acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Skill-Forming Evidence for LLM Agents: Joint Selection and Target-Model-Aware Compilation

Abstract

LLM agents increasingly turn stored trajectories into reusable skills. Recent work has begun to show that trajectory composition can materially change downstream skill quality, alongside continued progress in skill extraction. We ask the next structural question: what makes a set of trajectories sufficient for forming a trans- ferable skill, and how should that evidence be represented for the target model? We formulate skill induction as two coupled decisions over experience: selec- tion, which chooses the trajectories that jointly identify transferable structure, and compilation, which expresses that selected evidence in a form the target model can use. In an exact Conditional Procedure World, six machine-verified proposi- tions show that skill-forming value can be irreducibly joint, that sparse support sets can preserve full-pool utility, and that the preferred evidence can change with the target model. Neural experiments reproduce these mechanisms across Pythia, Qwen2.5, and SmolLM2. Closed-loop tests then show that these data decisions matter for agent performance. On ALFWorld, changing the selected trajectories moves success from 0.164 to 0.351, and the gain from success-only selection replicates across five prospective experience pools. Raw delivery of the same failure-inclusive evidence reduces success by 0.157 relative to compi- lation. On TextWorld, a compiler that encodes episode-varying recipe content hurts transfer, whereas an invariant-aware compiler reverses the effect. Together, these results characterize skill-forming evidence as a jointly structured and target- model-dependent object: effective skills require informative trajectory sets and a representation that preserves their transferable structure for the model that uses the skill.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, skill induction, trajectory selection, experience reuse, in-context learning, agent skills, target-model-aware compilation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_g26DOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how trajectory selection and target-model-aware compilation affect reusable skill formation in LLM agents.

Critical strengths
  1. Interesting perspective: The paper highlights the importance of complementary trajectories and joint evidence in skill formation.
  2. Extensive experiments: The authors provide theoretical analysis and empirical evaluations across synthetic and real agent environments.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Theory–practice gap: Despite emphasizing joint evidence, simple success-only selection achieves the best results on ALFWorld.
  2. Limited generalizability: The theoretical analysis relies on simplified synthetic settings, while compilation depends on domain-specific heuristics.
Questions for authors

N/A

Reviewer_qhzBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper splits skill induction from agent trajectories into two steps. Selection decides which trajectories jointly pin down a procedure, and compilation decides how that evidence is shown to the target model. An exact toy world (CPW) gives six small propositions on joint value, small support sets and reader-dependent optimal subsets. The same manipulations are then probed on Pythia, Qwen2.5 and SmolLM2. In closed loop, success-only k=4 selection lifts a Qwen2.5-7B ALFWorld agent from .231 to .351 and replicates on five new pools. On TextWorld, a compiler that drops recipe names turns a harmful skill into a helpful one.

Critical strengths
  1. The selection vs compilation split is tested with matched designs at each level, including a real 2x2 on the same 134 ALFWorld games. This makes it possible to tell whether a gain comes from what was kept or from how it was shown, and most skill papers don't separate the two.
  2. The statistical reporting is unusually transparent. It has paired tests, five newly collected pools, leave-one-task-type-out checks, multiplicity correction, and a table that also lists null and boundary results (Table 7). This is the main reason I believe the ALFWorld selection effect.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The selector that the theory recommends doesn't win once a real model reads the evidence. With Pythia, the four-record support set is about tied with a random four-record subset, as Table 2 and Appendix B.1 show. Positive coverage beats version-space greedy under both the raw and the compiled interface in Table 4. ALFWorld never uses this selector, so the support-set result mostly holds only in the exact Conditional Procedure World.
  2. The ALFWorld headline partly reuses development games. Table 7 describes the evaluation games as a development set plus a pre-specified extension. The untouched game tranche gives a smaller gain that is not statistically significant, and Section 4.3.1 doesn't mention this. The success range quoted in the abstract also runs from the worst selector to the best selector, so it is not the gain over the no-skill baseline.
  3. The claim that compilation is target-model-aware isn't backed by the closed-loop part. No compiler adapts to the reader, and only one agent model is used. The 7B probe says clean failures help, yet raw failure-inclusive evidence drops the 7B ALFWorld agent below the no-skill baseline.
  4. The TextWorld fix is a hand-written rule that removes ingredient and recipe names. It was added after looking at ingredient counts in the evaluation games, and it is tested on a small set of games with only a few recipe variants. The automatic variance compiler still loses to the no-skill baseline on TextWorld. So the claim about preserving cross-episode invariants rests on one intervention.
Questions for authors
  1. What is in the no-skill ALFWorld prompt? If it has no in-context examples, success-only k=4 is close to just adding same-type successful demos, and a standard ReAct [1] few-shot baseline would be the fair comparison.
  2. What does the fixed compiler keep from failure trajectories? If it mostly drops them, Section 4.3.2 compares showing failures vs. removing them, not two encodings of the same evidence.
  3. Table 6 notes that the winning arm is also the shortest compiled one. Is there a token-matched raw control for the raw vs. compiled comparison?
  4. SkillLens [2] reports that failure-heavy pools work best on ALFWorld, while here success-only wins. How do you reconcile these results on the same benchmark?
  5. Are the five prospective pools evaluated on the same 134 games used to develop the compiler and protocol?
  6. Several numbers don't match. The budget-6 interaction is +.121 and +.099 in the text but +.07 in the budget sweep. Section 4.3.3 says the standard compiler reaches at most .317, but both standard arms are .267. In Appendix B.1, the chance that a random four-record subset covers the skewed 7/7/1/1 pool should be about .027, not .05. Which values are correct?

[1] ReAct: Synergizing Reasoning and Acting in Language Models. [2] From Raw Experience to Skill Consumption: A Systematic Study of Model-Generated Agent Skills.

Reviewer_1vNxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

We understand this paper as studying how agents turn trajectories into reusable skills, with a focus on two stages: evidence selection and compilation. The paper uses conditional procedure world to analyze complementary evidence, and reader-dependent representations, then explores these ideas through lm probes and ALFWorld&TextWorld experiments.

Critical strengths
  1. We find the separation of selection and compilation useful for understanding where skill improvements come from.

  2. The repeated ALFWorld evaluations, statistical analysis, and transparent reporting of negative results.

Critical weaknesses
  1. We see a gap between the claims and the real-agent evidence. it depends heavily on pre-defined environments and readers, while ALFWorld performs best with simple success-only selection. The experiments do not directly establish the benefits of joint evidence selection or target model-aware compilation.

  2. We are not convinced that the gains consistently exceed simpler alternatives. Support sets beat random selection in only two of four Table 2 settings, and Table 7 reports no significant advantage over self-consolidation. Alfworld and textworld are the simliar tasks and how about the performance on multi-hop and webshop, even on terminal-style tasks?

Questions for authors
  1. Could you clarify which results show that joint evidence selection improves agent performance beyond simple selection standards?

  2. Do you have evidence that model-specific compilation outperforms a shared compiler in closed-loop tasks?

  3. Do the gains hold against token-matched summaries or simple entity-abstraction baselines? These comparisons would help us assess the added value.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.