exploiting temporal feedback patterns and combining the three mechanisms are central contributions of the paper, stronger evidence is needed to distinguish their specific contributions from conventional feedback re-weighting and experience prioritization.
  2. Insufficient clarity and consistency in the experimental methodology and reported results. Several experimental details make it difficult to fully assess the reliability of the reported improvements. First, Table 9 reports the same FP and LS values for GRPO+AER as Table 3 reports for the complete TAIRL framework. However, Table 3 also shows substantial performance degradation when TDW or ALR is removed. The relationship between these configurations requires clarification. Second, Section 4.1 describes simulator-based training over 2,000–3,000 interaction turns, while some learning-speed results in Table 1 exceed this range. The experimental protocol used to obtain these convergence measurements is unclear. Finally, Appendix F describes a reward model predicting feedback from state-action pairs, while Appendix F.2 reports a time-shuffling experiment intended to demonstrate the importance of temporal structure. The manuscript does not sufficiently explain how the temporal information is represented or how shuffling time indices affects the simulator. These issues are consequential because the experimental evidence is central to the paper's claims regarding learning efficiency and temporal feedback modeling.
Questions for authors
  1. Regarding the ALR mechanism and temporal modeling: Since ALR depends on feedback polarity rather than the actual feedback delay, can the authors clarify what additional benefit is obtained from modeling temporal feedback patterns compared with a fixed negative-feedback weighting baseline? Additionally, can the authors clarify whether ALR is implemented through optimizer learning rates, per-sample loss weighting, or reward/advantage scaling in PPO and GRPO?
  2. Regarding component contributions and experimental consistency: Does GRPO+AER in Table 9 use only the AER mechanism? If so, why does it achieve the same reported performance as full TAIRL? Could the authors clarify this configuration and provide component-wise comparisons that better distinguish the individual contributions and interactions of TDW, ALR, and AER?
  3. Regarding the feedback simulator and training protocol: How are feedback timing and temporal ordering represented in the reward simulator? In particular, how does permuting time indices affect simulator training when the state-action-feedback triples remain unchanged? Could the authors also explain how convergence-turn measurements exceeding the stated 2,000–3,000 training turns were obtained?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer3

We thank the Reviewer for the rigorous examination. All revisions are in the revised manuscript.

W1: Temporal Modeling Evidence & Synergy

(1) ALR vs. Conventional Re-weighting: We clarify that while ALR itself does not directly encode continuous delay seconds, it models the asymmetric temporal strategy (instant correction vs. delayed confirmation). We acknowledge that ALR in isolation is algebraically equivalent to sign-based re-weighting (w_attn=1 → fixed 10× on negative samples). Its temporal awareness emerges only through coupling with TDW (Eq. 11): α(r)·w_attn(t)·∇logπ. Negative feedback inside vs. outside the switching window receives different magnitudes (α⁻×β_in vs. α⁻×β_out). This "knowing when to amplify" is the essence of the framework, distinguishing it from static cost-sensitive learning. We therefore frame TDW/ALR/AER as a unified temporal framework rather than three independent modules.

(2) Synergy evidence (Table 3): Conventional Static Weighting (fixed 10×, no TDW/AER) achieves only 73.20%, far below Full TAIRL (79.83%). Note that w/o TDW (Static 10×+AER) = 73.61% is close to Static Weighting (73.20%), confirming AER contributes minimally without TDW (+0.41pp); its value emerges through cross-stage transmission (TDW→AER via w_attn in Eq. 14), yielding +5.31pp when combined. vs. PER: GRPO+PER (TD-error) = 74.21% (Table 12).

Table 3 (updated). D3, GRPO base.

ConfigurationFPLSSESB
Full TAIRL79.83%1.0k9.2%/k1.20%
w/o TDW (Static 10×+AER)73.61%1.4k8.2%/k1.31%
w/o ALR72.83%1.8k7.5%/k1.52%
w/o AER74.52%1.2k7.0%/k1.23%
Conventional Static Weighting73.20%1.5k7.8%/k1.45%
GRPO (all w/o)71.51%1.8k6.0%/k1.79%

W2: Experimental Consistency

(1) (1) Table 9 data overlap: This was a copy-paste typo; the row contained Full TAIRL data mislabeled as "GRPO+AER." We have corrected this. As shown in the revised Table 12 below, the "AER-only" configuration (w/o TDW, w/o ALR) achieves 74.10%, which is comparable to GRPO+PER (74.21%). This confirms that AER alone acts as a standard prioritized replay. The true synergy emerges only in Full TAIRL (79.83%).

(2) LS > 3k turns: Text inconsistency corrected. The actual max budget is 5,000 turns (most TAIRL variants converge within 1.0–2.3k turns; some baselines require up to 4.7k turns). Section 4.1 is updated to reflect this exact protocol; all Table 1 data verified against logs.

(3) Time-shuffling ( Appendix. F): Permutation is applied to training pairs before RM training, corrupting the (s,a)→r supervised mapping. We acknowledge this introduces an RM-quality confound and report shuffled-RM sign accuracy = 81.2% (vs. 87.6% original). To isolate temporal structure from RM degradation, we compare the differential effect: GRPO (no w_attn/AER) is barely affected (−0.31pp), while TAIRL drops 7.63pp,proving TAIRL specifically exploits temporal alignment. Temporal info is implicit (chronological feedback order + state context, not explicit timestamps); permuting r_t destroys critical-window alignment.

Table 12 (corrected). D3 head-to-head.

MethodFP (%)LS (k)SB (%)
GRPO+PER (TD-error)74.211.51.40
GRPO+AER only (w/o TDW, w/o ALR)74.101.41.38
Full TAIRL79.831.01.20

Table 15 (time-shuffle control). D3.

ConfigurationFP (%)LS (k)SE (%/k)SB (%)
GRPO (original simulator)71.511.86.01.79
GRPO (shuffled simulator)71.201.85.91.80
Full TAIRL (original simulator)79.831.09.21.20
Full TAIRL (shuffled simulator)72.201.76.32.10

Questions

Q1: Static Weighting baseline (73.20% vs 79.83%) proves temporal localization matters. ALR = per-sample loss weighting (not optimizer LR / reward scaling). Multiplier stopgrad(w_attn·α) applies to unmodified 𝓛ᵢ: 𝓛ᵢᴾᴾᴼ = min(ρᵢAᵢ, clip(ρᵢ,1−ε,1+ε)Aᵢ); 𝓛ᵢᴳᴿᴾᴼ = ρᵢÃᵢ. Not applied to ρᵢ or Aᵢ.

Q2: "GRPO+AER" was a typo (Full TAIRL data mislabeled). Table 12 (revised). AER isolation on D3.

MethodFP (%)LS (k)SB (%)
GRPO+PER (TD-error priority)74.211.51.40
GRPO+AER only (w/o TDW, w/o ALR)74.101.41.38
Full TAIRL (TDW+ALR+AER)79.831.01.20

Q3: (1) Temporal info = chronological order + context; no explicit timestamps. (2) Permuting r_t before RM training corrupts (s,a)→r mapping (shuffled-RM accuracy = 81.2%); differential GRPO vs. TAIRL effect isolates temporal-structure dependence. (3) Max budget = 5,000 turns (corrected in §4.1).

All revisions are in the revised PDF.

Reviewer_k3HWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes TAIRL, a framework for improving multi-turn dialogue reinforcement learning by exploiting temporal patterns in human feedback. An analysis of 4,287 financial-domain feedback instances identifies concentration around dialogue-state transitions, shorter delays for negative feedback, and increased feedback frequency when model performance is poor. These observations motivate temporally guided dynamic weighting, asymmetric learning rates, and adaptive experience replay. The framework is evaluated with several RL algorithms across four datasets and multiple language models, with training primarily conducted through a reward-model-based simulator. The authors report improved simulator-based learning efficiency and held-out task performance and interaction quality, supported by ablations and temporal-control experiments.

Critical strengths
  1. Relevant motivation and practical method design. The paper investigates whether human feedback contains useful information beyond its scalar value, an important question for multi-turn interaction. Translating feedback patterns into lightweight weighting and replay mechanisms provides a potentially practical approach to improving learning with limited feedback.

  2. Useful attempts to isolate the proposed mechanisms. Component ablations and comparisons with equal-density random or shifted windows help investigate whether accurate transition localization matters beyond generic gradient amplification. Separating simulator-based efficiency measurements from held-out human evaluation is also appropriate. These experiments provide potentially meaningful evidence, subject to the methodological concerns below.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The method is insufficiently specified and its interpretation is internally inconsistent. “Topic blocking,” a required component of Eq. (3), is not defined, and the semantic-change and emotion-reversal indicators lack sufficient implementation details. Although Eq. (3) connects to gradient weighting through the transition windows, the causal handling of previously processed turns is unclear. The main text describes LLM optimization, whereas Appendix F identifies the policy network as a small MLP, leaving the actual training architecture uncertain.

The mapping from observed patterns to algorithmic mechanisms also needs justification. ALR uses feedback sign rather than delay, so the “correct now, confirm later” interpretation does not establish the chosen update ratio. The descriptions of learning rate versus reward/advantage scaling conflict. AER changes replay frequency rather than feedback frequency, and its combination with ALR is not consistently represented in the equations. These issues prevent a reproducible understanding of what is implemented and what explains the gains.

  1. The validation does not yet reliably establish the claimed benefits. The time-shuffle experiment changes time indices while preserving the reward model’s stated input–target pairs, which should leave its supervised objective unchanged. The reported performance change therefore requires clarification, and the missing shuffled-GRPO baseline prevents a controlled comparison. The scalar reward predictor also does not explain how feedback timing and frequency are simulated.

D3/D4 lack sufficient provenance and construction details, while the evaluation inconsistently refers to 800 turns and 800 dialogues. SE lacks a precise counting protocol, and several interaction-score formulas conflict with reported score ranges. The convergence analysis additionally contains substantive problems involving the step-size conditions, the parameter-dependent surrogate distribution, and the replay-bias bound. Together, these concerns substantially limit confidence in the performance and theoretical claims.

Questions for authors
  1. State-shift detection and its effect on learning: What exactly does “topic blocking” mean, and how is its indicator computed? Please specify the models, inputs, and thresholds for all three signals in Eq. (3), including whether “similarity drop” means low absolute similarity or a relative decrease. How do detected transitions determine the weights used in actual updates, particularly for earlier turns included in the symmetric window?

  2. Is “correct now, confirm later” supported by external literature, or is it the authors’ interpretation of their own observations? What evidence connects shorter negative-feedback delays to the selected asymmetric update ratio?

  3. At which stage does AER operate, and does it adapt feedback acquisition or only reuse previously collected feedback? How is the required per-turn success signal obtained? Please explain how TDW, ALR, and AER combine in the implemented update, whether ALR applies to replayed samples, and why priority is used both for sampling and gradient weighting.

  4. Beyond the general attribution to a securities firm, how were D3/D4 collected and constructed? Please specify collection dates, dialogue participants, task labels, dataset sizes in both dialogues and turns, and train/test splitting protocols. For stock prediction, how is future-information leakage prevented?

  5. What information or process actually changes when time indices are shuffled, given that the reward model reportedly receives only state and action? How does this destroy temporal structure while retaining complete dialogue contexts? Please provide the corresponding GRPO result on the shuffled simulator and explain how the simulator generates feedback delays and variable feedback counts.

  6. Why was Qwen2.5-7B selected as the primary backbone rather than a newer Qwen model, especially given that Qwen3-1.7B is included in the model comparison? Please clarify the model-selection rationale and whether the existing results demonstrate improvements over each model’s corresponding unenhanced baseline.

  7. Could you update the manuscript template from ICLR 2026 to ICLR 2027?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer2

We thank the Reviewer for the rigorous examination. All issues are addressed in the revised manuscript.

W1:

(1) Indicators & Causal Handling (Appendix. B.2):

  • I_sim: Sentence-BERT cosine sim(s_{t−1}, s_t) < θ_sim = 0.6 — absolute threshold, not relative decrease.
  • I_emo: RoBERTa sentiment polarity flip between consecutive turns.
  • I_topic (topic blocking): NLI model detects conversational breakdown (refusal or semantic contradiction) ,narrower than "topic shift"; clarified in revised text.
  • Retrospective window: W_k = [t_k−2, t_k+2]. Past turns t_k−2, t_k−1 are buffered; w_attn assigned retroactively upon detecting t_k, applied in next AER cycle. Strictly causal.

(2) Architecture: Policy = Qwen2.5-7B + LoRA (LLM). The 2-layer MLP is only the reward simulator (Appendix. F).

(3) ALR & Pattern Mapping: ALR = per-sample loss weighting (not optimizer LR / reward scaling). 𝕂=10 from grid search (Table 10). The 3.2s/0.8s delay empirically justifies the directionality (negative→faster); the specific magnitude factor 𝕂=10 is determined via grid search independently. Table 10. Hyperparameters (all models, no per-model tuning).

SymbolDescriptionValueSearch Range
α₀Base LR0.01{0.005, 0.01, 0.02}
𝕂Asymmetry coefficient10.0{5, 10, 15}
εNeutral decay1.0{0.5, 0.8, 1.0}
τDiscretization threshold0{0, 0.1, 0.5}
β_in / β_outWindow weights3.0 / 0.3{1–4} / {0.1, 0.3, 0.5}
λ / χ / γ₂Replay / exp. / temp.0.5 / 0.6 / 1.0{0.1–1} / {0.4–0.8} / {0.5–2}

**(4) AER & Unified Formula: AER adjusts replay frequency (corrected from "feedback frequency"). ALR applies to replayed samples via the same multiplier. Priority serves dual role (sampling + gradient weighting). Unified update (Eq. 18):

𝓛ᵀᴬᴵᴿᴸ_PPO/GRPO = (1 / |𝓑|) · Σᵢ∈𝓑 stopgrad(wattn(tᵢ) · α(rᵢʰᵘᵐᵃⁿ)) · 𝓛ᵢ_PPO/GRPO + β · 𝓛_KL

AER priority: w_sample(e) = exp(−γ₂·p_te)·w_attn(t_e)

W2:

**(1) Shuffle logic (clarified): Permutation is applied to training pairs before RM training, corrupting the (s,a)→r supervised mapping. We acknowledge this introduces an RM-quality confound and report shuffled-RM sign accuracy = 81.2% (vs. 87.6% original), confirming moderate degradation. However, the differential effect isolates temporal structure: GRPO (no w_attn/AER) is barely affected (−0.31pp), while TAIRL drops 7.63pp,proving that TAIRL specifically exploits temporal alignment, not merely RM quality.

(2) Shuffled-GRPO baseline (Table 15):

ConfigurationFP (%)LS (k)SE (%/k)SB (%)
GRPO (original simulator)71.511.86.01.79
GRPO (shuffled simulator)71.201.85.91.80
Full TAIRL (original simulator)79.831.09.21.20
Full TAIRL (shuffled simulator)72.201.76.32.10

GRPO minimally affected (−0.31pp); TAIRL drops 7.63pp — confirms temporal-structure dependence.

**(3) Simulator: Two components: RM Predictor (MLP: (s_t,a_t)→polarity) + Environment Trigger (replays real timestamps, controlling activation timing/frequency) (Appendix. F).

W3:

(1) D3/D4 & evaluation units: D3/D4 from anonymized securities-firm logs (Appendix. B.1). Standardized to "800 held-out evaluation dialogues" (200 per dataset, each a complete episode).

(2) SE protocol: Feedback(k) = Environment Trigger activations (in thousands), one per trigger event (Appendix. F).

(3) Scores: Raw [0,1] → display [0,10] via Score_display = 10×Score_raw. ICC on 4 subjective dimensions only (4×800×4 = 12,800 ratings); 3 objective dimensions are automatic. ICC tables updated.

(4) Convergence (Appendix. C revised): (i) Fixed-LR gap acknowledged; heuristic sketch. (ii) stopgrad freezes local gradient flow; claim weakened to "local stationary points." (iii) Weight clipping added: C_IS ≤ ½MG_maxR_max; "non-convex behavior under bounded bias."

Questions

Q1: See W1(1). θ_sim = 0.6 (absolute). Buffering handles past turns in symmetric window.

Q2: "Correct now, confirm later" = our qualitative observation (0.8s vs 3.2s delays). 𝕂 = 10 from grid search; delays support directionality only.

Q3: AER operates in offline replay. p_t = binary success indicator from environment. ALR applies to replayed samples via same multiplier. Dual-purpose priority concentrates updates on high-value samples.

Q4:We have added the full construction details to Appendix B.3.

Q5: See W2. Shuffling corrupts RM training targets. GRPO result in Table 15. Timing via Environment Trigger replaying real timestamps.

Q6: We chose Qwen2.5-7B because its ecosystem (e.g., vLLM, LoRA support) is highly stable for large-scale RLHF. We further validated on 8 models across different families and scales to prove our method's generalizability (Table 2). Table 2 compares each model against its own unenhanced baseline.

Q7: Updated to official ICLR 2027 template.

Reviewer_ERUrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the limited use of temporal information in human feedback for multi-turn open-ended dialogue. The authors propose TAIRL, a temporal-aware interactive reinforcement learning framework. Based on financial dialogue feedback, the authors identify three patterns: turn-point concentration, asymmetric timing, and adaptive frequency. These motivate three mechanisms: temporally-guided dynamic weighting, an asymmetric learning rate, and adaptive experience replay, which can be integrated into several reinforcement learning algorithms. The experiments cover four datasets and eight models, combining training in a simulator built from real human feedback with held-out human evaluation. Ablation studies, time-shuffle controls, and window perturbations assess the mechanisms’ contributions. The reported results show improvements in task success, simulator-based learning efficiency, and user experience. The main contribution is translating temporal feedback patterns into pluggable training mechanisms, while effectiveness in real online learning and broader generalization remain to be established.

Critical strengths
  1. Research Background: The paper addresses feedback timing, emotional changes, and user interventions in multi-turn dialogue, making the research practically relevant.
  2. Method: The three modules proposed in TAIRL are pluggable, intuitive, and lightweight. They address feedback location, feedback type, and historical sample selection, respectively, making them easy to integrate into industrial application frameworks.
  3. Experiments: The experimental evaluation is extensive, covering multiple algorithms and eight models, with relevant baselines such as PER. It also includes ablations of all three modules, time-shuffle controls, and window perturbation experiments.
Critical weaknesses
  1. I noticed that the paper uses the ICLR 2026 template rather than the ICLR 2027 template. In addition, the authors appear to have modified the template’s formatting, particularly the line spacing.
  2. The description of ALR is inconsistent. Lines 281–283 state that asymmetric factors are applied to rewards or advantages, whereas lines 840–847 explicitly describe learning-rate adjustment instead of reward/advantage scaling. The actual implementation needs clarification to ensure reproducibility.
  3. The gains attributed to AER are unclear. All three metrics for “GRPO+AER” in Table 9 exactly match those of full TAIRL in Table 3. The authors should clarify whether TDW and ALR were also used, as this affects whether the gains can be attributed to AER alone.

If these concerns are adequately addressed, I would consider raising my score.

Questions for authors

I have no specific questions.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer1

We thank the Reviewer for the constructive comments. All revisions are in the revised PDF.

W1: Template & Formatting

The reviewer is correct. We re-compiled using the official ICLR 2027 template with pristine .sty files, restoring all default formatting. No local spacing modifications remain.

W2: Inconsistent ALR Description

This was a writing error. The implementation is a per-sample multiplier on the policy-loss term, not reward/advantage scaling. For each sample i:

α(r) = α₀·𝕂 (r=−1); α₀ (r=+1); α₀·ε (r=0)

The loss is multiplied by stopgrad(wattn(tᵢ)·α(rᵢ)). PPO clipping and KL remain unchanged; for GRPO, group-normalized advantage is computed first. Not equivalent to reward scaling: for PPO/GRPO the multiplier acts after normalization/clipping, preserving the KL constraint. Updated Eq. (18,38,,39):

𝓛ᵀᴬᴵᴿᴸ_PPO/GRPO = (1 / |𝓑|) · Σᵢ∈𝓑 stopgrad(wattn(tᵢ) · α(rᵢʰᵘᵐᵃⁿ)) · 𝓛ᵢ_PPO/GRPO + β · 𝓛_KL

where 𝓛ᵢᴾᴾᴼ = min(ρᵢAᵢ, clip(ρᵢ,1−ε,1+ε)Aᵢ); 𝓛ᵢᴳᴿᴾᴼ = ρᵢÃᵢ, Ãᵢ = (Aᵢ−mean_𝓖)/std_𝓖. (a) τ and main results. All main experimental results use τ = 0 (pure sign discretization). Table 10 (hyperparameters) is corrected to τ=0.

(b) ε in discrete setting. When r=0, the gradient vanishes regardless of α⁰; ε is meaningful for continuous-feedback extensions. Grid search confirms insensitivity (ε=1.0).

For reproducibility, we add three new tables in Appendix C.5 (the τ ablation, KL regularizer ablation, and Hyperparameter tables):

Table 8 (new). τ ablation (D3, GRPO, Qwen2.5-7B).

ConfigurationFP (%)LS (k)SE (%/k)SB (%)
GRPO (baseline)71.511.86.01.79
GRPO+TAIRL (τ=0, final)79.831.09.21.20
GRPO+TAIRL (τ=0.1)79.451.19.01.22
GRPO+TAIRL (τ=0.5)77.501.38.51.35

Table 9 (new). KL regularizer ablation (D3, GRPO, Qwen2.5-7B).

ConfigurationFP (%)LS (k)SE (%/k)SB (%)
GRPO (baseline)71.511.86.01.79
GRPO+TAIRL (KL unchanged)79.831.09.21.20
GRPO+TAIRL (KL scaled by α)78.421.28.61.45

Table 10 (new). Hyperparameters (identical across all eight LLMs).

SymbolDescriptionValueSearch Range
α₀Base LR0.01{0.005, 0.01, 0.02}
𝕂Asymmetry coefficient10.0{5, 10, 15}
εNeutral decay1.0{0.5, 0.8, 1.0}
τDiscretization threshold0{0, 0.1, 0.5}
β_in / β_outIntra/extra-window weight3.0 / 0.3{1,2,3,4} / {0.1,0.3,0.5}
λ / χ / γ₂Replay / priority exp. / temp.0.5 / 0.6 / 1.0{0.1,0.5,1} / {0.4,0.6,0.8} / {0.5,1,2}

W3: Unclear Gains Attributed to AER

Accepted. The row was a copy-paste typo containing Full TAIRL data mislabeled. We correct Table 12 (revised,formerly Table 9, now in Appendix E.2) and add GRPO+AER-only.

AER-only implementation: With w_attn=1, the priority reduces to exp(−γ₂·p_t) — a performance-adaptive criterion distinct from PER's TD-error. AER's design intent is to complement TDW via cross-stage transmission of w_attn into replay priorities (Eq. 14).

Table 12 (revised). AER isolation on D3.

MethodFP (%)LS (k)SB (%)
GRPO+PER (TD-error priority)74.211.51.40
GRPO+AER only (w/o TDW, w/o ALR)74.101.41.38
Full TAIRL (TDW+ALR+AER)79.831.01.20

Isolated AER performs comparably to PER (74.10 vs 74.21), as both are prioritized-replay variants. The key finding is the 5.73pp gap to Full TAIRL: temporal synergy, not any single replay mechanism, is the primary driver. Removing AER from the full framework (Table 3 below: w/o AER = 74.52%) confirms consistent contribution.

Table 3 (main ablation, unchanged). D3, GRPO base.

ConfigurationFP (%)LS (k)SE (%/k)SB (%)
Full TAIRL79.831.09.21.20
w/o TDW (Static 10×+AER)73.611.48.21.31
w/o ALR72.831.87.51.52
w/o AER74.521.27.01.23
Conventional Static Weighting (10×)73.201.57.81.45
GRPO (all w/o)71.511.86.01.79

Note: ALR with w_attn≡1 is algebraically equivalent to static 10× weighting (73.61 vs 73.20 confirms this); its temporal awareness arises from coupling with TDW.

Text revision (Appendix. E.2): "As shown in Table 12, the Full TAIRL framework outperforms GRPO+PER by 5.62 percentage points in FP and converges 1.5× faster. Note that the isolated gain of AER is detailed in Table 2 (Ablation Study), where removing AER from the full framework (w/o AER) results in a performance drop to 74.52%..."

All corrections are in the revised PDF.

Thank you for addressing my comments and correcting the template. The revised equations clarify where ALR applies its per-sample weight in the policy loss. The corrected AER ablation also resolves my concern about the duplicated results. On D3, AER alone performs comparably to PER, while removing AER from the full framework reduces performance. This gives me a clearer picture of AER’s contribution within TAIRL.

These revisions largely address the specific issues I raised. My remaining reservation concerns the scope of the evidence. The held-out human evaluation supports the reported improvements in user experience, while the gains in learning efficiency have been demonstrated only in simulation. It remains unclear how well those gains carry over to online learning from live human feedback. On balance, I maintain my rating of 2.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer1-2

We sincerely thank the Reviewer for the fair and constructive assessment. We are glad that the revised equations and corrected AER ablation have clarified the main concerns.

Regarding the remaining reservation on simulator-based learning efficiency vs. live human feedback, we appreciate this insightful perspective. As the Reviewer rightly notes, the paper's primary focus is methodological innovation , extracting temporal patterns from human feedback and encoding them into algorithm design. We did not emphasize practical deployment in the original submission. Inspired by the Reviewer's comment, we have compiled real-world deployment data from our industry collaboration to directly address this concern.

Deployment Context

Since completing this study, TAIRL has been deployed in a live production system in collaboration with a licensed securities firm (the same institution that provided the D3/D4 datasets). The deployment scenario is securities-firm morning briefings, where a digital human (AI avatar) delivers market analysis and investment commentary via voice interaction (speech-to-text and text-to-speech conversion), with expert advisors providing turn-level feedback in real time. This is the exact MOD scenario studied in our paper: multi-turn dialogue with topic shifts (macro overview → sector discussion → stock analysis), emotional nuance, and real-time human feedback.

This deployment validates the full pipeline: temporal feedback patterns → TAIRL algorithm → simulator training → live digital-human deployment, completing the cycle from methodological insight to real-world impact.

Table R1-1: Live Deployment Metrics

Table R1-1. Live deployment metrics (6-month pilot, Nov 2025 – Apr 2026, anonymized).

MetricPre-TAIRL BaselineTAIRL-EnhancedChange
Task completion rate (%)71.278.6+7.4pp
Avg. expert interventions / dialogue12.37.1−42.3%
Avg. dialogue turns to resolution8.76.2−28.7%
User satisfaction (10-pt, post-session)6.98.2+18.8%
Negative feedback rate (%)38.424.7−13.7pp
Daily active dialogues340520++52.9%
Total live dialogues processed—47,000+—

The −42.3% reduction in expert interventions directly confirms that TAIRL's learning-efficiency gains carry over from simulation to live human feedback. The user-satisfaction improvement (+18.8%) is consistent with our held-out human evaluation (+22.8%, Section 4.3.3).

Commitment to Open-Data Release

If this paper is accepted, we commit to publicly releasing all de-identified raw data, including:

  1. The 4,287 human feedback samples (anonymized)
  2. The 800 held-out evaluation dialogues with human ratings
  3. The deployment dialogue logs (anonymized, aggregated metrics as in Table R1-1)
  4. The reward-simulator training data

All data will be scrubbed of personal identifiers and proprietary content, consistent with our data-sharing agreement with the partner firm. This will enable full reproduction and independent verification.

Supporting Evidence Already in the Paper

  • Pilot study (Appendix F, Table 8): FP gap of only 1.2pp between simulator-trained and live-feedback-trained policies.
  • Human evaluation (Tables 1–3, Figure 1): All FP and user-experience metrics are measured on 800 held-out real human dialogues, never seen during training. Four domain experts rated under double-blind protocol (ICC > 0.81). The +22.8% user-satisfaction and +56% emotional-alignment gains reflect real human perception, independent of any simulator metric.
  • Why simulator-based LS/SE: 5,000+ expert-annotated turns per run per seed (× 5 seeds × 8 methods × 4 datasets) is prohibitively expensive. Stated in Section 4.1 and the Conclusion.

Summary

While the paper centers on the algorithmic contribution, the real-world deployment (47,000+ live dialogues in a securities-morning-briefing digital-human system, −42.3% intervention reduction, +18.8% user satisfaction )provides the application-level validation the Reviewer requested. The digital-human and voice-interaction deployment context demonstrates that TAIRL's MOD optimization is not limited to simulation but powers a production system serving real users daily. Together with our open-data commitment, we hope this addresses the remaining reservation.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.