- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DLoG is a retrieval-augmented framework for multivariate long-term forecasting. It adaptively decomposes each series into trend and seasonal components, performs local patch retrieval, and then searches a global training-memory repository separately for the two components. Seasonal matching uses shift-tolerant correlation, whereas trend matching combines correlations of the raw component and its first differences. Retrieved component futures, local references, and lightweight parametric forecasts are fused to form the prediction. Across nine benchmarks, DLoG reports consistently strong accuracy relative to forecasting and retrieval-based baselines. The paper also provides component ablations, three-seed main results, leakage-aware memory construction, and a detailed scalability analysis.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed inductive bias is plausible and practically useful. A single similarity score can be dominated by one component of a mixed signal, whereas separate searches can find a suitable trend and seasonal analogue even when no historical window jointly matches both. The matched holistic-retrieval ablation improves consistently on five datasets, with especially substantial gains on ECL, Traffic, and Weather. This is meaningful initial evidence for decomposed retrieval.
-
The empirical evaluation is broad and unusually attentive to retrieval mechanics. The study covers nine datasets, including high-dimensional ECL and Traffic, and compares against several retrieval and long-context approaches. The explicit overlap mask and training-only test repository address leakage concerns. Repository refresh cost, online latency, scaling with repository size, and the accuracy–efficiency trade-off are also reported clearly.
Critical weaknesses
-
The holistic control changes several factors simultaneously. It changes the representation, similarity functions, neighbor identities, future aggregation, and component-specific post-processing. Table 2 therefore shows that the complete DLoG system outperforms this holistic variant, but does not isolate which design choice causes the gain.
-
Separate retrieval introduces a compositional advantage beyond decomposition. The trend and seasonal branches may select different historical samples, increasing the chance of finding individually suitable matches. The paper does not separate this benefit from that of decomposed representations or component-specific similarity rules.
-
Recombining independently retrieved components requires an untested assumption. DLoG implicitly assumes that a trend future from one historical episode and a seasonal future from another can be combined into a valid forecast. This may hold for approximately additive, weakly coupled processes, but its behavior under strong trend–seasonality coupling is not examined.
-
Seasonal shift-tolerant matching may leave the retrieved future misaligned. The manuscript does not state that the maximizing temporal shift is applied inversely to the retrieved seasonal future. Without this step, a phase-shifted key can achieve high similarity while still supplying a future with the wrong phase; amplitude and bias calibration cannot correct that error.
-
The trend similarity does not measure level similarity as claimed. Pearson correlation is invariant to additive level shifts. Equation (8) therefore measures centered shape agreement and first-difference correlation, rather than similarity in absolute trend level.
-
The need for distinct component-specific metrics is not directly validated. Table 9 compares a common correlation metric with generic distances, but does not ablate seasonal shifting, trend differencing, or applying the same metric to both components. The paper therefore provides limited direct evidence that different components require different matching rules.
Questions for authors
-
What exactly is held constant in DLoG w/ Holistic Retrieval, including the number of searches and candidates, parameters, retrieved values, calibration/refinement modules, and fusion inputs?
-
Is the maximizing shift in Equation (7) recorded and applied to the associated seasonal future before aggregation? If not, how is phase consistency between the query and retrieved future maintained?
-
Can the authors report a factorial comparison between (i) decomposed representations with a combined score and shared neighbors, (ii) decomposed representations with separate neighbors but a common metric, and (iii) the full component-specific design? A capacity- and retrieval-budget-matched two-head holistic control would also be informative.
-
Can the authors evaluate retrieval quality before the final forecasting fusion, such as retrieved-future error for holistic versus decomposed retrieval, and test controlled signals where trend/seasonal coupling and decomposition quality are varied? This would distinguish improved retrieval from additional forecast capacity and identify when recombining component futures is valid.
2 comments
Response to Reviewer TDHt Part2
W3 & Q4: Component Recombination and Pre-Fusion Retrieval Quality
We thank the reviewer for highlighting component recombination. DLoG uses trend and seasonal references as complementary forecasting information, rather than requiring their combination to correspond to a single observed historical episode. These references are processed together with query-derived local forecasts through learned calibration and fusion modules to generate the final prediction.
To investigate retrieval quality before forecasting fusion, we conducted additional experiments under both synthetic and real-data settings. Reference MSE measures the error between directly aggregated retrieved futures and the ground truth, without learned calibration or forecasting fusion. The synthetic experiment introduces strong trend-seasonality coupling through a trend-slope/seasonal-amplitude correlation of 0.95, together with decomposition leakage of 0.2. For real ETTh1, all retrieval strategies use the same last-input level anchor to ensure a consistent evaluation.
Table 1. Pre-fusion retrieval quality (Reference MSE ).
| Setting | Retrieval strategy | Reference MSE | Distinct episodes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Synthetic | Shared Top-10 | 0.00820 | 10.0 |
| Synthetic | Separate Top-10 | 0.00582 | 17.1 |
| ETTh1 | Shared / Common | 0.6693 | — |
| ETTh1 | Separate / Common | 0.6557 | — |
| ETTh1 | Full component-specific | 0.6433 | — |
In the synthetic experiment, Separate Retrieval reduces reference MSE by approximately 29% compared with Shared Retrieval, even under strong component coupling and imperfect decomposition. This demonstrates that independent component retrieval can produce more accurate point references beyond the weakly coupled setting. The two strategies use the same top- per component, although Separate Retrieval accesses more distinct historical episodes.
On real ETTh1, Separate Retrieval with a common metric improves reference MSE from 0.6693 to 0.6557, while full component-specific matching further reduces it to 0.6433, achieving the best retrieval quality among the evaluated strategies. This corresponds to an overall improvement of approximately 3.9% over Shared/Common Retrieval. These results provide direct evidence that both independent component retrieval and component-specific matching contribute to improved pre-fusion reference accuracy, complementing the superior final forecasting performance of the full DLoG framework.
W4 & Q2: Seasonal Shift and Phase Consistency
We thank the reviewer for pointing out the distinction between shift-tolerant matching and explicit future phase alignment.
In Eq. (7), seasonal similarity is computed by maximizing correlation over a bounded range of circular temporal shifts from to . This enables the retrieval mechanism to recognize similar periodic patterns despite small phase differences.
In the current implementation, the maximizing shift determines the similarity score and neighbor selection, but is not explicitly retained or inversely applied to the retrieved seasonal future. Therefore, DLoG performs shift-tolerant neighbor selection rather than explicit phase alignment of retrieved future values.
The retrieved seasonal reference is subsequently processed through query-conditioned forecasting and amplitude/bias calibration. However, phase consistency is not explicitly enforced for each retrieved future, and these operations do not guarantee correction of an arbitrary phase error.
Our ETTh1 ablation shows that removing seasonal shift increases MSE from 0.3531 to 0.3576 and MAE from 0.3852 to 0.3910. These results support the contribution of shift-tolerant matching to forecasting performance, although they do not independently establish future phase alignment.
W5: Interpretation of Trend Similarity
We appreciate the reviewer's observation regarding the interpretation of trend similarity in Eq. (8).
The trend similarity function is designed to capture centered trend-shape agreement and local temporal changes, rather than directly comparing absolute trend levels. Specifically, the Pearson correlation term measures similarity between centered trend trajectories, while the first-difference term captures local increment patterns, reflecting growth and decline dynamics.
This formulation allows DLoG to identify similar trend evolution patterns across historical segments with different absolute levels. The current input's absolute level is handled separately through last-value normalization and restoration in the forecasting pathway.
The ETTh1 ablation further supports the contribution of first-difference matching: removing trend differencing increases MSE from 0.3531 to 0.3608. We will revise the terminology from “level similarity” to “centered trend-shape and local-change similarity” to accurately describe the implemented mechanism.
Response to Reviewer TDHt Part1
W1 & Q1: Holistic Retrieval Control
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of isolating the contributions of different retrieval components. DLoG is designed as an integrated component-aware retrieval framework, where decomposition, component-specific matching, and learned forecasting jointly contribute to prediction performance.
In Table 2, the holistic variant follows the same overall retrieval architecture and training configuration, while changing the retrieval representation and matching strategy. These changes can also affect neighbor selection, retrieved references, and their subsequent processing. Therefore, Table 2 evaluates the effectiveness of the complete framework rather than independently isolating every design factor.
The results demonstrate that DLoG consistently outperforms holistic retrieval across all five datasets. For example, MSE decreases from 0.155 to 0.134 on ECL and from 0.495 to 0.425 on Traffic. Furthermore, using both trend and seasonal retrieval branches outperforms either branch alone, supporting the effectiveness of integrating complementary component information.
To further distinguish the contributions of individual retrieval choices, we conducted additional controlled ablations, as reported in our response to W2, W6, and Q3. These experiments explicitly match the decomposition architecture, forecasting heads, trainable parameter count, and training protocol.
W2, W6 & Q3: Separate Retrieval and Component-Specific Matching
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestion to distinguish the benefits of independent neighbor selection from those of component-specific similarity rules. DLoG allows trend and seasonal components to retrieve historical patterns independently, while employing matching rules tailored to their temporal characteristics.
To evaluate these design choices, we conducted additional experiments on ETTh1 with three random seeds. All configurations use the same decomposition architecture, forecasting heads, trainable parameter count, and training protocol.
The full component-specific design achieves the lowest mean MSE (0.3531), outperforming both shared-neighbor retrieval with a common Pearson metric (0.3569) and separate-neighbor retrieval with a common Pearson metric (0.3610). Notably, separate neighbors with a common metric do not improve performance over shared neighbors. In contrast, introducing component-specific matching reduces MSE from 0.3610 to 0.3531 (approximately 2.2%). Removing seasonal shift or trend differencing further increases MSE to 0.3576 and 0.3608, respectively.
These results support the importance of component-specific matching beyond independent neighbor selection alone. In particular, trend differencing and seasonal shift tolerance both contribute to the full design's performance on ETTh1.