- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a new network, called Constrained Triple-Head Price Optimization (C3PO), that aims to provide prices of services to customers. The input features of the network is the customer features as well as the historical prices. Given the inputs, the network consists of three sequential stages: 1) encoding the features through transformers, 2) taking elasticity prior as new inputs to enable in-context learning, 3) two heads that output the price and revenue. The training of the network consists of three learning paradigms: 1) imitation learning that makes the output price to approximate the labeled optimal price; 2) learning the revenue head such that the output revenue predicts the true revenue caused by the output price; 3) In-context learning with elasticity priors. Experiments show that the proposed network outperforms a calibrated MNL baseline.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
-
The paper suffers from severe presentation issues, making me hard to understand the core contributions of the paper, which I also believe is not solely caused by my unfamiliarity with the topic. Therefore, I can not recommend acceptance at this stage. Here are some examples:
- The paper lacks mathematical notations to formally formulate the problem of this paper. There're only very few notations, e.g., paragraphs around equation (1) and (3). Many concepts are described only informally (for few examples, the elasticity priors, the discrete choices model etc.) I believe that the presentation requires a major revision before acceptance.
- For another example, in line 140-142, the paper formulates the goal as "Instead, a desirable theoretical guarantee is that, for any discrete choice model, the probabilities it generates can be approximated by those produced by the model, or equivalently, that the induced utility functions are themselves universally approximable". I can not understand this sentence. I also do not how this goal connects to the other part of this paper.
- Even in places where mathematical notations are used, they are not complete enough neither. For example, the paper does not describe the expression of each term in loss function in equation (2).
- Some sentences are overclaimed, e.g., in line 72-73, the paper says "the proposed approach is applicable beyond pricing to many other problem areas such as optimal product design, assortment optimization, transportation planning, and marketing, among others". However, no experiments support this claim, so this is better framed as future works.
-
In addition to the presentation issue, I also do not see too many contributions from the paper. The network architecture largely uses transformers as building block. The training paradigms are also similar to supervised learning. Theoretical results (e.g., Theorem 4.4) seem very straightforward. The significance and difficulty of the studied problem are also not satisfactorily justified. The main contribution seems to be a direct application of machine learning to a new problem, which I believe has limited contribution, and given the competitiveness of ICLR, does not warrants an acceptance either.
Questions for authors
None