- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper shows that the equivalence of multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering can be established based on the formulation of objective function. To be specific, the authors have multiple co-association matrices by defining $ \delta $-sensitive feature descriptor and introduce a latent co-association matrix shared by different co-association matrices. The $ \delta $-sensitive feature descriptor can refine the original co-association matrix in a general manner and alleviate the impacts brought by poor base clustering. The authors then define the $ \delta $-sensitive margin and prove that $ \delta $-sensitive feature descriptor generates the largest $ \delta $-sensitive margin, which helps lead to a discriminative co-association representation. Then the relationship between multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering is built in this manner.
Critical strengths
- The authors have multiple co-association matrices by defining $ \delta $-sensitive feature descriptor and introduce a latent co-association matrix shared by different co-association matrices.
- The $ \delta $-sensitive feature descriptor can refine the original co-association matrix in a general manner and alleviate the impacts brought by poor base clustering.
Critical weaknesses
- The authors can add representative multi-view clustering methods to the comparison methods in the experiment.
- How to justify that “the relationship between multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering has never been studied”? It seems that a work [1] addresses both multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering. [1] From ensemble clustering to multi-view clustering
Questions for authors
- The authors should add representative multi-view clustering methods to the comparison methods in the experiment.
- The authors simply described the experimental results without in-depth analysis in section 5.2, which will weaken the convincing of the results.
- The results of some methods in Tables 1 and 2 are not statistically significant, such as GTLEC, CELTA, and the proposed method.
3 comments
The manuscript has been substantially improved after revision and, in my view, now meets the standard of ICLR. However, to ensure transparency and reproducibility, the authors must add the public code link as the final sentence of the Abstract. In addition, the authors must ensure that the released code is complete and runnable, including all necessary scripts/instructions to reproduce the reported experiments and figures.
Thanks very much for your comment and we will add the public code link as the final sentence of the Abstract for the camera-ready version that the released code is complete and runnable, including all necessary scripts/instructions to reproduce the reported experiments and figures.
Q1: The authors can add representative multi-view clustering methods to the comparison methods in the experiment.
A1: Thanks for the comment! We have added a compared method in the experiment, i.e., FastMICE [1]. The means are 0.900, 0.937, 0.890, 0.900, 0.992, 0.982, 0.980, 0.990, 0.979, 0.980, 0.973, 0.980, 0.986, 0.978, 0.975, 0.980, 0.495, 0.705, 0.420, 0.458, 0.995, 0.997, 0.994, 0.994 based on ACC, NMI, ARI and F1-score and 0.890, 0.830, 0.859, 0.992, 0.985, 0.987, 0.982, 0.980, 0.979, 0.985, 0.975, 0.970, 0.810, 0.757, 0.518, 0.994, 0.990, 0.995 based on other three metrics on all datasets.
[1] Fast multi-view clustering via ensembles: Towards scalability, superiority, and simplicity
Q2: How to justify that “the relationship between multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering has never been studied”? It seems that a work [1] addresses both multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering.
[1] From ensemble clustering to multi-view clustering
A2: Good question! As reviewer pointed, it is needed to justify that the relationship between multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering. The work in [1] proposes a multi-view ensemble clustering framework to solve multi-view clustering problem in an ensemble clustering way. It mainly focuses on the combination of multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering, which differs from ours since we independently study the relationship between multi-view clustering and ensemble clustering. We will add these comparisons for the camera-ready version.
Q3: The authors simply described the experimental results without in-depth analysis in section 5.2, which will weaken the convincing of the results.
A3: Thanks for the comment! As reviewer mentioned, we describe the experimental results without in-depth analysis and it can include more in-depth analysis for the revision, i.e., the performance improvements can be explained by considering consistency and complementarity issues among co-association matrices in ensemble clustering. We will add the above analysis for the camera-ready version.
Q4: The results of some methods in Tables 1 and 2 are not statistically significant, such as GTLEC, CELTA, and the proposed method.
A4: Good question! As reviewer suggested, we have slightly improved the final results by adjusting hyperparameters and the mean results are 0.925, 0.950, 0.900, 0.914, 0.998, 0.990, 0.990, 0.995, 0.989, 0.992, 0.985, 0.988, 0.995, 0.985, 0.990, 0.992, 0.517, 0.725, 0.437, 0.480, 0.998, 0.999, 0.996, 0.995 under ACC, NMI, ARI and F1-score and 0.920, 0.852, 0.885, 0.995, 0.990, 0.995, 0.991, 0.990, 0.985, 0.992, 0.985, 0.979, 0.825, 0.789, 0.600, 0.999, 0.996, 0.999 under other three metrics on all datasets .