- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper focuses on long video reasoning under a fixed evidence budget. The overall logic is complete, and the method modules are mainly designed around the core challenge of "finding missing evidence". Its main contribution is the valuable integration of mechanisms and the reconfiguration of the problem. The overall structure of the paper is clear, the technical description is relatively clear, and the experiments are relatively reasonable and complete.
Critical strengths
The research motivation is reasonable, and the description of the challenges is logically consistent. The key information in the long video may indeed be scattered across different times, events and perspectives. Simply relying on the ranking of relevance is prone to generating duplicate evidence. The paper progresses from "relevant evidence" to "joint evidence sufficient to answer the question", and the problem definition is highly reasonable.
The methods have a certain degree of relative innovation and have a good correspondence with the core challenges. The uniqueness of the paper lies in treating the query-side requirement graph as the dynamic control state of evidence routing, rather than merely using the graph as video memory or scene representation.
The overall structure of the paper is clear, and the technical description is relatively complete. The connection between the problem definition, methods, training objectives, experiments and appendices is natural. The algorithm flow and main formulas can support reproduction. Figures 1 and 2 express the motivation and overall architecture of the method in a relatively intuitive way, and the qualitative cases also help to illustrate how the method handles the temporal sequence and cross-event relationships.
Critical weaknesses
The motivation is valid, but the statement regarding the inadequacies of the existing methods is somewhat absolute. The paper generalizes the existing methods as correlation or diversity selection, which may give the impression that existing research generally lacks the ability to model relationships. In fact, existing work has already covered logical dependencies, scenario graphs, problem decomposition, and adaptive search, so the paper needs to more accurately distinguish "existing relationship modeling" from "the relationship state used in this paper for dynamic evidence routing".
The key argument experiments still have room for improvement. The paper needs to further discuss the impact of graph parsing errors, query complexity, candidate pool quality, and evidence budget changes on the method. The current experiments have well demonstrated that "the method is effective under the given protocol", but the discussion on the method's scope of application, failure scenarios, and actual deployment costs is still insufficient.
The chart information is rich, but some expressions can be further simplified. The overall charts can support the main conclusions, and qualitative cases also have explanatory power. Some tables simultaneously carry the main results, matching control, and routing statistics, with high information density. It is recommended to strengthen the way of highlighting the main conclusions and reduce the cost for readers to distinguish between different experimental protocols.
The ablation study is basically complete, but it lacks necessary discussion experiments. The current ablation mainly proves that the removal of each module will decrease performance, but it does not fully answer whether these modules are superior to simpler alternative solutions. For example, whether ordinary problem decomposition, no type of relationship state, or simple coverage goals can achieve similar effects, there is still a lack of direct verification.
Questions for authors
-
Please clarify the core differences of this paper compared to existing graph-based, logical search, and iterative retrieval methods.
-
Please explain why a complete necessity, sufficiency, and conflict mechanism is required. It should be demonstrated why these modules are necessary relative to simple relevance, coverage, or diversity goals, and provide comparisons of stronger alternative solutions or error cases.
-
Please provide a more precise positioning of the shortcomings of the existing research. The paper should acknowledge that existing work has introduced scenario graphs, logical dependencies, and adaptive search, and further explain that this paper addresses the more specific problem of "relationship state-driven fixed-budget evidence closure".
-
Please describe in which scenarios the method may fail. For example, when the problem analysis is inaccurate, when the required relationship exceeds the predefined types, when the candidate pool lacks key evidence, or when the problem requires open-ended reasoning, how the performance and behavior of the method change.
Dear Reviewer TBak
Dear Reviewer TBak,
Thank you for your constructive and technically insightful comments. In our rebuttal, we clarified how the QDG templates can be adapted to a new benchmark and reported parsing accuracy on VSI-Bench. We also added experiments that separate the effects of graph correction and evidence selection, evaluate sensitivity to the acquisition weights, and compare EgoSCOPE with Frame-Voyager using the same training data.
With about one day remaining in the discussion period, we would appreciate hearing whether these results address your concerns. If they do, we would be grateful if you could consider updating your evaluation. We would also be happy to clarify any remaining points.
Thank you again for your time and for helping us improve the paper!
Best wishes!