- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EviTrace uses spoof-type-supervised evidence slots and confidence-guided residual refinement for face anti-spoofing. A coarse prediction routes uncertain samples to selected slots and patches, exposing an explicit intermediate trace. Training uses CelebA-Spoof, and evaluation covers eleven target datasets with component ablations, slot suppression, and measured inference costs.
Critical strengths
- The intermediate variables are connected to the actual prediction path. Slot suppression and routing/patch ablations provide more meaningful evidence than visualizations alone, while the residual formulation preserves a concrete coarse-to-fine decision process.
- The evaluation covers diverse unseen domains and separates discriminative from generative comparators. The appendix also reports actual mixed-batch latency, making the limits of selective-computation savings explicit.
Critical weaknesses
- The trace exposes auditable computation, but does not yet provide a validated explanation of spoof cues. Slots are supervised by attack-type labels, and suppressing a predictive slot establishes functional relevance rather than semantic correctness or localization faithfulness. The paper acknowledges this distinction, which still limits its central interpretability claim.
- The richer-supervision control uses a plain ViT-B, whereas EviTrace uses a CLIP-pretrained backbone. It therefore does not fully isolate the contribution of structured slots from a conventional CLIP-based classifier with the same ten-way supervision and training setup.
Questions for authors
- How does EviTrace compare with a CLIP-based ten-way auxiliary classifier trained with the same labels, sampler, and optimization budget?
- Can sample-level cue annotations or targeted region interventions validate slot semantics and the relevance of DPR-selected patches?
3 comments
[Q2] Matched supervision for structured evidence slots
Thank you for raising this point. The original plain ViT-B control was designed to assess the benefit of adding ten-way attack-type supervision on a fixed backbone. To isolate the contribution of the slot design under matched CLIP pretraining, we added a conventional auxiliary head that predicts the ten attack types from the global CLS feature alongside the binary live/spoof task.
The CLS auxiliary-head and slot-supervised variants use the same CLIP ViT-B/16 initialization, ten attack-type labels, sampling strategy, and optimization settings. Both use a type-loss weight of 0.15, with slot–text alignment and DPR disabled.
| CLIP ViT-B/16 variant | Avg. HTER (%) ↓ | Avg. AUC (%) ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| Binary classification only | 21.01 | 85.68 |
| Binary classification + evidence slot tokens | 21.31 | 85.43 |
| Binary classification + CLS auxiliary type head | 22.61 | 83.96 |
| Evidence slot tokens + slot-wise type supervision | 15.13 | 89.43 |
Across the 11 target datasets, slot-wise supervision reduces average HTER from 22.61% to 15.13% and increases average AUC from 83.96% to 89.43% compared with the CLS auxiliary head. Adding slot tokens alone yields performance close to that of the binary baseline. The gains emerge when the attack-type labels supervise the slots.
One possible explanation is that the auxiliary head places two demands on the same global CLS feature. The type classifier uses it to distinguish among attacks, while the binary classifier uses it to group those attacks into a single spoof class. Dedicated slots give the model a place to learn distinct attack cues and combine their pooled representations with the global CLS feature for the binary decision. The matched results support the benefit of organizing and using the same attack-type supervision through dedicated evidence slots.
We will add the matched CLS auxiliary-head comparison to Table 2 and clarify the purpose of the original plain ViT-B control in the revised manuscript.
[Q3] Validation of slot semantics and DPR-selected patches
Thank you for suggesting these validation tests. As shown in our response to Q1, the matched Print/Replay interventions support attack-family-level semantic specificity. Here, we further evaluate the functional relevance of the slots and patches selected by DPR through equal-count removal experiments.
Functional relevance of DPR-selected patches. For the patch intervention, we fixed the slots used to retrieve patches and removed either the 49 patches originally selected by DPR or 49 randomly sampled patches from the same candidate pool. DPR then retrieved 49 patches from the remaining candidates using the original affinity rule. We also ran an analogous comparison for the four slots selected by DPR. All conditions used the same checkpoint, coarse predictions, routed samples, and decision threshold. HTER was computed over the full SiW test set.
| Inference condition | Number removed | HTER (%) ↓ | Absolute HTER increase (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original EviTrace | 0 | 1.69 | 0.00 |
| Remove random slots | 4 | 3.03 | +1.34 |
| Remove DPR-selected slots | 4 | 6.36 | +4.67 |
| Remove random patches | 49 | 2.05 | +0.36 |
| Remove DPR-selected patches | 49 | 5.09 | +3.40 |
Removing DPR-selected patches increased HTER by 3.40% in absolute terms, compared with 0.36% for equal-count random removal. Because DPR used the same number of patches in both conditions, this difference supports the contribution of the particular regions selected by DPR to the final decision. The slot intervention supports attack-family semantics, and the patch intervention supports the functional relevance of the selected regions. Sample-level annotations of specific cues and their locations would enable a finer-grained test of whether individual slots capture those cues and whether DPR localizes them.
[Q1] Interpretability of the reasoning trace
Thank you for raising this concern. We agree that IRT provides an auditable inference trace, but attack-type supervision alone does not establish the semantic correctness of individual spoof cues. To further assess its interpretability, we conducted matched slot interventions on SiW to evaluate whether the learned evidence slots exhibit attack-family-level semantic selectivity.
Attack-family selectivity of the slots. We grouped the annotated attacks into Print and Replay. We suppressed either the three print slots (Photo, Poster, and A4) or the three display slots (PC, Pad, and Phone), using the same suppression procedure, checkpoint, test videos, and decision threshold. We report APCER, the fraction of attack videos incorrectly accepted as bona fide, separately for each attack family.
For Print attacks, suppressing the print slots increases APCER from 1.40% to 3.26%, compared with 1.63% when suppressing display slots. For Replay attacks, suppressing the display slots increases APCER from 1.59% to 4.16%, compared with 1.59% when suppressing print slots. The reversal across the two attack families supports semantic selectivity at the attack-family level. Each slot group has a larger effect on the detection of its corresponding attack family. The functional relevance of DPR-selected slots and patches is further evaluated through matched removal experiments, as detailed in our response to Q3.