- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces insight anticipation, a task that predicts a downstream paper's core insight from summaries of two parent papers. The evaluated direction is from parent papers to downstream insights. Identifying the parents is only part of dataset construction. To build the dataset, a model reads each downstream paper, selects two cited parents, and explains how their ideas are combined. This process produces GIANTSBENCH, with about 17,000 examples, making research idea generation measurable against published contributions.
Critical strengths
It offers a more testable question than open-ended brainstorming, i.e., given prior papers, can a model predict how later work combines them?
Critical weaknesses
-
The validation of parent-paper selection is limited. Only 50 papers are checked by external experts, whose judgments cannot establish the authors' actual sources of inspiration. And model agreement of multiple LLM judges would not establish true provenance. Collecting feedback from some original authors might strengthen the evidence, but I still have serious doubts about this research setting.
-
The construction prompt requires two parent papers without an explicit option to report that no suitable pair exists. The paper does not report failure rates, exclusion rules, or manual handling
-
The assumption of exactly two parent papers needs stronger support, especially when the ground truth is not necessarily correct. Explaining this choice by controlling the input length is not convincing.
Questions for authors
Which specific downstream application will this task (insight anticipation) improve? And which experiments in the current paper can demonstrate that it will indeed be helpful?
2 comments
Going beyond two parent papers for context purposes
We agree with the reviewers framing that two going beyond two parent papers can be addressed through alternative forms of context management. We now run an experiment, where we use a stronger LLM (DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash) agentically with the pi harness (pi.dev), a common harness used by prior work [1,2] for interacting with a filesystem. Here, we supply the agent with n randomly sampled papers extracted from the related works of a target paper in a flat filesystem that the model can access and browse via the harness. We then perform inference time scaling (best@k), to understand the how the similarity evolves with more insights that are generated. We see that there is a monotonic increase in performance as more reference papers are seen, indicating that this is helpful for prediction. The best@k performance also indicates that through simple sharpening with RL, we can get to this target insight. For the final version of the manuscript and the dataset release, we will setup a filesystem variant of the evaluation and fine-tune a model with the harness.
| Reference papers | best@1 | best@2 | best@4 | best@8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2.53 | 3.03 | 3.48 | 3.84 |
| 2 | 2.98 | 3.40 | 3.76 | 4.06 |
| 4 | 3.45 | 3.82 | 4.08 | 4.28 |
| 8 | 3.48 | 3.89 | 4.20 | 4.47 |
| 16 | 3.71 | 4.08 | 4.39 | 4.62 |
Which specific downstream application will this task (insight anticipation) improve? And which experiments in the current paper can demonstrate that it will indeed be helpful?
Thank you for the question. The main downstream application is literature-grounded research ideation: given papers a researcher has selected, the model proposes a concrete insight that combines them. This is the synthesis step in human-in-the-loop research assistants and in automated research pipelines, which first retrieve relevant work and then propose ideas to pursue. Insight anticipation evaluates this step directly, because published downstream papers provide a grounded record of which combinations of prior work actually led to new research.
Several experiments in the paper indicate that GIANTS-4B would be helpful for this application:
-
Temporal forecasting. All evaluations use downstream papers published after the training cutoff, including papers published after the base model's release (Appendix C). GIANTS-4B therefore anticipates insights that had not yet appeared in its training data, which is the setting a research assistant faces.
-
Usefulness to researchers. In our human study, annotators who did not see the ground truth or the model identity rated GIANTS-4B's insights as significantly clearer and better scoped, i.e., more focused and testable, than those of the base model and Gemini-3-Pro, at comparable implementation complexity (Figure 5). These are the properties a researcher needs to act on an idea.
-
Potential impact. SciJudge-30B, a model trained to predict citation impact, prefers GIANTS-4B's insights over the base model's in 68% of comparisons (Figure 4).
-
Generate-then-select pipelines. GIANTS-4B remains the strongest model as the number of samples increases (Figure 2), so it can supply a stronger pool of candidates for a system that generates several ideas and then filters them.
-
Breadth. Although trained only on cs.CL, GIANTS-4B improves in all 16 domains (Figure 3), so a single model can support researchers across fields.
We deliberately focus on insight generation given a fixed set of parent papers. Our goal is to evaluate whether models can generate novel yet tractable research insights when provided with rich contextual knowledge: specifically testing their ability to make conceptual leaps [4] and escape "idea basins" [5,6]. Utilizing citation graphs from published literature provides a structured warm-start objective for research agents, as human scientific progress relies on synthesizing existing work into meaningful new contributions.
References
[1] Learning in a World of Notes (https://engram.com/blog/learning-in-a-world-of-notes)
[2] Harness Leaderboard (https://huggingface.co/spaces/joelniklaus/harness-leaderboard)
[3] ScholarCatalyst: A Benchmark for Retrieving Papers That Inspire New Research (https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.02202)
[4] Position: LLMs can't jump (https://openreview.net/forum?id=klU4737opt)
[5] Fork-and-Flush: Escaping Idea Basins in Autoresearch Agents (https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.07447)
[6] How models explore ideas (https://bespokelabs.ai/blog/how-models-explore-ideas)
We thank Reviewer fRdc for recognizing the verifiability of our setting. Below, we addressed the concerns you raised related to parent-paper selection, data construction, and downstream application of our task.
Thank you for raising this. We agree that expert ratings and agreement between LLM judges cannot establish the authors' actual sources of inspiration. As the reviewer suggests, we therefore validated our parent selection against the original authors.
ScholarCatalyst [3] is a recently released dataset in which 184 authors labeled, for 207 of their own recent papers, which prior papers inspired the work and which plausible candidates did not. We ran our unchanged parent-identification step on all 207 papers: the same prompt, with the full PDF as input. One difference is the model: we used gemini-3.7-flash, because gemini-2.5-flash is no longer available to API users. Of the 414 selected parents, 72% are papers the authors themselves marked as inspirations, and only 4% were explicitly rejected by the authors. The remaining 24% were never shown to the authors, so they carry no label, and we count them as not confirmed. Among selected parents that the authors did judge, 95% were inspirations, compared with 44% for a randomly chosen paper from the same author-judged pool. 86% of pairs contain at least one author-confirmed parent, and 58% have both. ScholarCatalyst's own model-based reconstruction reaches a similar level of agreement with the authors: 58.2% precision for the main research question, versus 56.2% for our parents on the same criterion. This suggests that LLM selection from a paper's cited works recovers genuine inspirations far above chance, though not perfectly. We will add this analysis and its scope (computer science, papers from 2025 onward) to the paper.
On the research setting. GIANTS does not require the selected parents to be the complete or sole origin of the target paper. It requires that the target insight be predictable from them. Appendix E.2 tests this directly. Similarity falls from 4.90 with both true parents to 2.99 with one parent, 1.98 when a parent is replaced by an unrelated paper, and 1.00 with no parents. So the target insight is recoverable from the selected parents and not from a prior over target insights. Any remaining noise in parent selection is shared by all models, so it does not affect the comparison between them. Together with the author-level evidence above, we believe this supports the benchmark as a test of synthesizing insights from the literature that actually inspired the work.
Thank you for pointing this out. We will add the full construction funnel and the exclusion rules to the appendix. We summarize both here, along with new evidence on how often a two-parent structure fits real papers.
We ran the parent-identification prompt on 519,380 arXiv papers. Two parent titles could be extracted for 503,761 (97.0%). The remaining 3.0% were excluded. These were API failures (0.1%) and, mostly, responses that named papers without the required output tags. Explicit statements that no suitable pair exists were very rare (39 papers, under 0.01%). We then applied fully automatic exclusion rules, with no manual handling: (1) Both parent titles must exactly match a published paper whose full text we could obtain and summarize. 112,803 papers remain. This step also removes hallucinated or garbled titles, which cannot match. (2) The target paper must have at least two citations. 110,373 papers remain. The temporal train/test split and per-domain sampling are then applied to these 84,895 papers.
How often do two parents fit? To measure how restrictive the two-parent assumption is, we used ScholarCatalyst [3], in which 184 authors labeled the key inspirations of 207 of their own papers. Most papers have at least two key inspirations, and only 13% have exactly one.
The median is three, and 87% of papers have two or more. Forcing exactly two parents is therefore rarely asking for something that does not exist. For papers with more than two key inspirations, the selected pair is a subset of the paper's true foundations, which matches the task: the target insight only has to be predictable from the given parents. We also ran our pipeline on these papers. For the 13% with a single key inspiration, the forced second pick was rarely wrong: authors rejected only 6% of those picks.