- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies test-time reinforcement learning for multiple-solution reasoning problems, where each problem may admit several distinct valid outcomes but complete solution annotations are unavailable during training. The paper identifies a “Frequency Conflict” in existing label-free TTRL methods, generation frequency is used both to estimate correctness, which favors frequent outcomes, and to preserve outcome-level diversity, which favors infrequent outcomes. As a result, frequency alone cannot distinguish rare valid solutions from rare erroneous ones. To address this issue, the paper proposes MS-TTRL, which separates correctness estimation from diversity preservation. It uses outcome-level self-verification to estimate correctness, while generation frequency is reserved for diversity-aware reward scaling. The method further introduces a Three-State Outcome Cache that categorizes outcomes as correct, candidate, or wrong; ambiguous candidate outcomes receive soft rewards and are re-verified when revisited. Finally, Confidence-Gated Inverse Probability Scaling amplifies rare outcomes only after they have been verified with sufficiently high confidence. Experiments cover three backbone models and five random seeds. MS-TTRL consistently improves Recovery Rate and Outcome Recovery Rate over TTRL and TTRL-CoCoV, with an average Recovery Rate improvement of 19.13 percentage points over the strongest label-free baseline.
Critical strengths
-
The distinction between trajectory-level diversity and outcome-level diversity is important in multiple-solution reasoning. Existing TTRL methods based on majority-vote pseudo-labels are naturally biased toward dominant outcomes and can suppress rare but valid alternatives. The paper clearly explains why methods designed for single-answer reasoning do not directly transfer to multiple-solution settings.
-
The central observation—that generation frequency induces opposing preferences when used for both correctness estimation and diversity preservation—is intuitive and well motivated. The formulation helps explain why simply rewarding rare outcomes is unsafe and why extending majority voting to the top-𝑘 outcomes does not resolve the underlying ambiguity between rare valid and rare invalid outcomes.
-
The method improves both Recovery Rate and Outcome Recovery Rate across all evaluated HypoSpace model–task combinations and on MACE-Math. The gains are observed across model scales, model families, and five random seeds. Some improvements are substantial, particularly on 3D Structure Reconstruction, where majority-based TTRL exhibits severe outcome-level collapse despite high trajectory accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
-
MS-TTRL uses the same model as both the policy and the verifier. Consequently, generation and verification errors may be strongly correlated. A model that generates an outcome due to a systematic misunderstanding may also accept that outcome during verification. Repeating verification several times primarily reduces sampling variance, but does not necessarily mitigate systematic errors shared by the generator and verifier. Therefore, the verification pass rate should not automatically be interpreted as a reliable correctness probability.
-
The policy model is continuously updated, and the same evolving model is also used as the verifier. However, once an outcome enters the Correct or Wrong set, its state is permanently reused and never reconsidered. An early false acceptance can therefore continue receiving positive and inverse-frequency-scaled rewards, while an early false rejection can permanently suppress a valid outcome. This creates a mismatch between the evolving verifier and the persistent cache.
-
The evaluated tasks have finite solution spaces, highly structured outputs, explicit rules, and relatively straightforward outcome extraction. These properties are particularly favorable for outcome-level self-verification and caching. It is therefore unclear whether the method extends to the broader scientific and engineering reasoning settings emphasized in the introduction, where outcomes may be open-ended, difficult to canonicalize, or impossible to verify reliably through reverse reasoning.
-
The current comparison does not fully isolate which part of MS-TTRL produces the improvement. In particular, the paper lacks comprehensive comparisons with verifier-only rewards, verifier rewards combined with standard entropy or novelty regularization, periodic re-verification, frozen-verifier training, and inference-time diverse sampling without reinforcement learning. The untrained base model is also an important reference. This is especially relevant because the paper states that MS-TTRL remains below the base model on MACE-Math, while the corresponding base-model result is not shown in the main table.
-
TTRL-CoCoV primarily promotes trajectory-level diversity, whereas MS-TTRL explicitly targets diversity among final outcomes. Its limited improvement in Recovery Rate therefore does not strongly establish the superiority of MS-TTRL over alternative outcome-level diversity methods; it mainly confirms that diverse reasoning trajectories do not necessarily produce diverse final answers. This comparison is relevant but not sufficient for the paper’s central claim. More related baselines should be included to emphasize the advantage of the proposed method.
Questions for authors
I have a basic question to this study: Does the method actually solve the multiple-solution discovery problem? Its success depends on the policy first sampling a valid outcome and the self-verifier reliably recognizing it. Therefore, the current evidence supports improved preservation of observed valid outcomes rather than general recovery of the full solution space.
Others refer to Weakness. In summary, I think there should be more evidence, such as related baselines, tasks, or verifier effectiveness, to prove the strengths of the method.
3 comments
Official Comment by Authors (2/3)
W3: Evaluation on an open-ended task
We have added a small-molecule editing task from ChatDrug [1]. Given a source molecule, the model must generate a different molecule with a single connected component, at least one additional hydrogen-bond donor, and a molecular fingerprint similarity of at least 0.4 to the source molecule.
These problems do not provide a predefined list of candidate molecules, making the task more open-ended and closer to a real scientific application. We use Qwen3.5-4B and evaluate all methods on the same 48 test problems with 32 samples per problem. UValid@32 is the average number of distinct valid molecules generated per problem.
| Method | Accuracy (%) | UValid@32 |
|---|---|---|
| Base Model | 26.50 | 5.56 |
| TTRL | 59.05 | 0.81 |
| TTRL-CoCoV | 58.53 | 1.23 |
| MS-TTRL | 77.21 | 7.60 |
MS-TTRL improves accuracy and UValid@32 over TTRL by 18.16 percentage points and 6.79, respectively, and over TTRL-CoCoV by 18.68 percentage points and 6.38. It also improves over the base model by 50.71 percentage points in accuracy and 2.04 in UValid@32. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of MS-TTRL in a more open-ended task which better reflects real-world scientific problems.
W4: Additional baselines and comparison with the base model
We added the requested comparisons using Qwen3-1.7B: verifier-only rewards, verifier rewards with entropy regularization, periodic re-verification, a frozen verifier, and the untrained base model.
Verification and cache reuse
We compare MS-TTRL with Self-Verify, Self-Verify with entropy regularization, and Self-Reconsider, reporting RR and standard verification sample counts.
| Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-Verify | 46.92 | 27.10 | 46.28 |
| Self-Verify + entropy regularization | 36.35 | 9.58 | 41.63 |
| Self-Reconsider | 48.87 | 27.20 | 49.32 |
| MS-TTRL | 45.89 | 28.39 | 46.00 |
| Standard verification samples | Causal | 3D | Boolean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-Verify | 259,264 | 43,280 | 29,600 |
| Self-Verify + entropy regularization | 72,416 | 20,608 | 25,760 |
| Self-Reconsider | 98,240 | 29,792 | 16,520 |
| MS-TTRL | 25,496 | 7,456 | 3,264 |
MS-TTRL achieves similar RR to Self-Verify and Self-Reconsider across the three tasks, while using substantially fewer standard verification samples: reductions of 90.2%, 82.8%, and 89.0% relative to Self-Verify, and 74.0%, 75.0%, and 80.2% relative to Self-Reconsider. These results show that cache reuse reduces verification overhead while preserving solution coverage.
Verifier rewards with entropy regularization yield lower coverage than MS-TTRL on all three tasks and do not effectively improve outcome-level diversity.
Frozen verifier
We next compare MS-TTRL with a variant that freezes the verifier:
| Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean | MACE-Math |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frozen verifier | 44.67 | 27.20 | 45.21 | 34.50 |
| MS-TTRL | 45.89 | 28.39 | 46.00 | 44.26 |
A frozen verifier also improves outcome coverage, but less than MS-TTRL. These results indicate that the self-verifier improves as model training proceeds.
Inference-time diversity methods
Without training, we evaluate higher-temperature sampling () and Diverse Beam Search (DBS), which penalizes repetition to encourage diverse paths.
| Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Model + higher-temperature sampling () | 41.33 | 8.96 | 30.71 |
| Base Model + DBS | 28.15 | 4.27 | 18.11 |
| MS-TTRL | 45.89 | 28.39 | 46.00 |
| Outcome Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base Model + higher-temperature sampling () | 19.69 | 4.94 | 22.68 |
| Base Model + DBS | 14.24 | 2.23 | 10.84 |
| MS-TTRL | 23.26 | 16.93 | 36.49 |
Averaged over the three tasks, MS-TTRL improves RR over higher-temperature sampling and DBS by 13.09 and 23.25 percentage points, respectively, and also achieves substantially higher Outcome Recovery Rate (ORR). These results show that promoting diversity through inference-time sampling alone has limited effectiveness.
Comparison with the base model
Finally, we compare the untrained base model with TTRL and MS-TTRL:
| Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean | MACE-Math |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base Model | 38.97 | 6.87 | 32.12 | 49.72 |
| TTRL | 36.94 | 9.07 | 31.03 | 34.39 |
| MS-TTRL | 45.89 | 28.39 | 46.00 | 44.26 |
| Outcome Recovery Rate (%) | Causal | 3D | Boolean | MACE-Math |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base Model | 18.78 | 3.98 | 23.75 | 37.78 |
| TTRL | 17.42 | 5.28 | 22.63 | 22.75 |
| MS-TTRL | 23.26 | 16.93 | 36.49 | 34.74 |
Relative to the untrained base model, MS-TTRL improves RR by 6.92, 21.52, and 13.88 percentage points on Causal, 3D, and Boolean, respectively, with ORR also improving on each task. Training therefore increases coverage of valid outcomes under the same evaluation sampling budget.
On MACE-Math, MS-TTRL remains below the base model by 5.46 percentage points in RR and 3.04 percentage points in ORR. However, the corresponding drops for TTRL are 15.33 and 15.03 percentage points. MS-TTRL therefore effectively mitigates mode collapse on MACE-Math relative to TTRL.
Official Comment by Authors (3/3)
W5: Comparison with outcome-level diversity methods
Existing methods for outcome-level diversity, such as IPS-GRPO and DMPO, target settings with ground-truth labels. To the best of our knowledge, prior work in the label-free setting focuses on trajectory-level diversity, and MS-TTRL is the first method to target outcome-level diversity in this setting.
Beyond TTRL and TTRL-CoCoV, Section 5.4 of the paper evaluates a family of baselines that treat the top most frequent outcomes as positive pseudo-labels () to promote outcome-level diversity. MS-TTRL substantially outperforms every variant, confirming that expanding the set of frequency-based pseudo-labels alone does not resolve the frequency conflict.
Q1: Preserving outcome-level diversity during RL post-training
MS-TTRL does not recover the full solution space. Its central contribution is to address outcome-level mode collapse during label-free RL post-training, preserving diversity across distinct valid outcomes.
Prior work has observed that reinforcement learning from verifiable rewards (RLVR) can improve success rates under small sampling budgets, but can hardly enable a model to solve problems that remain beyond its reach even with repeated sampling [2, 3]. MS-TTRL belongs to the same paradigm. Nevertheless, RLVR remains an important approach to post-training that effectively improves model capability and accuracy. In multiple-solution reasoning, these gains can coexist with generation concentrated on a small subset of valid outcomes. Preserving diversity across distinct valid outcomes is therefore a central objective of post-training.
More specifically, methods such as IPS-GRPO address outcome-level mode collapse through inverse-frequency scaling with ground-truth correctness labels. In the label-free setting, however, methods such as TTRL also use frequency to judge correctness, creating the frequency conflict. MS-TTRL resolves this conflict by estimating correctness through outcome-level self-verification while reserving generation frequency for diversity preservation.
[1] Shengchao Liu et al. Conversational Drug Editing Using Retrieval and Domain Feedback. ICLR, 2024.
[2] Yang Yue et al. Does Reinforcement Learning Really Incentivize Reasoning Capacity in LLMs Beyond the Base Model? arXiv:2504.13837, 2025.
[3] Xinyu Zhu et al. The Surprising Effectiveness of Negative Reinforcement in LLM Reasoning. arXiv:2506.01347, 2025.
Official Comment by Authors (1/3)
We thank reviewer degW for the thorough review and valuable feedback on shared biases between generation and verification, cache reliability, applicability to open-ended tasks, baseline and component comparisons, and the distinction between solution discovery and diversity preservation. We have revised the manuscript accordingly, with newly added headings highlighted in red in the updated PDF.
We agree that using the same model for generation and verification can introduce shared systematic biases. In our formulation, pt(z) is a verification pass rate, not a calibrated probability of correctness. Its purpose is to provide reasonably reliable outcome rewards in the label-free setting.
Precision, recall, and false-accept rate
To evaluate these rewards, we measured the precision, recall, and false-accept rate of the self-verifier's acceptance decisions on sampled outcomes:
High precision and recall across all three tasks support the reliability of the self-verifier. The false-accept rate is elevated only on Causal (28.85%). Overall, despite shared systematic biases, the self-verifier provides reliable rewards without ground-truth labels.
Comparison with an external verifier
We also recorded the outcomes assessed by MS-TTRL's self-verifier and re-verified these same outcomes offline using Phi4-4B-mini-Instruct:
Phi achieves a lower false-accept rate on Causal at the cost of a substantial drop in recall. Its overall verification performance on 3D and Boolean is worse or comparable. Reliable rewards for multiple-solution tasks must support both the correctness of accepted outcomes and coverage of valid outcomes. The self-verifier maintains high precision and recall on all three tasks, showing that shared systematic biases do not prevent it from providing an effective correctness signal.
Handling uncertain judgments
In addition to the verifier quality discussed in W1, the Candidate Set reduces the risk of permanently caching uncertain judgments too early. Outcomes with intermediate verification pass rates remain in the Candidate Set, receive soft rewards, and are re-verified by the updated model when the corresponding problem is revisited. This keeps outcomes with insufficient evidence from immediately receiving either the inverse-frequency amplification reserved for confirmed correct outcomes or the zero reward that would suppress them.
The Candidate Set ablation in the paper supports this design. On Causal, removing the Candidate Set and using the midpoint threshold yields 74.80% accuracy and 41.79% Recovery Rate (RR), compared with 93.75% and 45.89% for full MS-TTRL. This demonstrates that the Candidate Set helps mitigate permanent caching errors.
Re-verifying cached outcomes
We have also added a Self-Reconsider baseline, which re-verifies selected cached outcomes from the Correct and Wrong Sets during training, to examine how reusing earlier judgments affects coverage of valid solutions. Results for Qwen3-1.7B are as follows:
Relative to MS-TTRL, Self-Reconsider changes RR by +2.98, −1.19, and +3.32 percentage points on Causal, 3D, and Boolean, respectively. MS-TTRL uses 74.0%, 75.0%, and 80.2% fewer standard verification samples. Cache reuse thus substantially reduces repeated verification while maintaining comparable coverage of valid solutions.