- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes VIR-SCI, which re-models the information fusion in multi-view clustering as an incremental reasoning process. This method exploits complementary information through symmetric cross-view interactions and achieves selective fusion by using feature-level adaptive modulation. Additionally, it combines mutual information constraints with contrastive learning to maintain semantic consistency. Experiments on six benchmark datasets demonstrate that this method has excellent clustering performance, and ablation experiments also validate the effectiveness of the main modules.
Critical strengths
- The method design is innovative. Compared with the traditional one-time multi-view fusion, the paper proposes a symmetrical cross-view incremental interaction mechanism, combined with feature-level modulation, to more meticulously model the complementary relationship between different views.
- The framework design is relatively complete. Mutual information constraints, cross-view interaction, and feature-level fusion cooperate with each other, resulting in a method with good logical coherence.
- The experimental results are persuasive. The method achieves the best results in terms of ACC, NMI, and PUR metrics on six benchmark datasets, and provides sufficient ablation experiments, parameter sensitivity analysis, and visualization results.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper can further analyze the computational complexity and running time of the model to more fully illustrate the scalability of the symmetric cross-view interaction mechanism when the number of views increases.
- It is suggested to further clarify the essential difference between incremental reasoning and conventional attention-weighted fusion to highlight the uniqueness of the method.
- The current experiments are mainly based on standard multi-view clustering datasets. The generalization ability in higher dimensions or more complex noise environments still deserves further research.
Questions for authors
- As the number of views increases, how does the computational cost of symmetric cross-view interaction change?
- Compared to directly using cross-view attention fusion, does the proposed incremental reasoning mechanism have independent and stable performance advantages?
Reply to Reviewer RETX
Thanks for your careful review. We are glad to address your questions one by one.
W1: We have provided a detailed analysis of the computational complexity and runtime of VIR-SCI. Please refer to
YX5gW2. We have also conducted additional experiments to evaluate the scalability of symmetric cross-view interaction as the number of views increases. For details, please refer to Q1.W2: Conventional attention-weighted fusion directly calculates view importance weights and aggregates different views into a fused representation, focusing on weighted information aggregation. In contrast, VIR-SCI first excludes the current view and takes the remaining views as anchors in turn to infer complementary information through anchor–candidate interactions (Eqs. (8)–(9)). It then combines the current view with the incremental representations to generate feature-wise importance weights and selectively injects the complementary information into the current view (Eqs. (10)–(13)). Therefore, the key difference is that VIR-SCI focuses on cross-view complementary information inference and selective feature-wise injection, rather than simply improving the calculation of attention weights.
W3: We have conducted additional noise robustness experiments by adding 10%–50% Gaussian noise to one input view of each of the three datasets: MNIST-USPS, Fashion, and Cifar100, and re-evaluated the clustering performance of VIR-SCI. The results show that VIR-SCI maintains relatively stable clustering performance even under high noise levels. For example, on Fashion, the ACC decreases by only 1.47% when the noise level reaches 50%. These results demonstrate the robustness of VIR-SCI against noise interference.
Values are reported as ACC / NMI / PUR.
Q1: We have conducted additional experiments on Caltech-5V to evaluate runtime and memory consumption with different numbers of views. As the number of views increases from 2 to 5, memory consumption rises from 133.36 MB to 374.11 MB, while runtime shows an overall modest increase from 194.33s to 246.01s. These results indicate that although symmetric cross-view interaction introduces additional computational costs, VIR-SCI maintains manageable runtime and memory consumption as the number of views increases, demonstrating its scalability in few-view scenarios.
Q2: Conventional cross-view attention fusion directly aggregates view information based on their correlation weights, making it difficult to explicitly identify complementary information beneficial to the current view. In contrast, VIR-SCI first infers cross-view complementary information through symmetric interactions that exclude the current view, and then selectively injects it through feature-wise modulation to reduce redundancy. Meanwhile, normalized additive fusion and semantic consistency constraints help maintain representation stability. The existing ablation study (M20) also demonstrates the contribution of incremental reasoning over simple one-shot fusion. Therefore, VIR-SCI improves not only information weighting but also complementary information inference and selective fusion.