acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

TCCA: Target-Conditioned Credit Assignment for Test-Time Reinforcement Learning

Abstract

Test-time reinforcement learning derives supervision from self-generated answers, but outcome-only credit loses information at two levels: within a prompt, responses with the same binary reward receive identical base advantages, while across prompts, within-prompt normalization does not reflect differences in target ambiguity. We introduce Target-Conditioned Credit Assignment (TCCA), which keeps a single hard pseudo-target estimated from the rollout pool and uses it to organize learning credit at two complementary resolutions. Self-certainty-weighted Soft Vote estimates the target and its answer distribution. The associated ambiguity reallocates normalized outcome credit across prompts through Hardness-Oriented Advantage Scaling, while target-matching reasoning traces form compact semantic references that provide relative reasoning credit within each prompt. The two terms are normalized separately and combined at the advantage stage for the same policy update, reusing the sampled responses and a frozen semantic encoder without a dedicated process reward model. Across single-run evaluations on three backbones and four reasoning benchmarks, TCCA yields higher point estimates than outcome-only TTRL in all 12 settings. In matched three-seed MATH-500 experiments, TCCA improves sample accuracy / majority correctness from 38.96/40.40 to 41.10/42.80 on Qwen2.5-0.5B and from 39.80/41.73 to 42.82/44.67 on Llama3.2-1B-Instruct, with positive paired differences in all three seeds on both backbones. Component removals and a separate one-versus-two-prototype comparison further support the credit construction, with approximately 5.3% additional complete-run time on the measured setup.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Test-Time Reinforcement Learning, Large Language Model Reasoning, Credit Assignment, Self-Supervised Reinforcement Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_nGzvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Based on TTRL, this paper is a combination of self-certainty weighting, weighted voting, answer entropy-based HOAS, and embedding-based clustering. The results are rich and better than the TTRL baseline.

Critical strengths

The paper identifies several weaknesses in standard TTRL and tries to address them at different levels, especially through uncertainty-aware weighting and finer-grained credit assignment.

The empirical study is quite thorough, with multiple models and benchmarks, matched multi-seed runs, ablations, and efficiency analysis, and the overall results are consistently positive.

Critical weaknesses

I am not fully convinced by the HOAS design. More ambiguous prompts are given larger weights, but these prompts may also have less reliable pseudo-targets. The paper shows positive empirical gains, but does not directly establish that higher ambiguity corresponds to more useful rather than noisier supervision.

The “reasoning credit” is built from embedding similarity and clustering of target-matching traces. This can certainly create finer-grained scores, but it is not clear that these scores actually measure better reasoning rather than just semantic similarity or stylistic similarity.

Questions for authors

If the soft vote is intended to produce a more reliable pseudo-target, why is direct pseudo-target accuracy against the available gold answer not reported? The current “reward accuracy” can count jointly negative decisions and therefore does not directly validate the claimed target-quality improvement.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer nGzv: Direct pseudo-target accuracy against gold

To address the reviewer’s concern about reward agreement, we directly check whether the pseudo-target used for each training prompt matches the gold answer. TCCA uses confidence-weighted voting. SoftVote-Off uses equal-count voting and recomputes the pseudo-target. Over all 150 training steps, TCCA selects 5,717/14,400 (39.70%) correct pseudo-targets, compared with 5,557/14,400 (38.59%) for SoftVote-Off, a difference of +1.11 percentage points.

StepsSoftVote-Off (Count Vote)TCCADifference
1–5037.10%37.21%+0.10
51–10039.35%40.81%+1.46
101–15039.31%41.08%+1.77
1–15038.59%39.70%+1.11

At the end of the paired training runs, TCCA improves sample accuracy from 39.70% to 41.10% and majority-vote accuracy from 41.00% to 42.80% over SoftVote-Off.

Figure R1. Training-time comparison of TCCA and SoftVote-Off.

T = TCCA   C = SoftVote-Off (Count Vote)   * = same plotted bin

A. Pseudo-target accuracy against gold (%)

42.5 |             *        T        T     T     T
40.0 |    C  *  T     *  *  C  *  *  C  *  C     C
37.5 |    T     C                             *
35.0 |
32.5 |
30.0 |
27.5 |
25.0 | *
22.5 |
20.0 |
17.5 |
     +---------------------------------------------
       10          50             100           150

B. Gold-correct retained training responses (%)

42.5 |                                     T
40.0 |                            T  T  T  C     *
37.5 |                   *  *  *  C  C  C     *
35.0 |             *  *
32.5 |
30.0 |          *
27.5 |       *
25.0 |    *
22.5 |
20.0 |
17.5 | *
     +---------------------------------------------
       10          50             100           150

          Last optimizer step in each 10-step block

Panel A counts one selected pseudo-target per training prompt. Panel B counts each of the 32 retained responses per prompt separately. Both use gold answers. Each column pools 10 consecutive optimizer steps across three runs, and the column at 150 represents steps 141–150. Values are rounded to the nearest 2.5 percentage points for display.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer nGzv: What HOAS amplifies & Mathematical steps under equal rewards

What HOAS amplifies

Training effect. TCCA exceeds HOAS-Off by 1.18 pp in sample accuracy and 1.20 pp in majority-vote accuracy across three matched MATH-500 runs. We reset the HOAS weight to 1 when voting returned a usable pseudo-target, the group’s active answer entropy exceeded the batch center, and its original HOAS weight was greater than 1. To preserve the near-consensus treatment raised by f6oQ, we retain the original HOAS weights for groups in which exactly 31 of the 32 retained responses match the voted pseudo-target. This keeps the scaling of the lone nonmatching response in place while testing the contribution of the high-entropy boosts elsewhere. Both arms use the same voting and RC rules. At step 150, removing these boosts reduces sample accuracy from 41.29% to 39.90% and majority-vote accuracy from 43.00% to 41.00%.

Gold-based diagnostic. HOAS applies the same prompt weight to positive and negative outcome advantages. A weight above 1 can therefore strengthen positive feedback for a response that matches an incorrect pseudo-target. To quantify what happens to gold-correct responses, we use a frozen pool of 64 responses per MATH-500 problem sampled from the step-150 Qwen2.5-0.5B TCCA checkpoint trained with seed 0. We use all 64 candidates to reconstruct the voted pseudo-target and answer entropy, and compute the outcome advantages on the same first 32 responses per problem. We fix the rollouts, pseudo-targets, and offline batches of 32 prompts, then compare unit weights with HOAS weights recomputed on those batches. This replay involves no new sampling or parameter updates. Gold is used only to label targets and responses for analysis.

For prompt (qq) and retained response (ii), let (AqiA_{qi}) be the GRPO-normalized outcome advantage before HOAS and RC, (wqw_q) the recomputed HOAS weight, and (gqig_{qi}) an indicator that the response’s final answer matches gold. We measure the change in signed outcome coefficients on gold-correct responses:

g_{qi}(w_q A_{qi}-A_{qi}).$$ For this diagnostic, ($\mathcal{H}$) is the higher-entropy half of the prompts with valid pseudo-targets and positive entropy in the frozen pool, comprising 178 prompts. The 20 prompts with correct pseudo-targets contribute **+22.27**, and the 158 with incorrect pseudo-targets contribute **−8.17**. Both terms count only gold-correct responses, including correct responses whose negative advantage becomes more negative when the pseudo-target is wrong. The signed coefficient sum on gold-correct responses rises from **163.68 to 177.78**, a net change of **+14.10**. Since this statistic sums changes only over gold-correct responses, prompts with no such responses contribute zero. HOAS can still amplify positive advantages on those prompts when incorrect responses match the pseudo-target. ## Mathematical steps under equal rewards We show two pairs of saved rollouts. Within each pair, both responses have the same final answer and binary pseudo-reward. Two blinded model assessments judged the mathematics and the presentation separately. The scores below are the applied reasoning credit (RC) residuals from replaying the saved rollouts. - **Unicycle speed.** Both responses answer `12π` inches per second and receive reward 1. The higher-RC response correctly gives `18π` inches per revolution and `36π` inches for two revolutions in three seconds. The other uses the same arithmetic but calls `36π` the distance for one revolution before dividing by the time for two. The applied RC residuals are **+0.057918** and **−0.100000**, respectively. Both assessments favor the former on mathematics and tie the pair on presentation. - **Fibonacci series.** Both responses give the wrong answer `1/2` and receive reward 0. The higher-RC response writes the valid telescoping identity `F(n+1) / (F(n) × F(n+2)) = 1/F(n) − 1/F(n+2)`. The series sums to `2` using `F(1) = F(2) = 1`. The other response drops the numerator and uses `F(1) = 0` despite the stated initial value. The applied RC residuals are **+0.012271** and **−0.003458**, respectively. Both assessments favor the former on mathematics and the latter on presentation. The appendix reproduces both questions and their original responses. In the matched MATH-500 ablation, TCCA improves sample and majority-vote accuracy by **1.33 and 1.40 percentage points**, respectively, over RC-Off.
Reviewer_epgBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

TCCA augments outcome-only TTRL with credit derived from the sampled responses. Confidence-weighted voting selects a pseudo-target whose answer ambiguity controls outcome weighting across prompts. A frozen encoder then scores traces against target-matching semantic prototypes to recover within-outcome distinctions. The signals are normalized separately and reuse existing rollouts without training a process reward model.

Critical strengths
  • Nearest-prototype scoring allows a response to match either supported reference cluster, avoiding comparison against a single averaged direction. Allowing up to two prototypes improves sample accuracy by 1.74 points over one, with positive differences in all three matched runs.
  • When outcome rewards are identical, varying prototype similarities can still produce nonzero semantic advantages. This preserves a source of learning credit in groups where normalized outcome advantages vanish.
Critical weaknesses
  • Reproduced SCOPE and ETTRL Adv-Res results cover only Qwen2.5-0.5B/MATH-500. Comparisons elsewhere depend on varying external baselines with different protocols. Table 1's unmatched single runs leave small gains vulnerable to training variation, so the broader conclusions need support beyond the matched MATH-500 results.
  • The voting and uncertainty components have precedents in COMPASS and SEED-GRPO; related credit constructions appear in Latent-GRPO and GDPO. RC-Off measures the effect of removing the entire reasoning branch, leaving the specific benefit of target conditioning unresolved. Constructing references from all responses under the same encoder and scoring would test this choice directly.
Questions for authors

What changes when references use all responses, with the encoder and scoring fixed?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer epgB

All responses as references. AllRef builds prototypes from all eligible same-question responses. TCCA uses eligible responses matching the voted pseudo-target. Both share the encoder, prototype construction, scoring, and RC gate. With same setting as the TCCA runs on MATH-500, the three AllRef results show sample accuracy average 39.77% sample / 41.67% majority-vote accuracy. The three TCCA runs average 41.10% / 42.80%, a difference of +1.33 / +1.13 percentage points.

Beyond MATH-500. We compare Original TTRL and TCCA on AMC with Qwen2.5-0.5B. And we Step 300, sample / majority-vote accuracy — Original TTRL 9.49% / 9.64%, TCCA 12.73% / 13.25%. Combining with the already reported result, which is from 10.62% to 13.93% in sample accuracy, TCCA consistently outperforms Original TTRL on AMC.

Relationship to prior work. COMPASS combines confidence-weighted pseudo-target voting with a trajectory score derived from token probabilities. SEED-GRPO uses semantic entropy to attenuate updates on high-uncertainty prompts. Latent-GRPO derives intrinsic rewards from proximity to a robust centroid of terminal hidden states, and GDPO normalizes each reward separately before combining the resulting advantages. In TCCA, the same voted pseudo-target defines the binary outcome reward and identifies eligible target-matching rollouts for prototype construction. We score trajectories by their similarity to the nearest prototype in a frozen embedding space and add a bounded residual to the HOAS-scaled outcome advantage.

I thank the authors for the response and the AllRef results, which address my question. As noted in my review, my remaining concern is that the comparisons lack a consistent set of baselines across settings: each setting compares against only a subset of baselines. For example, SCOPE and ETTRL Adv-Res are reproduced only on Qwen2.5-0.5B/MATH-500. Considering all of this, I will keep my score.

Reviewer_f6oQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1(−1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focus on test-time rl for math reasoning without gt labels. Based on a self-supervised GRPO variant that extracts both outcome and reasoning credit from a single pseudo-target, the authors propose TCCA to get dense training signals without training an extra PRM. For each prompt, they sample 64 rollouts and use a certainty-weighted Soft Vote to get a target answer and an answer distribution qxq_x. The outcome advantage is reweighted per prompt via HOAS based on the entropy of qxq_x. Then, correct traces are embedded with a frozen Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B model, filtered, and clustered into one or two prototypes. All rollouts are then scored by how close they are to the nearest prototype, and this normalized score is combined with the outcome advantage. Experiments on three small backbones (Qwen2.5-0.5B/7B, Llama3.2-1B) across four standard reasoning benchmarks show gains over previous baselines, including multi-seed verification on MATH-500.

Critical strengths

This paper separates intra-prompt reasoning differences from inter-prompt learning weights, the idea itself makes sense. Since they just use the voting results from the current 64 rollouts to calculate rewards, and pick the target-matching traces in the same batch as reasoning references, there is no need to sample any extra responses during training. It only uses a small frozen encoder instead of training a new process reward model, so the extra compute cost is small enough for practical use.

The method shows gains on the smaller models. Also, the authors did ablation studies on each component and compared using 1 vs. 2 prototypes, which verifies that their main designs are effective.

Critical weaknesses

It is not entirely clear whether the gains from HOAS actually come from forcing the model to learn more from high-disagreement prompts. Equation (14) explains why the common positive scaling coefficient needs to be applied after standardization within the group, but the article does not discuss why questions with higher answer entropy deserve higher weights, nor does it explain what the underlying mechanism is. Thus, HOAS might simply be stabilizing training by softening extreme negative updates on near-consensus prompts, rather than optimally allocating learning effort toward ambiguous ones.

Also, it remains unclear whether the prototype similarity term teaches the model better reasoning, or merely encourages it to mimic the surface phrasing of the reference traces. Scoring entire traces by embedding cosine similarity conflates reasoning validity with stylistic or template similarity. It becomes especially critical in homogeneous all-positive groups: here, the outcome advantage is identically zero, so the similarity residual becomes the sole signal deciding which correct solutions are reinforced and which are penalized.

Questions for authors

During actual training, how does HOAS affect the effective advantage magnitudes of matching vs. non-matching rollouts? In near-consensus groups, does HOAS primarily act by dampening the large negative advantages of the few dissenting rollouts?

Have you tried replacing HOAS with direct advantage clipping (especially on the negative side)? How would that compare empirically?

During training, what fraction of prompts have all 32 training rollouts matching the pseudo-target, and how does this proportion evolve over training steps?

Compared to standard outcome-only TTRL, does TCCA reduce the diversity of valid solution strategies after training? Any pre- vs. post-training analysis or examples on solution diversity would be very helpful.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer f6oQ

1. Matching and nonmatching advantages

In our instrumented 150-step TCCA run, we observed 327 near-consensus prompt instances in which exactly 31 of the 32 retained responses matched the voted pseudo-target. Matching is defined by agreement with the voted answer. HOAS downweighted 326 of these 327 instances.

Before adding reasoning credit (RC), the median outcome advantage changed from +0.1768 to +0.1665 for a matching response and from −5.4800 to −5.1611 for the lone nonmatching response. HOAS applies the same positive weight to all responses within a prompt, so the median magnitude shrank by about 5.8% on both sides. The difference in absolute reduction follows from the binary reward structure. With 31 rewards of 1 and one reward of 0, subtracting the group mean of (31/32) gives (+1/32) for each match and (-31/32) for the nonmatch. Dividing by the same standard deviation preserves this 31-to-1 ratio. The same proportional shrinkage therefore reduces the lone negative advantage by about 0.319 in magnitude and each positive advantage by about 0.010.

This is the downweighting side of the same prompt-level scaling rule discussed in our response to nGzv. When a prompt’s HOAS weight exceeds 1, both signs grow in magnitude. In the targeted ablation reported there, we preserve the original scaling for all 31/32 groups and remove only the extra boosts for eligible high-entropy groups elsewhere. The resulting drop in step-150 accuracy shows that those boosts contribute to performance in that matched run, with the near-consensus scaling rule held fixed.

2. Direct negative-side clipping

Clip-only replaces HOAS with max(A_out, −4.5) after GRPO normalization and uses the same RC rule. Before training, we set the floor between the pre-scaling negative advantages for 31/32 matches (−5.48) and 30/32 matches (−3.81), so it targets the near-consensus negative tail. The floor moves the 31/32 negative value to −4.5, compared with the HOAS median of −5.1611. At step 150, TCCA exceeds Clip-only by 1.94 sample and 2.20 majority-vote percentage points on average across three matched seed pairs. Majority-vote accuracy is higher in all three pairs.

In a second control, we keep the original HOAS weight only for groups with exactly 31 of 32 matches and use unit weights elsewhere, with the same RC rule. At step 150 of the matched run, TCCA reaches 41.29% sample and 43.00% majority-vote accuracy, compared with 37.54% and 38.60% for this control.

3. Frequency of all-matching groups

All 32 retained responses match the pseudo-target in 695/4,800 prompt instances (14.48%). The proportion is 4.00%, 15.31%, and 24.13% over steps 1–50, 51–100, and 101–150, respectively. These groups have uniform binary rewards and zero normalized outcome advantage. Every one of the 695 groups has at least one retained response with a nonzero RC residual.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer f6oQ

4. Saved rollouts with equal outcome rewards

Each pair shares the question, final answer, and binary outcome reward. We report the applied RC residuals. The cylindrical tank and Fibonacci series residuals come from replaying the scorer on the recorded responses. The Appendix gives the full questions and both original responses for each case.

CaseHigher RCLower RC
Shaded triangle. Both answer 15. All 32 rewards are 1.+0.015605. Uses the diagram's base 10 cm and perpendicular height 3 cm.−0.100000. Substitutes vertex (10,3) for (2,3) and calls the vertical segment from (10,0) to (10,3) a horizontal base of length 10.
Cylindrical tank. Inflow is 20π m³/h and the level rises 4 m/h. Both answer √5 and receive reward 1.+0.063865. Derives dV/dt = πr² × dh/dt.+0.043126. Writes h = 4 m/h and substitutes the height rate as the height.
Fibonacci series. Both answer 1/2 and receive reward 0.+0.012271. Gives the valid identity F(n+1) / (F(n) × F(n+2)) = 1/F(n) − 1/F(n+2).−0.003458. Drops the numerator and treats F(1) as zero. Both blinded rounds prefer its writing but prefer the other rollout's mathematics.

5. Valid solution strategies before and after training

In the sum-and-remainder problem, which asks for 1 + 2 + … + 12 modulo 4, the common start produces valid formula and direct-addition routes. Sum formula uses the arithmetic-series formula or an equivalent pairing argument to obtain 78 before taking the remainder. Direct addition obtains 78 by adding the integers one at a time. Total valid responses counts responses with a valid derivation and the correct final answer across both strategies.

Model and checkpointSum formulaDirect additionConfirmed valid
Common starting checkpoint437
Original TTRL, step 15016016
TCCA, step 15014216

Both strategies appear at the common starting checkpoint. At step 150, both methods produce 16 valid solutions under the same 16-sample budget. TCCA still samples the direct-addition strategy twice. One saved TCCA response starts with 1 + 2 = 3 and 3 + 3 = 6, and adds each number through 55 + 11 = 66 and 66 + 12 = 78 before taking the remainder.

Thank the authors for the detailed rebuttal. The explanations and results about how HOAS and prototype scoring work during training have addressed my initial questions. However, I maintain my score at 2 due to the following remaining concerns:

1.A small frozen Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B model lacks the ability to verify complex math logic:I doubt if a small frozen Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B can guide larger policy models. Also, the 3-seed runs are only on 0.5B/1B models and the 7B gain is small, so scaling is a question to me.

2.On hard problems, LLMs often hallucinate with high confidence. When the pseudo-target is wrong, HOAS and prototype matching may give more weight to wrong reasoning and make the hallucination worse.

3.The method relies on too many manual hyperparameters (Table 7), which feels quite heuristic for tasks with different difficulty.

  1. Please check the text format in your "Replying to Appendix" comment. The LaTeX math symbols are not converted well.

Comments on the paper

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Shared response to the area chair and reviewers

We thank the reviewers for asking how Target-Conditioned Credit Assignment (TCCA) changes supervision during training. In the three Qwen2.5-0.5B comparisons reported on MATH-500, TCCA improves sample accuracy from 38.96% to 41.10% and majority-vote accuracy from 40.40% to 42.80% over Original Test-Time Reinforcement Learning (TTRL). Both metrics improve in each reported pair.

We report gold pseudo-target accuracy throughout training, matched ablations of prompt-level scaling, and a fixed-rollout analysis of how HOAS changes the outcome advantages on correct answers. Saved equal-reward rollouts show differences in mathematical steps, and a before-and-after example shows TCCA retaining a valid minority solution strategy at the same sampling budget as Original TTRL.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Appendix. Original questions and rollouts 1: Shaded triangle

The question and both responses are reproduced from the saved text for each case. The response headings give the applied RC residuals.

Shaded triangle

Gold and shared final answer 15 cm². All 32 binary pseudo-rewards in the group are 1.

The shaded triangle in the original problem has vertices (0,0), (2,3), and (10,0).

Original question

In the diagram, what is the area of the shaded triangle? [asy]
fill((0,0)--(2,3)--(10,0)--cycle,gray);
draw((0,0)--(10,0)--(10,3)--(0,3)--cycle,linewidth(1));
draw((0,0)--(2,3)--(10,0),linewidth(1));
label("10 cm",(5,3),N);
label("10 cm",(5,0),S);
label("3 cm",(0,1.5),W);
label("3 cm",(10,1.5),E);
draw((0,2.5)--(.5,2.5)--(.5,3));
draw((10,2.5)--(9.5,2.5)--(9.5,3));
[/asy]

Higher-RC response (+0.015605)

To find the area of the shaded triangle, we need to follow these steps:

1. Identify the base and height of the triangle.
2. Use the formula for the area of a triangle.
3. Substitute the given values into the formula.

From the diagram, we can see that the base of the triangle is 10 cm and the height is 3 cm. The area of a triangle is given by the formula:

\[
\text{Area} = \frac{1}{2} \times \text{base} \times \text{height}
\]

Substituting the given values into the formula, we get:

\[
\text{Area} = \frac{1}{2} \times 10 \, \text{cm} \times 3 \, \text{cm} = \frac{1}{2} \times 30 \, \text{cm}^2 = 15 \, \text{cm}^2
\]

Therefore, the area of the shaded triangle is \boxed{15} square centimeters.

Lower-RC response (−0.100000)

To find the area of the shaded triangle, we need to follow these steps:

1. **Identify the vertices of the triangle:**
   - The vertices are \(A(0, 0)\), \(B(10, 0)\), and \(C(10, 3)\).

2. **Calculate the length of the base \(BC\):**
   - The base \(BC\) is the horizontal distance between \(B\) and \(C\).
   - \(BC = 10 \text{ cm}\).

3. **Calculate the length of the height \(AC\):**
   - The height \(AC\) is the vertical distance from \(A\) to \(C\).
   - \(AC = 3 \text{ cm}\).

4. **Use the formula for the area of a triangle:**
   The area \(A\) of a triangle is given by:
   \[
   A = \frac{1}{2} \times \text{base} \times \text{height}
   \]

5. **Substitute the known values into the formula:**
   \[
   A = \frac{1}{2} \times 10 \text{ cm} \times 3 \text{ cm}
   \]

6. **Perform the calculation:**
   \[
   A = \frac{1}{2} \times 30 \text{ cm}^2 = 15 \text{ cm}^2
   \]

Therefore, the area of the shaded triangle is \(\boxed{15}\) square centimeters.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Appendix. Original questions and rollouts 2: Cylindrical tank

The question and both responses are reproduced from the saved text for each case. The response headings give the applied RC residuals.

Cylindrical tank

Gold and shared final answer √5 m. Both responses receive binary pseudo-reward 1.

Original question

A right cylindrical tank with circular bases is being filled with water at a rate of $20\pi$ cubic meters per hour. As the tank is filled, the water level rises four meters per hour. What is the radius of the tank, in meters? Express your answer in simplest radical form.\nPlease reason step by step, and put your final answer within \boxed{}.

Higher-RC response (+0.063865)

To find the radius of the tank, we need to use the relationship between the volume of water in the tank and the height of the water level. The volume \( V \) of a cylinder is given by the formula:

\[ V = \pi r^2 h \]

where \( r \) is the radius and \( h \) is the height of the water level. We are given that the tank is being filled with water at a rate of \( 20\pi \) cubic meters per hour and that the water level rises at a rate of 4 meters per hour. This means that the height of the water level is increasing at a rate of 4 meters per hour. Therefore, we can express the height \( h \) as a function of time \( t \) by differentiating the volume formula with respect to time:

\[ \frac{dV}{dt} = \pi r^2 \frac{dh}{dt} \]

Given that \( \frac{dV}{dt} = 20\pi \) and \( \frac{dh}{dt} = 4 \), we can substitute these values into the equation:

\[ 20\pi = \pi r^2 \cdot 4 \]

To find \( r^2 \), we divide both sides of the equation by \( 4\pi \):

\[ \frac{20\pi}{4\pi} = r^2 \]
\[ 5 = r^2 \]

Taking the square root of both sides, we get:

\[ r = \sqrt{5} \]

Therefore, the radius of the tank is \(\boxed{\sqrt{5}}\) meters.

Lower-RC response (+0.043126)

To find the radius of the tank, we can use the formula for the volume of a cylinder, which is given by:

\[ V = \pi r^2 h \]

where \( V \) is the volume, \( r \) is the radius, and \( h \) is the height (or length) of the cylinder.

We are given that the tank is being filled with water at a rate of \( 20\pi \) cubic meters per hour, and the water level rises at a rate of 4 meters per hour. This means that the volume of water added to the tank per hour is:

\[ 20\pi \text{ cubic meters per hour} \]

Since the tank is cylindrical, the volume of water added per hour is equal to the volume of a cylinder with radius \( r \) and height \( h \):

\[ 20\pi = \pi r^2 h \]

We can simplify this equation by dividing both sides by \( \pi \):

\[ 20 = r^2 h \]

Next, we need to find the height \( h \) of the water in the tank. We know that the water level rises at a rate of 4 meters per hour, so the height \( h \) can be expressed as:

\[ h = 4 \text{ meters per hour} \]

Now we substitute \( h = 4 \) meters per hour into the equation \( 20 = r^2 h \):

\[ 20 = r^2 \cdot 4 \]

Solving for \( r^2 \):

\[ r^2 = \frac{20}{4} = 5 \]

Taking the square root of both sides, we get:

\[ r = \sqrt{5} \]

Therefore, the radius of the tank is:

\[ \boxed{\sqrt{5}} \]

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.