- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The method formulates RGB face anti-spoofing as relational reasoning over complementary physical cues. It builds a Physical Semantic Graph over texture, frequency, geometry, reflectance, and physiological evidence, and uses consistency regularization to distinguish genuine faces from attacks. Cross-dataset experiments show competitive generalization.
Critical strengths
A key strength is the clear conceptual shift from feature-driven fusion to relational reasoning over complementary physical semantics. The Physical Semantic Graph provides an interpretable way to model dependencies among texture, frequency, geometry, reflectance, and physiological cues, which gives the method a stronger physical motivation than conventional cue aggregation. A second strength is the cross-dataset evaluation, which shows that the proposed consistency-based reasoning achieves competitive generalization across multiple FAS benchmarks; this is particularly important because cross-domain robustness is a central challenge in FAS.
Critical weaknesses
However, several issues are required to be clarified:
-
My major concern is the technical novelty of the proposed method. GCN-based relational modeling has been widely explored, while the current design appears to introduce only limited architectural innovation. The authors should provide a more insightful explanation of the methodological novelty and clarify what fundamentally distinguishes the proposed graph reasoning mechanism from existing GCN-based approaches.
-
Why are these five physical semantics—texture, frequency, depth, reflectance, and physiology-related cues—selected as graph nodes? The authors should provide stronger justification for this choice and discuss whether these semantics are sufficiently comprehensive to characterize facial liveness or whether other relevant physical cues may have been overlooked.
-
Only one method published in 2026 is included in the comparison. The authors are encouraged to compare with more recent approaches to better demonstrate the competitiveness and superiority of the proposed model against the latest advances.
-
Qualitative results should also be provided to illustrate the relative importance of different physical semantics across representative cases and to show how each semantic cue contributes to the final liveness prediction.
Questions for authors
Please clarify several points that could materially affect my assessment: first, what is the key technical novelty of the proposed graph reasoning mechanism beyond existing GCN-based relational modeling, and which specific design choices fundamentally distinguish it from prior graph-based FAS methods; second, what theoretical or empirical basis supports selecting texture, frequency, depth, reflectance, and physiology-related semantics as the five graph nodes, and whether these cues are intended to comprehensively characterize facial liveness; and third, given that only one 2026 method is included, how should the reported performance be interpreted relative to more recent FAS approaches and whether the main conclusions are expected to remain competitive. As a suggestion for future work, qualitative case-level analyses showing how different physical semantics contribute to individual predictions would further improve interpretability.