- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TimeSelect, a time-series forecasting framework that adaptively selects informative historical contexts for individual variables and forecasting instances. Unlike conventional methods that rely on fixed-length input windows, TimeSelect employs a differentiable context selector to suppress potentially irrelevant historical observations. The framework further incorporates correlation-derived temporal bases to capture stable temporal dependencies and a cycle-aware refinement module to preserve recent periodic patterns. Extensive experiments on 13 real-world datasets demonstrate competitive forecasting accuracy against SOTA baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses a meaningful and practical problem in time-series forecasting by recognizing that informative historical contexts vary across variables and forecasting instances.
-
The proposed framework effectively integrates variable-wise context selection, correlation-derived temporal bases, and cycle-aware refinement. These components are well motivated and complement each other in capturing relevant historical information and temporal patterns.
-
The experimental evaluation is comprehensive, covering 13 real-world datasets and comparisons with 13 competitive baselines.
Critical weaknesses
The paper could further explore sensitivity to the context-mask temperature, as well as the robustness of cycle-aware refinement under conditions of distribution shift or weak periodicity. Additionally, certain implementation details require clarification; please refer to the question box below.
Questions for authors
-
How sensitive is TimeSelect to the context-mask temperature? Could the authors clarify whether these hyperparameters require dataset-specific tuning?
-
The proposed temporal bases are constructed from training-set correlations and remain fixed during inference. How would the model respond to substantial distribution shifts or changes in temporal periodicity?
-
Since cycle-aware refinement explicitly uses recent periodic observations, how does the framework behave on datasets with weak or irregular periodicity?
-
Since RevIN is applied before historical context selection, are the normalization statistics computed from the entire input window or only the selected historical context?
Dear Reviewers M48z and vdGA,
The authors have responded to your questions. Please review their responses and consider whether your concerns have been addressed. You may also take a look at the other reviewers' comments and the revised manuscript and share any further feedback if you have any.
Best regards,
Your AC