- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper talk about keyframe-based skill-incremental manipulation suffers from a level mismatch. Learning and replay operate on individual keyframes, while the knowledge to preserve spans entire skill executions. It proposes GROW, which adds long-horizon cues through dual-horizon attention grounding, an auxiliary action-chain predictor, and chain-based replay herding. Result gains over iManip and other baselines on RLBench and a real robot.
Critical strengths
The motivation is clear and well illustrated. The close the blue or red jar example concretely shows why local next-keyframe supervision can lose instruction-conditioned context.
The method is lightweight and self-supervised. All extra supervision comes from existing demonstrations, with no external models, and it plugs into multiple PerceiverIO backbones.
Evaluate on three backbones, five SIL settings, two ablation regimes, real-robot experiments.
Critical weaknesses
Table 8 shows large gains even when GROW’s components act only during base pretraining, and in the real-world study GROW already reaches 60% on the base task versus 20% for both baselines before any incremental update. This suggests much of the improvement comes from a stronger base representation rather than reduced forgetting. Results under joint multi-task training, and forgetting measured relative to each method’s own base, would be needed to support the SIL-specific claim.
The goal anchor is only the terminal end-effector position, and the action chain predicts translations only, which says little about skill progression in tasks like push buttons or stack blocks. The method is therefore closer to auxiliary future-waypoint prediction than to modeling skill-level semantics.
The tables show large unexplained variance, e.g., non-monotonic σ sensitivity in Table 11 and an ablation in Table 2 outperforming full GROW on New tasks.
Questions for authors
Please provide complete specifications of the real-world hardware: the exact name, model, manufacturing year, and production batch of the robot and sensors.
If the paper is accepted, can you guarantee that the trained models will be publicly released before the conference? Will all reported results be fully reproducible from the released materials?
Please provide the complete set of parameters (if you set potential hyperparametersto the machine) used for the experiment shown in the supplementary video grow_3_slide_the_block_onto_the_red_square.mp4, to support reproducibility.
Dear Reviewers,
Please review the authors' rebuttal and the other reviewers' comments, and participate in the discussion before it closes on November 18 (AoE). Kindly indicate whether your concerns have been adequately addressed and raise any remaining questions or concerns.
Thank you for your time and contributions.
Best regards,
Area Chair