- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes IBEC-MVC, an Information Bottleneck Enhanced Contrastive Multi-View Clustering framework. It integrates three components: Information Bottleneck-guided Progressive Matrix Factorization (IB-PMF), Entropy-Regularized Self-Supervised Contrastive Learning (ER-SCL), and Mutual Information Maximization for View Consistency (MIM-VC). The method aims to preserve clustering-relevant information during progressive dimensionality reduction, prevent cluster collapse through entropy regularization, and adaptively fuse heterogeneous views via mutual information maximization. Theoretical results include information preservation, contrastive convergence, consensus mutual information bound, and global convergence. Experiments are conducted on five benchmark datasets against 17 baselines, with reported improvements in ACC and NMI.
Critical strengths
The paper proposes a principled integration of information bottleneck, contrastive learning, and mutual information maximization for multi-view clustering.
IB-PMF introduces progressive matrix factorization with information-theoretic compression, which is a reasonable way to preserve clustering-relevant information.
ER-SCL addresses the important cluster collapse problem through entropy regularization.
MIM-VC provides an adaptive view fusion mechanism based on mutual information and view quality.
The paper reports competitive performance on five benchmark datasets and compares against many recent baselines.
Critical weaknesses
The proof of Lemma3.1 in AppendixA.1 appears incorrect. From Eq.~(17), the derivation gives
Since $I(\mathbf{X};\mathbf{Y}) \le H(\mathbf{Y})$, this does not imply
or
The claimed information preservation guarantee therefore needs to be re-proved or the assumptions must be clarified.
The experimental section is incomplete in the provided version. Table~2 only shows the header, so the main quantitative comparison cannot be verified. Complete results, standard deviations, and significance tests should be provided.
The paper claims average improvements over state-of-the-art methods, but the exact average improvements and statistical significance are not clearly reported.
Ablation studies are mentioned but not shown in detail. The individual contributions of IB-PMF, ER-SCL, and MIM-VC need to be quantified.
Hyperparameter sensitivity is not adequately discussed. Important parameters include , , , , , , , and . The selection strategy and robustness across datasets should be clarified.
Some notation and formulas need correction. For example, the definition of in Eq.(7) uses , but the index/dimension convention is unclear. The consensus constraint in Eq.(12) also needs clearer explanation.
Reproducibility details are insufficient: data preprocessing, train/test splits, random seeds, number of runs, and code availability are not fully described.
The paper should better distinguish its contributions from existing information bottleneck, NMF-based, and contrastive multi-view clustering methods.
Questions for authors
Can you correct or clarify the proof of Lemma~3.1? Under what assumptions does the information preservation bound hold?
Can you provide the complete Table~2 with all baseline results, standard deviations, and statistical significance tests?
How are the hyperparameters selected? Can you provide sensitivity analysis for , , --, and ?
Can you report the full ablation study showing the effect of removing IB-PMF, ER-SCL, and MIM-VC?
Please clarify the notation in Eq.(7) and Eq.(12), especially the cluster assignment and consensus regularization terms.
Can you provide computational complexity analysis and runtime comparisons with the baselines?
Will code and implementation details be released to support reproducibility?
Although some minor issues have been addressed, the core concerns remain unresolved: the original formulation contains explicit sign errors and vanishing terms, and the theoretical justifications are post-hoc rather than causal. Therefore, I maintain my original score.