- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
WireForge proposes a framework for low-poly mesh generation guided by 2D wireframe priors. A 2D wireframe-generation agent produces and refines references from text instructions or sketches. The framework associates 2D wireframe features with 3D spatial anchors on the input mesh by injecting them into a mesh-generation backbone through cross-attention. The paper aims to improve geometric fidelity while enabling user-directed control of edge layouts.
Critical strengths
-
Useful problem. Geometric similarity alone does not guarantee meaningful or artist-friendly edge layouts. Explicit wireframe guidance is a reasonable way to address this limitation.
-
Intuitive user interface. Text- and sketch-based wireframe specification could make mesh layout control more accessible and flexible.
-
Modular conditioning design. The proposed mechanism can be adaptable to different mesh-generation backbones.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main contribution is not clearly defined. The title emphasizes low-poly mesh generation, Tables 1 and 2 mainly evaluate geometric fidelity, and Figure 7 demonstrates user-directed edge-layout control. These correspond to different research objectives, but the paper does not establish which is its primary contribution. As a result, the method analysis and experiments are insufficient for each of the three possible claims. The authors should clearly define the main objective and align the method, baselines, and evaluation with it.
-
Relevant work on low-poly generation and mesh topology is insufficiently covered. Low-poly Mesh Generation for Building Models (SIGGRAPH 2022) is directly relevant to low-poly mesh generation. More recent work, including TriFlow: Generating Artist-Like 3D Mesh Topology via Nearest-Vertex Vector Fields (2026), also addresses geometry-conditioned generation of structured, artist-like topology. SpaceMesh: A Continuous Representation for Learning Manifold Surface Meshes (SIGGRAPH Asia 2024) learns polygonal mesh connectivity, while Mesh-controllable Multi-level-of-detail Text-to-3D Generation (Computers & Graphics 2024) studies controllable mesh complexity. These works should be discussed to clarify the distinction between geometric simplification, topology generation, and user-directed layout control. LATO (ICML 2026), which is already cited, should also be considered in the experimental comparison where the tasks are compatible.
-
The central edge-layout control claim lacks direct evaluation. The current geometric metrics, such as surface distance and normal error, do not establish whether generated edges preserve salient 3D features or follow the specified 2D wireframe. Figure 7 provides qualitative evidence, but it is insufficient to establish reliable controllability. The paper should quantify projected wireframe alignment, 3D feature preservation, and compliance with different layout instructions. The butterfly in fig 7 is an good example. But the inconsistency between the 2d and 3d wireframes in the sideview of the bus in fig 7 should be discussed.
-
The contribution of wireframe density and layout is unclear. If the primary goal is low-poly generation, the authors should disentangle the effects of wireframe density and edge arrangement. It is also important to determine whether existing mesh-generation methods followed by QEM simplification can achieve comparable geometric fidelity at similar face counts. Such comparisons would help establish the added value of the proposed pipeline.
Questions for authors
-
What is the primary contribution: accurate mesh generation, low-poly mesh generation, or user-controllable edge-layout generation? How does each major experiment support that claim?
-
How much do wireframe density and wireframe layout independently contribute to the results? Can the authors provide controlled ablations and compare against existing mesh-generation methods followed by QEM simplification at matched face counts?
-
How do the authors quantitatively evaluate alignment between the input 2D wireframe and the generated 3D edge layout? Can they report 3D feature-preservation metrics and demonstrate consistent compliance with different text instructions and wireframe references?
-
Paired supervision. How to pair QEM results with the edge layouts generated by WirePilot? What is a successful pair and what is not?
4 comments
Official Response by Authors – Part 2
Wireframe density, edge arrangement, and QEM comparisons
In WireForge, both polygon density and edge arrangement are controlled through the wireframe reference, rather than through separate parameters. In particular, we do not specify an explicit face-count parameter at inference; the model learns to infer the approximate polygon density and layout style from the reference wireframe map.
Our experiments demonstrate these two aspects of control: Figure 5 varies wireframe density to produce meshes with different polygon complexities, while Figure 8 modifies edge arrangements at a similar intended density to demonstrate layout customization. Thus, both capabilities are enabled through the same editable wireframe interface.
Regarding QEM, it is a geometry-driven simplification method that does not directly support user-specified edge-layout control. We also observed that QEM can produce damaged regions or severe local geometric degradation on challenging inputs, particularly those with non-manifold geometry or uneven polygon distributions. Therefore, our objective is not simply to improve geometric approximation at a prescribed face count, but to enable reference-guided structural control during mesh generation.
Paired supervision and WirePilot references
For the additional adaptation stage involving approximately 9,000 WirePilot references, we use a vision model for initial screening, followed by manual inspection to select references with approximately matching edge-layout styles, polygon density, and geometric structure relative to the corresponding target meshes.
The purpose is not to require exact edge correspondence, but to retain consistent training pairs while exposing the model to the variations introduced by WirePilot at inference time.
At inference, WirePilot generates the structural references without access to the ground-truth target mesh.
Accept
Thank you for these tests and clarifications. I support the acceptance of the paper.
Thank you for your response! We are glad our reply addressed your concerns, and we appreciate your recognition of our work.
Official Response by Authors – Part 1
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the value of this work and for the constructive feedback. We address each concern below.
Clarifying the primary contribution
The primary objective of WireForge is controllable edge-layout generation for low-poly meshes under a given surface geometry. Introducing wireframe guidance improves geometric fidelity while enabling control over edge-layout styles.
A single surface can admit many plausible polygonal layouts. Existing surface-conditioned mesh generators largely rely on learned mesh priors to determine these layouts, but generally lack an explicit interface for specifying alternative edge arrangements. WireForge addresses this underdetermination by introducing an editable 2D wireframe reference as additional structural guidance.
Our experiments demonstrate both the geometric benefits and structural controllability of this guidance:
Related work and positioning
Due to space limitations, we focused our discussion on representative milestones and recent influential methods. We appreciate the suggested references and have added SpaceMesh (SIGGRAPH Asia 2024) and TriFlow (ECCV 2026) to the revised PDF. Given the space constraints, we have prioritized representative works most directly relevant to our methodological contributions.
Regarding LATO, our experiments already include its newer iteration, LATO.2, in Table 1 and Figure 4. Given the limited space and evaluation resources, we prioritized this updated version rather than additionally evaluating the original LATO.
Quantitative evaluation of edge-layout control We additionally evaluate rendering-based metrics across existing mesh-generation baselines, using the same reference budget of s=3000 for WireForge.
Importantly, existing baselines do not accept wireframe references as conditions. Evaluating their outputs against our WirePilot references is therefore not a fully fair comparison of controllability. Nevertheless, we report these results.
For a more comparable assessment of polygonal layout quality, we also conducted a user study (Appendix A.6), in which participants ranked the overall quality of generated meshes under the same input geometry. WireForge received 82.8% of the Top-2 selections.
Regarding the butterfly and bus examples in Figure 8, our wireframe serves as a soft structural prior, guiding polygon density and edge arrangement rather than enforcing exact correspondence. Figure 8 demonstrates that different wireframe references can produce distinct layouts under the same geometry condition, while precise per-edge alignment remains a limitation.