- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DuoTS adds a horizon-dependent correction to a patch forecaster, combining recent context with retrieved historical states and their observed successor changes. Experiments cover eight datasets, four horizons, and transfer to three backbones.
Critical strengths
The forecast–retrieve–revise design is sensible. Horizon-specific queries combine recent context with historical continuations, while the exclusion preference reduces duplicate matches from overlapping patches. Encoding successor changes provides a reasonable way to represent what followed a matched state.
The results are competitive across eight datasets and four horizons. The main experiments report three-run variability, and the transfer and perturbation studies provide additional evidence. In Appendix F, random candidate selection worsens 25 of 27 affected settings, supporting the usefulness of learned ranking.
Critical weaknesses
The model has many interacting components, but the gain from explicit analog-successor retrieval over a simpler corrector is not isolated. Table 3 masks contexts only at inference, and Table 11 compares outputs of the same jointly trained model. Neither tests a retrained corrector with comparable capacity that attends to the same history.
Appendix D describes 20–50 Optuna trials per dataset, look-back candidate, and horizon, using validation MSE. Comparable tuning budgets and window-selection rules are not documented for the main baselines. Since several gains are small, this uncertainty affects the strength of the comparative claims.
Questions for authors
Could you compare the full correction with one simpler attention-based corrector on representative datasets, keeping the backbone, model capacity, training budget, and tuning budget comparable? This would help identify the benefit of explicitly retrieving successor information.
Which main-table baselines were rerun, and what tuning budgets and look-back selection rules were used? If these differed substantially from DuoTS, a matched rerun of the strongest baseline would make the comparison more convincing.
Simpler attention corrector and baseline rerun protocol
Thank you for your concrete reviews. For more detailed results, please refer to the revised pdf.
W1 / Q1. We retrained a generic attention corrector that reads the same history tokens with the same horizon query, without block retrieval, Top-K selection, diversity, confidence, or successors. It has the same parameter count as DuoTS and keeps its backbone, current context, router, and decoder. We also retrained a variant without successors (Table 4, Table 14).
Entries are alternative minus DuoTS, with the number of horizons where DuoTS is better. DuoTS is better than both at 15 of the 16 ETTh1 and ETTm1 comparisons, by up to 6.5% MSE, and is lowest or tied at every Weather horizon. We will add the remaining datasets to the paper as the runs complete.
W2 / Q2. All six baselines in Table 1, SRSNet (Wu et al., 2025), TimeKAN (Huang et al., 2025), Amplifier (Fei et al., 2025), iTransformer (Liu et al., 2024b), TimeMixer (Wang et al., 2024), and PatchTST (Nie et al., 2023), are now rerun through TFB (Qiu et al., 2024) under the DuoTS protocol. The look-back is searched over {96, 336, 512} jointly with each baseline's hyperparameters in 50 Optuna trials (Akiba et al., 2019) (Appendix D.2). The results are essentially unchanged. DuoTS still has the lowest MSE in 22 and the lowest MAE in 24 of 32 settings (22 and 23 in the submission). We also rerun RAFT (Han et al., 2025), the closest retrieval-based method, and DuoTS is more accurate in three of four cells (Appendix E, Table 11). We will add the remaining datasets to the paper as the runs complete.