acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

EFFECT-GUIDED STRUCTURAL GROWTH IN PRETRAINED SKILL SPACES FOR LIFELONG REINFORCEMENT LEARNING

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Expandable representations can support lifelong reinforcement learning, but task failure alone does not reveal whether the active representation is the bottleneck or where additional capacity should be exposed. We introduce Effect-Guided Structural Skill Growth (EGSG), which treats the active span of a pretrained executable skill representation as geometry that can be interrogated online. For each policy-requested short-horizon effect, EGSG measures support mismatch and maps the request through a source-trained inverse model to one candidate latent realization. Persistent out-of-span residuals propose directions to test; they are not treated as proofs of global non-representability. A direction is committed only when held-out execution shows that exposing it reduces matched effect-realization error relative to both the current span and a source-covariance-matched alternative. On Meta-World MT10 and a 12-task MT50 lifelong stream, EGSG reaches 0.78 and 0.66 final average success, respectively; on MT10, it accepts only 2.4 structural updates on average while outperforming interface-matched fixed-capacity and comparable-growth controls. Across the 24 accepted MT10 updates, the proposed directions align with held-out expert residual structure above matched nulls, reduce normalized out-of-span residuals by 19% and matched effect error by 27%, and improve matched success by 27 percentage points before subsequent policy optimization. No post-hoc false-growth event is observed among these 24 accepted updates; removing execution validation reintroduces such events. A five-task real-robot stream provides a preliminary feasibility demonstration.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
ROB: Robot Learning, Control & Foundation Models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_4AmcOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper frames lifelong structural adaptation as an active-span adequacy problem: whether the currently exposed portion of a frozen pretrained skill space is what limits performance, as distinct from task novelty or low return. For this, EGSG uses persistent skill projection residuals as a signal of where the span may be insufficient, and expands the span only when held-out execution confirms the proposed direction helps. EGSG outperforms fixed-capacity, alternative growth, and lifelong RL baselines on Meta-World with few structural updates.

Critical strengths
  • The paper addresses a meaningful question: diagnosing when the representation, rather than optimization or exploration, is the bottleneck in lifelong RL. The approach is also structurally efficient, with no growth in trainable parameters, few structural updates and low validation overhead.

  • The added directions improve matched success from 0.23 to 0.50 on held-out requests before any further policy learning, showing that the gain comes from the added direction and not only from continued training.

Critical weaknesses
  • EGSG depends heavily on the source tasks, since it can only use behaviors the frozen source decoder can already produce. The split is chosen by the authors, and incoming tasks are largely covered by the source (Table 7: 95.4% of incoming expert variance at K=8; Fig. 1: 3 of 5 incoming tasks already solved at K=4). It is unclear how EGSG performs when incoming tasks are less covered by the source, which limits the applicability of this approach.

  • The paper describes the old span as preserved after growth, but the same request can still produce a different executed skill once a new direction is added. Since G_inv and the skill decoder are frozen, forgetting might mainly occurs in the high-level policy, which is shared across tasks and trained with 50% rehearsal. Rehearsal is shared across all EGSG-family controls, but none of the experiments isolates whether the structure itself prevents forgetting. The paper should compare EGSG without rehearsal, and a no-projection baseline (K=16) trained with the same rehearsal data.

  • Proposing where to expand the span and then verifying it before acceptance is essentially about sampling (or search) efficiency for verification, but this efficiency gain is not measured. According to the paper, validation costs only ~0.3% of the task budget per candidate, so a brute-force best-of-N baseline that validates many PCA or random directions and commits the best one also can be a good option. The paper should demonstrate its efficiency advantage over this.

Additional feedback

  • State the frozen and trained components in the main text, since G_inv being frozen is not very clear. Cite GPM, SPiRL, and HIRO. Clarify the Fig. 1 vs. App. F.2 inconsistency for button-press.
Questions for authors

Please see the weaknesses above.

Reviewer_5yNrOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies growing the skill latent space (subspace of the full space) over a sequence of tasks. The subspace is occupied by a span of basis vectors, and new basis vectors are added only when they demonstrate their utility. The paper shows a performance improvement over baselines on a meta-RL benchmark and a physical robot.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper was incredibly difficult to read, to the extent that I believe the paper should’ve been desk-rejected given the standards of desk rejection I’ve observed in other ICLR desk rejections this year. The entire paper is riddled with undefined terminology (examples in the abstract given in Questions below), and many sections (e.g. the abstract and introduction) are nearly unintelligible. This style of writing is one of the features of AI-generated papers, so I ran the main text through Pangram and it claims 90% of the paper’s main text was AI-generated. If true, the AI Use Statement’s claim that AI was used for “manuscript organization and editing” understates the degree of AI use for the paper.
  2. There are issues with evaluation rigor. First, there’s a fairness concern in comparisons with external baselines. While EGSG operates in temporal abstractions that consist of 5 primitive actions, all external baselines operate at the level of primitive actions and don’t involve temporal abstractions. Also, the “Validate” step of the method involves validating a candidate new basis vector on a held-out validation set that the baselines don’t get, potentially privileging EGSG. Second, the “EGSG-family structural controls” section appears to be missing the most important structural control, namely a version of “EGSG Fixed Basis” that simply uses the full skill latent space (see Q1 below).
Questions for authors
  1. While the skill representation space has 16 dimensions, the “EGSG Fixed Basis” and “EGSG Fixed Large” ablations only expose 4 and 8 dimensions, respectively. What are its results when all 16 dimensions are exposed? That would be the simplest fixed skill space baseline that needs to be provided to support the paper’s story that enlarging the space starting from a small number of dimensions is useful compared to having a fixed larger number of dimensions throughout adaptation.
  2. Are there any comparisons with external methods that use temporal abstractions, which would be the fairer comparison given that EGSG uses temporal abstractions?

Additional suggestions:

  1. “Draft parts of the research paper” is a recommended disclosure of AI use. Some parts of the paper exhibit properties of AI-generated text. For example, the abstract was largely unintelligible to me as it was dominated by undefined terminology like “expandable representations”, “capacity”, “span”, “short-horizon effect”, “post-hoc false-growth”, etc., and it shows up as 100% AI-generated when put into Pangram. Although I do not have conclusive evidence that these parts of the paper are drafted by AI, if they are indeed AI-generated, then ICLR’s official policy recommends that the authors disclose such use of AI.
Reviewer_XsHSOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
1
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper attempts to propose EGSG, a method that selectively expands the active skill space within a frozen pre-trained representation. Experiments include Meta-World tasks in simulation and a claimed real-world experiment with 5 tasks. The paper's narrative is very hard to understand and it's contributions and experiments remain unclear to me.

Critical strengths

The paper attempts to address a relevant problem: deciding when additional representational capacity is needed.

I was not able to understand the paper well enough to judge any additional strengths.

Critical weaknesses

The paper is very difficult to follow. Important implementation choices are scattered across sections and the appendix. I find it impossible to understand the complete experimental procedure and details of the method confidently from the main text alone.

The threshold results appear inconsistent with the equations in the paper. Doubling the residual threshold gives 1.088, above the maximum possible normalized residual of 1. Yet the paper still reports growth under this setting - this discrepancy needs to be clarified.

The simulation evaluation is limited to one benchmark family and just one set of tasks. More realistic multi-stage tasks and different task splits are necessary to establish broader usefulness.

The real-robot experiment is very unclear in details and results. The takeaways are questionable.

Questions for authors

Can you attempt to re-write the paper clearly, concisely, and with sufficient details of the approach and experiments?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.