acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

VTEM: View-Transition Egocentric Memory for Long-Horizon Embodied Reasoning

Abstract

Long-horizon embodied reasoning is fundamental to the reliable deployment of embodied agents, enabling informed decision-making from observations accumulated during long-term interactions. However, existing memory-based approaches often fail to establish effective spatiotemporal associations across observations, causing redundant cross-view content to accumulate in memory and retrieval to return context-misaligned evidence. To address these limitations, we propose the View-Transition Egocentric Memory framework (VTEM), which models view transitions to support traceable memory construction and reliable evidence retrieval. VTEM comprises two core components: the View-Transition Memory Chain (TMC) and Transition-Guided Hierarchical Retrieval (THR). TMC derives spatiotemporal associations from sampled observations and uses them to assess memory value, retaining observations that contribute novel information in a hierarchical scene-view memory chain, thereby enabling efficient memory construction. THR decomposes user questions into hierarchical retrieval targets and association cues, then combines scene-view matching with transition-guided multi-hop reasoning to retrieve fine-grained, context-aligned evidence. Extensive experiments on OpenEQA, ECBench-MultiScene, and EnvQA demonstrate improvements of 7.89, 3.44, and 4.57 points over the strongest baselines, respectively, validating the effectiveness of VTEM for efficient and reliable long-horizon embodied reasoning.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Embodied AI, Long-Horizon Embodied Reasoning, Egocentric Memory, Memory-Augmented Agents, Spatiotemporal Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_E4Y5OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problems of memory accumulation and retrieval-context misalignment in long-horizon embodied reasoning. Existing approaches face challenges associated with redundant multi-view observations and accumulated long-term memories, while memory organization and retrieval can lead to context mismatches. To address these issues, the paper proposes View-Transition Egocentric Memory (VTEM). It infers scene, viewpoint, and cross-view object changes from consecutive observations, combines semantic value and visual novelty to determine which observations should be retained, and decomposes user questions into scene constraints, visual targets, and association constraints. It then performs hierarchical retrieval and conditionally conducts multi-hop retrieval along memory-transition edges when the initial evidence is insufficient. The paper evaluates VTEM primarily on OpenEQA, ECBench-MultiScene, and EnvQA, reporting improvements of 7.89, 3.44, and 4.57 score points, respectively, over the strongest baselines: 3D-Mem, GeLM, and Qwen3-VL-8B. The main contributions are:

  1. Constructing memory using view-transition relationships.
  2. Designing hierarchical multi-hop retrieval over the memory chain.
  3. Conducting extensive experiments on three major embodied question-answering benchmarks.
Critical strengths
  1. The problem is important and well motivated. Long-horizon embodied tasks can lead to substantial memory redundancy, while retrieval based on semantic or visual similarity alone has limitations and may result in context mismatches. The paper addresses a meaningful problem with a reasonable motivation.
  2. The method is clearly presented and reasonably designed. The paper incorporates view-transition relationships into memory construction to assess the value of observations, then reuses these relationships during retrieval. The overall framework is coherent and well structured.
  3. The experimental results demonstrate promising performance. The paper evaluates the method on major embodied question-answering benchmarks and reports consistent performance improvements. It also evaluates the approach on real-world observation videos, providing some evidence of its practical applicability.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The novelty of the memory construction mechanism could be further clarified. Although view-transition-based memory construction is a key contribution, the observation selection process partly relies on CLIP feature similarity, which has also been explored in prior work. It would be helpful to clarify more explicitly what distinguishes the proposed mechanism from existing approaches and what additional benefits it provides.
  2. The question decomposition strategy may pose some challenges for generalization. The retrieval stage decomposes questions into three components: scene constraints, visual targets, and association constraints. This design relies on the assumption that questions can be effectively mapped to these predefined components. It would be useful to discuss how the method handles questions that do not naturally fit this decomposition and whether its performance remains robust across diverse question formulations.
  3. The breadth of the fine-grained component evidence is limited. Table 2 and Appendix A.4 do provide module, transition, and retrieval ablations, including temporal-chain and shuffled-transition controls. However, the detailed appendix comparisons use only 50 OpenEQA questions from four trajectories. It remains unclear whether the individual component gains generalize across the full benchmarks and diverse environments.
  4. The end-to-end efficiency trade-off remains unclear. Appendix A.3 reports construction and question-time model calls: Full VTEM uses 4.68 calls per question versus 1.00 for flat retrieval, while reducing retrieved memories from 12.00 to 8.38 on the controlled subset. This analysis is useful, but wall-clock latency and exact token costs are not reported, so it is unclear when memory compression offsets the additional reasoning overhead.
Questions for authors

Could the authors report the end-to-end inference latency and the offline memory-construction cost? Specifically, under what conditions can the benefits of memory compression offset the additional overhead introduced by retrieval?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer E4Y5 (1)

Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully revised the manuscript in response to your comments, with the major revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

Weakness 1

Although view-transition-based memory construction is a key contribution, the observation selection process partly relies on CLIP feature similarity, which has also been explored in prior work. It would be helpful to clarify more explicitly what distinguishes the proposed mechanism from existing approaches and what additional benefits it provides.

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. VTEM identifies the semantic value of new observations by capturing new scene, object, or state information across views, and combines it with visual value for observation selection; CLIP similarity is only one replaceable implementation of visual value estimation (e.g., VLMo-based similarity). Therefore, VTEM does not rely heavily on CLIP similarity for observation selection. Specifically, VTEM infers scene changes, viewing-direction changes, and cross-view object changes between the current observation and the retained observation history without explicit 3D reconstruction. It then combines the resulting semantic value with visual novelty to determine the overall memory value and selectively retain high-value observations.

To further validate our design, we conduct two complementary experiments: (1) an ablation study comparing CLIP-based visual novelty alone with its combination with view-transition-based semantic value, to evaluate the contribution of semantic value assessment; and (2) a visual feature replacement experiment, replacing CLIP features with VLMo features while keeping the remaining components unchanged, to examine whether VTEM's effectiveness depends on a specific visual feature encoder. As shown in the table below, incorporating semantic value increases the normalized score from 0.400 to 0.530. Furthermore, replacing CLIP with VLMo achieves a normalized score of 0.535. These results demonstrate that semantic value assessment improves observation selection beyond visual novelty alone, while VTEM maintains comparable performance with different visual feature encoders.

MethodVisual FeatureAssociation-Guided Semantic ValueNormalized Score
Visual Novelty OnlyCLIPNo0.400
Full VTEMCLIPYes0.530
Full VTEMVLMoYes0.535
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer E4Y5 (2)

Weakness 2

The retrieval stage decomposes questions into three components: scene constraints, visual targets, and association constraints. This design relies on the assumption that questions can be effectively mapped to these predefined components. It would be useful to discuss how the method handles questions that do not naturally fit this decomposition and whether its performance remains robust across diverse question formulations.

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Our question decomposition is designed for a general embodied egocentric reasoning task: As characterized in previous studies [1–3], this task involves an agent answering natural-language task questions grounded in its first-person visual observations, requiring it to identify relevant objects and their states, locate related scenes or events, and reason about their spatio-temporal relationships. Existing studies  [1–3] on embodied and egocentric reasoning cover these question elements, including locations, objects, states, actions, events, and their spatio-temporal associations. Based on these elements, we further organize the question information into three retrieval components: scene constraints (locations and spatio-temporal localization), visual targets (objects and states), and association constraints (events, actions, and spatio-temporal associations). For questions lacking certain elements, the corresponding components are left empty and their retrieval operations are skipped.

Experiments on three established benchmarks featuring diverse question types in embodied egocentric reasoning further demonstrate that VTEM maintains robust performance across different question formulations: OpenEQA [1], Env-QA [4], and ECBench-MS [5]. Specifically, OpenEQA evaluates embodied question answering over prior embodied experience, Env-QA focuses on understanding dynamic environments, including object states, temporal orders, and events, while ECBench-MS involves long-horizon multi-scene reasoning. VTEM achieves consistent performance improvements across all three benchmarks, further supporting the applicability and robustness of our question decomposition across diverse embodied egocentric reasoning tasks.

References:

[1] Majumdar et al. OpenEQA: Embodied Question Answering in the Era of Foundation Models. CVPR 2024.

[2] Grauman et al. Ego4D: Around the World in 3,000 Hours of Egocentric Video. CVPR 2022.

[3] Jia et al. EgoTaskQA: Understanding Human Tasks in Egocentric Videos. NeurIPS 2022.

[4] Gao et al. Env-QA: A Video Question Answering Benchmark for Comprehensive Understanding of Dynamic Environments. ICCV 2021.

[5] Dang et al. ECBench: Can Multi-modal Foundation Models Understand the Egocentric World? 2025.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer E4Y5 (3)

Weakness 3

Table 2 and Appendix A.4 do provide module, transition, and retrieval ablations, including temporal-chain and shuffled-transition controls. However, the detailed appendix comparisons use only 50 OpenEQA questions from four trajectories. It remains unclear whether the individual component gains generalize across the full benchmarks and diverse environments.

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Our original fine-grained ablations used a representative subset, following established experimental practices in prior works (VideoAgent, Embodied VideoAgent, and 3D-Mem). To further address your concern about generalization, we expand the fine-grained ablations in Appendix A.4 to all OpenEQA-HM3D tasks, consistent with the main-text ablations.

As shown below, Full VTEM achieves 62.61% LLM-Match, outperforming TMC association only, TMC value only, THR anchor only, and THR multi-hop only by 7.36, 9.15, 8.44, and 7.54 percentage points, respectively. These results demonstrate that the component gains persist across the full OpenEQA-HM3D evaluation set, rather than being limited to the original 50-question subset.

MethodLLM-Match (%)
no TMC & no THR48.52
TMC association only55.25
TMC value only53.46
THR anchor only54.17
THR multi-hop only55.07
Full VTEM62.61

We will include these expanded ablation results in the revised manuscript.

Weakness 4 and Question 1

W4. Appendix A.3 reports construction and question-time model calls: Full VTEM uses 4.68 calls per question versus 1.00 for flat retrieval, while reducing retrieved memories from 12.00 to 8.38 on the controlled subset. This analysis is useful, but wall-clock latency and exact token costs are not reported, so it is unclear when memory compression offsets the additional reasoning overhead.

Q1. Could the authors report the end-to-end inference latency and the offline memory-construction cost? Specifically, under what conditions can the benefits of memory compression offset the additional overhead introduced by retrieval?

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Following your suggestions, we conduct additional efficiency experiments to evaluate VTEM's offline memory-construction cost and end-to-end inference latency, including token counts and peak GPU memory usage. The results are reported below.

Memory Construction. The table below compares the memory-construction time of VTEM and 3D-Mem. VTEM requires 1.10 s per sampled candidate view, substantially faster than 3D-Mem (2.47 s/frame), reducing construction time by approximately 55.5%. This is a one-time offline cost, and the constructed memory can be reused across multiple questions.

MethodConstruction Time per Sampled Candidate View
3D-Mem2.47 s/frame
VTEM (Ours)1.10 s/frame

Query Inference. We further compare VTEM with Flat Retrieval in terms of VLM calls, retrieved memories, token counts, peak GPU memory, and end-to-end inference latency. As shown below, despite increasing VLM calls from 1.00 to 4.68, VTEM reduces retrieved memories from 12.00 to 8.38, total tokens by 7.1%, and inference latency from 8.77 to 7.76 s (11.5%), while improving the score from 0.51 to 0.57.

MethodVLM CallsRetrieved MemoriesInput TokensOutput TokensTotal TokensPeak GPU MemoryLatencyScore
Flat Retrieval1.0012.009947.8412.169960.0018.45 GiB8.77 s0.51
VTEM (Ours)4.688.389090.88165.629256.5017.46 GiB7.76 s0.57

These results suggest that for long-horizon tasks with substantial memory evidence, reducing the amount of retrieved evidence can offset the additional retrieval overhead. In our experiments, VTEM achieves lower end-to-end inference latency despite more VLM calls. Moreover, the offline construction cost can be amortized when the same memory is reused across multiple questions.

We will include these efficiency results and corresponding analyses in the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_ot2eOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a memory framework for long-horizon embodied question answering (VTEM). The main idea is to model transitions between observations explicitly instead of treating stored observations mostly independently. VTEM consists of two parts: TMC, which models view transitions and uses semantic value together with visual novelty to decide which observations should be stored, and THR, which decomposes a question into scene/view/association constraints and uses these for hierarchical and transition-guided retrieval. The method is evaluated on OpenEQA, EnvQA, and ECBench-MultiScene. The paper also contains ablations of TMC/THR, an analysis of memory coverage and recurrence, real-video experiments, and additional controlled experiments in the appendix.

Critical strengths

I think the strongest novel aspect is not simply adding spatio-temporal structure to memory, since this already exists in related approaches such as R4. Rather, I find the decision of whether an observation actually adds sufficient information to be stored interesting. TMC combines semantic information gain and visual novelty for this purpose and then preserves the selected observations in a transition-aware memory structure. This is potentially a useful complement to existing persistent spatio-temporal memory approaches. I liked the experimental analysis. The basic TMC/THR ablation already gives a clear signal, but the additional experiments that shuffle transition descriptors, remove association cues, use temporal-only chains, or restrict retrieval make the evidence considerably more convincing. These experiments provide actual evidence that the proposed transition relations matter rather than the gain simply coming from additional retrieval or a larger context.

Critical weaknesses

Some claims about prior memory redundancy and efficiency need stronger evidence. The paper motivates VTEM partly by arguing that existing methods accumulate redundant cross-view observations. However, this does not generally hold in the way it is currently stated. R4, for example, explicitly matches new observations against existing spatially and semantically similar memory entries and updates/refines matched entries.

VTEM does provide its own quantitative memory analysis. Table 4 measures object coverage together with average and maximum recurrence, and TMC substantially reduces recurrence while retaining similar object coverage relative to dense memory. This is a good analysis. However, since memory redundancy/compactness is part of the argument, I would really like to see these same memory metrics compared directly against other strong persistent-memory approaches. Otherwise the paper demonstrates that TMC is more compact than simple sampling strategies, but not that it solves a weakness of the strongest relevant existing methods.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors clarify the conceptual distinction between VTEM and R4 in more depth? Both methods maintain structured spatio-temporal memory and use structured retrieval. To me, a potentially important difference is that VTEM introduces value-aware selective memory construction, whereas R4 continuously updates/refines an object-level 4D memory. Do the authors consider value-aware construction the key distinction, and could they quantitatively isolate its advantage against R4 rather than only against dense/random/uniform memory?

  2. The paper argues that existing approaches suffer from repeated cross-view observations. However, R4 explicitly associates new observations with existing memory entries using spatial and semantic similarity and updates/refines matched entries. Can the authors provide evidence that cross-view memory redundancy is actually a problem for R4 or related structured-memory methods? This would help substantiate one of the central motivations of the paper.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ot2e (1)

Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully revised the manuscript in response to your comments, with the major revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

Weakness 1 and Question 2

W1. The paper motivates VTEM partly by arguing that existing methods accumulate redundant cross-view observations. However, this does not generally hold in the way it is currently stated. R4, for example, explicitly matches new observations against existing spatially and semantically similar memory entries and updates/refines matched entries.

Q2. The paper argues that existing approaches suffer from repeated cross-view observations. However, R4 explicitly associates new observations with existing memory entries using spatial and semantic similarity and updates/refines matched entries. Can the authors provide evidence that cross-view memory redundancy is actually a problem for R4 or related structured-memory methods? This would help substantiate one of the central motivations of the paper.

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. As acknowledged in our paper (lines 79–81), R4 can mitigate cross-view memory redundancy through 3D reconstruction, but introduces additional computational costs. In contrast, other structured-memory methods (e.g., 3D-Mem and CLiViS) may still accumulate redundant cross-view observations. VTEM instead infers scene, viewing-direction, and object changes across observations to assess whether new observations provide additional information, selectively retaining valuable observations and reducing redundancy without explicit 3D reconstruction. We clarify these distinctions as follows:

  1. 3D reconstruction-based methods (e.g., R4): As noted in our paper (lines 78–79), R4 establishes cross-view spatial associations through 3D reconstruction, which can reduce memory redundancy but introduces additional computational costs.

  2. Other structured-memory methods (e.g., 3D-Mem, CLiViS): These methods primarily construct structured memory based on object-level information or visual observations, without explicitly assessing whether new observations contribute additional information beyond existing memory. Consequently, repeated observations of the same objects or scenes from different viewpoints may still accumulate, leading to cross-view memory redundancy.

  3. VTEM: In contrast, VTEM models view-transition associations by inferring view changes relative to surrounding scene elements without explicit 3D reconstruction. Based on these associations, TMC evaluates each observation's memory value according to whether it contributes new information, thereby reducing redundant cross-view observations through value-aware selective memory construction.

Since R4 is not open-source and its implementation details limit direct reproduction, we compare TMC with 3D-Mem, a reproducible structured-memory baseline, to further evaluate cross-view memory redundancy. As shown below, TMC achieves higher object coverage (78.33% vs. 76.50%) while reducing average recurrence (7.02 vs. 9.74) and maximum recurrence (16.30 vs. 18.60). These results demonstrate that TMC more effectively reduces cross-view memory redundancy while preserving object coverage compared with 3D-Mem.

MethodObject Coverage ↑Avg. Repeat ↓Max. Repeat ↓
Uniform Sampling (1/4)74.44%7.7717.50
3D-Mem76.50%9.7418.60
TMC (Ours)78.33%7.0216.30

We clarify these distinctions and add the comparative analysis in the revised manuscript. Thank you again for your valuable suggestions, which help strengthen the motivation and experimental evidence for VTEM.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer ot2e (2)

Weakness 2

VTEM does provide its own quantitative memory analysis. Table 4 measures object coverage together with average and maximum recurrence, and TMC substantially reduces recurrence while retaining similar object coverage relative to dense memory. This is a good analysis. However, since memory redundancy/compactness is part of the argument, I would really like to see these same memory metrics compared directly against other strong persistent-memory approaches. Otherwise the paper demonstrates that TMC is more compact than simple sampling strategies, but not that it solves a weakness of the strongest relevant existing methods.

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Following your suggestions, we further compare TMC with 3D-Mem, a related persistent-memory method, using the same memory metrics as Table 4: object coverage, average recurrence, and maximum recurrence. As shown in the comparison table above, TMC achieves higher object coverage (78.33% vs. 76.50%) while reducing average recurrence (7.02 vs. 9.74) and maximum recurrence (16.30 vs. 18.60). These results demonstrate that TMC more effectively reduces cross-view memory redundancy while preserving higher object coverage compared with 3D-Mem, further supporting the effectiveness of our value-aware memory construction.

Question 1

Q1. Could the authors clarify the conceptual distinction between VTEM and R4 in more depth? Both methods maintain structured spatio-temporal memory and use structured retrieval. To me, a potentially important difference is that VTEM introduces value-aware selective memory construction, whereas R4 continuously updates/refines an object-level 4D memory. Do the authors consider value-aware construction the key distinction, and could they quantitatively isolate its advantage against R4 rather than only against dense/random/uniform memory?

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Yes, we consider value-aware selective memory construction a key distinction between VTEM and R4. Although both methods maintain structured spatio-temporal memory and use structured retrieval, they differ in their memory construction strategies:

  1. R4: R4 constructs object-level 4D memory through 3D reconstruction and continuously updates/refines matched memory entries based on spatial and semantic associations. This can reduce cross-view memory redundancy but introduces additional computational costs.

  2. VTEM: In contrast, VTEM models view-transition associations by inferring view changes relative to surrounding scene elements without explicit 3D reconstruction. Based on these associations, TMC explicitly evaluates whether each observation contributes new information and performs value-aware selective memory construction to reduce redundant cross-view observations.

To quantitatively evaluate this advantage, we refer to the cross-view memory redundancy comparison with 3D-Mem presented above in W1/Q2, which provides evidence for the effectiveness of VTEM's value-aware memory construction beyond dense/random/uniform sampling baselines. Since R4 is not open-source and its complete implementation details are unavailable, we cannot faithfully reproduce its original method for a controlled direct comparison.

We further clarify these conceptual distinctions and the corresponding experimental evidence in the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_KssiOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses long-horizon embodied question answering. It targets two limitations of prior methods. The first is redundancy in memory across views. The second arises during retrieval: weak association across observations makes it hard to identify the memory fragments relevant to the question, so the retrieved memory is misaligned with the question’s context. To address these, the authors propose VTEM (View Transition Egocentric Memory), a training-free framework. TMC scores each frame as αt = λρt+(1−λ)νt, writes frames with αt ≥ τ into a scene-view chain, and stores a transition descriptor on each edge. THR decomposes the question into (cs, cv, ca), retrieves anchors scene-first, and expands along chain edges when a sufficiency check fails. Reported gains over the strongest baselines are 7.89 points on OpenEQA, 3.44 on ECBench-MS, and 4.57 on EnvQA.

Critical strengths

S1. The paper states its research problem clearly. It names two failure modes early and illustrates both in Figure 1: cross-view memory redundancy at construction time and context-misaligned retrieval at query time. These failure modes directly motivate the framework’s two modules, each targeting one of them: TMC addresses redundancy and THR addresses retrieval.

S2. The experiments are designed to test each claim separately. The proposed method is compared against general LVLMs, an embodied LVLM and memory-based methods, covering the prior SOTA alternatives (Sec. 4.1; Table 1). On the full HM3D split, the module ablation separates the contributions of TMC (+2.29) and THR (+5.88) from the full framework (+14.09 over flat retrieval) (Table 2). The method is also tested on real robot videos as a first check of transfer beyond simulated benchmarks (Sec. 4.4; Table 3).

Critical weaknesses

W 1. The method section is hard to follow. Three issues make Section 3 difficult to understand:

Section 3 introduces about ten functions across Eqs. 1–9, which mix LVLM prompts, CLIP similarities and hand-written rules. Only Fd is identified as “an LVLM with a structured prompt” (line 276); the others are described mainly in Table 5 and Appendix A.8, so the reader cannot tell from Section 3 how each function is implemented.

Figure 2, the visual overview of the method, is never referenced in the text. The caption (lines 178– 179) does not explain its numbered steps or symbols.

The recursion in Eq. 2, δi,t = Frel(ot−1, ot, δi,t−1), is unclear. Section 3.2 says TMC aggregates changes between adjacent frames “instead of relying only on endpoint comparison” (lines 200–201), but Frel is not defined in the main text. Its only definition (Table 5) takes the latest retained memory and the current view as input, not (ot−1, ot, δi,t−1). Algorithm 1 (line 8) and Appendix A.8 also build δi,t from the latest retained node and the current view, so it is unclear if the recursion is carried out with our without endpoint observation. The view-transition descriptor is central to the method, and it is currently difficult to understand.

Stating each function’s implementation next to its equation, explaining how Eq. 2 is computed and how it relates to Algorithm 1, and referencing Figure 2 in Section 3 with an expanded caption would resolve this.

W 2. The experimental setup of the main comparison in Table 1 is unclear. The paper states that “all methods follow the same evaluation samples and protocols when applicable for each dataset” (line 357), but it does not specify whether any method was re-run or why the numbers differ from those in the original papers. Two issues weaken the comparison:

Models are not stated. Section 4 never names the LVLM that produces VTEM’s Table 1 results. In their original papers, Embodied VideoAgent and 3D-Mem use GPT-4o, CLiViS uses a Qwen2.5- Max planner with 7–8B VLMs, and GeLM is a trained Vicuna-7B grounding model with no memory module. The baseline reproduction settings need more detail.

Baseline numbers differ from the published ones, and their source is not stated. Embodied VideoAgent reports 57.9 on the full OpenEQA EM-EQA set and 43.13 on EnvQA (its Tables 3–4), whereas Table 1 lists 51.63 and 27.26; with the published EnvQA number, VTEM would not rank first on EnvQA. CLiViS reports only the ScanNet subset, scored as accuracy by a Qwen2.5-Max judge. GeLM’s own paper does not evaluate on these benchmarks, and the ECBench paper reports 21.54 for GeLM on the full benchmark, against 43.48 on the authors’ ECBench-MS subset. These baseline runs need explanation, or the comparison should use benchmarks with published baseline results on same metric.

Since the OpenEQA margin and the EnvQA result are the main empirical evidence of the paper, these gaps affect the central claim. Stating, for every baseline, whether its numbers were copied or re-run, together with its backbone, frame budget, inputs and judge, and re-running the main memory baselines with VTEM’s answer model and evidence budget, would make the comparison interpretable and controlled.

W 3 (minor). The paper presents VTEM as efficient but supports this only with LVLM-call and storage counts on a small subset. The abstract claims “efficient memory construction” and “efficient and reliable long-horizon embodied reasoning” (lines 022 and 027–028). Two issues weaken this claim:

The paper reports no wall-clock latency, token counts or GPU memory, only logged LVLM calls (Tables 11–12). The stated reason for omitting latency, that it depends on “deployment hardware, batching, and API routing” (lines 935–937), applies weakly here, since all VTEM LVLM calls use the open-weight Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct (Table 21) and only the evaluator requires an API.

Closely related methods report runtime: CLiViS gives latency in seconds against two baselines (its Table 4), 3D-Mem times each pipeline component (its supplementary Table 6), etc. Reporting construction time per frame, query latency and peak GPU memory for VTEM and flat retrieval would support the efficiency claim; otherwise the claim should be softened

Questions for authors

Q1. How is Eq. (2) computed in practice? Is δi,t updated recursively over adjacent frames, or computed using the latest retained node and the current view, as suggested by Algorithm 1 and Table 5?

Q2. Which LVLM was used to produce VTEM's Table 1 results? For each baseline, were the results taken from the original publications or reproduced? Why do the reported results differ from previously published values?

Q3. How do VTEM's memory-construction time per frame, query latency, and peak GPU memory usage compare with those of prior frameworks?

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Kssi (1)

Thank you for your valuable feedback. We have carefully revised the manuscript in response to your comments, with the major revisions highlighted in blue for ease of reference.

Weakness 1 and Question 1

W1. The method section is hard to follow. Three issues make Section 3 difficult to understand:

Weakness1(1) Section 3 introduces about ten functions across Eqs. 1–9, which mix LVLM prompts, CLIP similarities and hand-written rules. Only Fd is identified as “an LVLM with a structured prompt” (line 276); the others are described mainly in Table 5 and Appendix A.8, so the reader cannot tell from Section 3 how each function is implemented.

Thank you for your suggestions. Following your suggestions, we add implementation details alongside each function when it is first introduced. For example, below Eq. (2), we specify that FrelF_{\mathrm{rel}} is implemented using an LVLM with a structured prompt, which takes two adjacent observations and the accumulated transition descriptor since the last retained observation as inputs to recursively update the view-transition descriptor, capturing scene changes, viewing-direction changes, and cross-view object changes.

Weakness1(2) Figure 2, the visual overview of the method, is never referenced in the text. The caption (lines 178–179) does not explain its numbered steps or symbols.

Thanks for pointing that out. Following your suggestion, we add a reference to Figure 2 in Section 3 and expand its caption to explain the numbered steps and symbols, illustrating the task execution and memory retrieval processes of our method.

Weakness1(3) The recursion in Eq. 2, δi,t=Frel(ot−1,ot,δi,t−1)\delta_{i,t} = F_{\mathrm{rel}}(o_{t-1}, o_t, \delta_{i,t-1}), is unclear. Section 3.2 says TMC aggregates changes between adjacent frames “instead of relying only on endpoint comparison” (lines 200–201), but Frel is not defined in the main text. Its only definition (Table 5) takes the latest retained memory and the current view as input, not (ot−1,ot,δi,t−1)(o_{t-1}, o_t, \delta_{i,t-1}). Algorithm 1 (line 8) and Appendix A.8 also build δi,t\delta_{i,t} from the latest retained node and the current view, so it is unclear if the recursion is carried out with or without endpoint observation. The view-transition descriptor is central to the method, and it is currently difficult to understand. Stating each function’s implementation next to its equation, explaining how Eq. 2 is computed and how it relates to Algorithm 1, and referencing Figure 2 in Section 3 with an expanded caption would resolve this.

Q1. How is Eq. (2) computed in practice? Is δi,t\delta_{i,t} updated recursively over adjacent frames, or computed using the latest retained node and the current view, as suggested by Algorithm 1 and Table 5?

Thank you for pointing out the unclear recursion in Eq. (2). FrelF_{\mathrm{rel}} takes two adjacent observations, ot−1o_{t-1} and oto_t, together with the previous transition descriptor, δi,t−1\delta_{i,t-1}, as inputs, rather than directly comparing the memorized endpoint observations oio_i and oto_t. Specifically, δi,t−1\delta_{i,t-1} captures the accumulated scene changes, viewing-direction changes, and cross-view object changes from the retained endpoint observation oio_i to the previous observation ot−1o_{t-1}. FrelF_{\mathrm{rel}} then incorporates the changes between ot−1o_{t-1} and oto_t to recursively update this descriptor.

The discrepancies in Table 5, Algorithm 1, and Appendix A.8 stem from the differences between the code-level encapsulation of δi,t−1\delta_{i,t-1} and memory states and their algorithmic notation. In our implementation, the accumulated transition descriptor δi,t−1\delta_{i,t-1} and the retained endpoint observation oio_i are encapsulated together in the latest retained memory state. However, FrelF_{\mathrm{rel}} takes only the cached δi,t−1\delta_{i,t-1} from this state as its input, without directly using the endpoint observation oio_i. Therefore, the description "latest retained memory and current view" is an abbreviated representation of the actual inputs.

Thank you again for pointing out this issue. We revise these descriptions to clarify the actual inputs of the recursive computation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Kssi (2)

Weakness 2 and Question 2

W2. The paper states that “all methods follow the same evaluation samples and protocols when applicable for each dataset” (line 357), but it does not specify whether any method was re-run or why the numbers differ from those in the original papers. Two issues weaken the comparison:

Weakness2(1) Models are not stated. Section 4 never names the LVLM that produces VTEM’s Table 1 results. In their original papers, Embodied VideoAgent and 3D-Mem use GPT-4o, CLiViS uses a Qwen2.5-Max planner with 7–8B VLMs, and GeLM is a trained Vicuna-7B grounding model with no memory module. The baseline reproduction settings need more detail.

Thank you for your advice. For fair comparison, following the established evaluation setup in embodied reasoning [1, 2, 3], we rerun all methods on the same evaluation samples and under the same evaluation protocols. Specifically, we use the same VLM backbone (Qwen2.5-VL-7B) for VTEM and memory-based methods (Embodied VideoAgent, 3D-Mem, and CLiViS) to evaluate the effectiveness of the memory frameworks themselves. For training-based methods, we use their original trained models from the respective papers to assess their effectiveness. All experimental settings are detailed in Appendix Sections A.1, A.2. Following your suggestion, we further clarify the baseline reproduction settings in Section 4.

[1] Fan et al. Embodied VideoAgent: Persistent Memory from Egocentric Videos and Embodied Sensors Enables Dynamic Scene Understanding. ICCV 2025.

[2] Yang et al. 3D-Mem: 3D Scene Memory for Embodied Exploration and Reasoning. CVPR 2025.

[3] Li et al. CLiViS: Unleashing Cognitive Map through Linguistic-Visual Synergy for Embodied Visual Reasoning. CVPR 2026.

Weakness2(2) Baseline numbers differ from the published ones, and their source is not stated. Embodied VideoAgent reports 57.9 on the full OpenEQA EM-EQA set and 43.13 on EnvQA (its Tables 3–4), whereas Table 1 lists 51.63 and 27.26; with the published EnvQA number, VTEM would not rank first on EnvQA. CLiViS reports only the ScanNet subset, scored as accuracy by a Qwen2.5-Max judge. GeLM’s own paper does not evaluate on these benchmarks, and the ECBench paper reports 21.54 for GeLM on the full benchmark, against 43.48 on the authors’ ECBench-MS subset. These baseline runs need explanation, or the comparison should use benchmarks with published baseline results on same metric.

Thank you for your suggestions. As clarified in our response to the preceding comment, the OpenEQA and EnvQA results of Embodied VideoAgent and CLiViS differ from those in the original papers mainly because we unified their VLM backbones to Qwen2.5-VL-7B for fair comparison.

For GeLM, the difference between our ECBench result (43.48) and the published result (21.54) arises from different evaluation subsets. Following the experimental setup of Embodied VideoAgent, we select the ECBench-MS subset to assess long-range multi-scene reasoning. This subset contains long-horizon samples involving at least three scenes, enabling a more focused evaluation of the methods' capabilities on long-range multi-scene tasks, whereas the published GeLM result is evaluated on the full ECBench benchmark.

To further demonstrate VTEM's advantage over existing methods using a stronger VLM backbone (GPT-4o), we additionally compare our results with the published GPT-4o-based results of Embodied VideoAgent on OpenEQA.

MethodVLM BackboneScanNetHM3DAll
Embodied VideoAgent (Published)GPT-4o59.4054.9057.90
Embodied VideoAgent (Ours rerun)Qwen2.5-VL-7B55.1244.8851.63
VTEM (Ours)Qwen2.5-VL-7B64.6762.6163.97

The results show that VTEM achieves 63.97 on OpenEQA using Qwen2.5-VL-7B, outperforming our controlled rerun of Embodied VideoAgent by 12.34 points under the same backbone. Notably, VTEM also exceeds the published GPT-4o-based result of Embodied VideoAgent (57.90) by 6.07 points, providing further evidence of VTEM's effectiveness beyond the backbone configuration.

Thank you again for your valuable suggestions. We clarify these differences and the corresponding comparison settings in the revised manuscript to make the baseline comparisons more transparent and interpretable.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Kssi (3)

Weakness 2 and Question 2

Weakness2(3) Since the OpenEQA margin and the EnvQA result are the main empirical evidence of the paper, these gaps affect the central claim. Stating, for every baseline, whether its numbers were copied or re-run, together with its backbone, frame budget, inputs and judge, and re-running the main memory baselines with VTEM’s answer model and evidence budget, would make the comparison interpretable and controlled.

Q2. Which LVLM was used to produce VTEM's Table 1 results? For each baseline, were the results taken from the original publications or reproduced? Why do the reported results differ from previously published values?

Thank you for your suggestions. For memory-based baselines, we use the same answer model (Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct), frame sampling stride (5), RGB observation inputs, and evaluation judge (GPT-4-1106-preview for OpenEQA), with the same evidence budget of up to 12 memory candidates per question. We rerun all baselines under these consistent settings to ensure fair comparison. Following your suggestion, we have added further baseline reproduction details in Section 4 to demonstrate the controlled experimental settings. Regarding the differences between our reported results and previously published values, as explained in our response to W1 (2), these differences are mainly due to our use of a unified VLM backbone (Qwen2.5-VL-7B) for fair comparison and our selection of the ECBench-MS subset to objectively evaluate long-horizon multi-scene reasoning capabilities.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Kssi (4)

Weakness 3 and Question 3

W3. The abstract claims “efficient memory construction” and “efficient and reliable long-horizon embodied reasoning” (lines 022 and 027–028). Two issues weaken this claim

Weakness3(1) The paper reports no wall-clock latency, token counts or GPU memory, only logged LVLM calls (Tables 11–12). The stated reason for omitting latency, that it depends on “deployment hardware, batching, and API routing” (lines 935–937), applies weakly here, since all VTEM LVLM calls use the open-weight Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct (Table 21) and only the evaluator requires an API.

Weakness3(2) Closely related methods report runtime: CLiViS gives latency in seconds against two baselines (its Table 4), 3D-Mem times each pipeline component (its supplementary Table 6), etc. Reporting construction time per frame, query latency and peak GPU memory for VTEM and flat retrieval would support the efficiency claim; otherwise the claim should be softened.

Q3. How do VTEM's memory-construction time per frame, query latency, and peak GPU memory usage compare with those of prior frameworks?

Thank you for your valuable suggestions. Following your suggestions, we conduct additional efficiency experiments covering memory-construction time, query latency, token counts, and peak GPU memory usage. The results demonstrate that VTEM significantly reduces memory-construction and query costs while improving reasoning performance.

Memory Construction Time. The table below compares the memory-construction time of VTEM, Flat Retrieval, and 3D-Mem, which constructs memory based on 2D images. The results show that VTEM achieves substantially faster memory construction than 3D-Mem while obtaining better memory performance. Note that 3D-Mem is not a 3D modeling method; it is included here to compare the construction costs of different memory methods. Since Flat Retrieval only changes the retrieval stage, its memory-construction time is the same as VTEM's. Specifically, VTEM requires 1.10 s/frame, compared with 2.47 s/frame for 3D-Mem, reducing construction time by approximately 55.5% while improving the score from 0.45 to 0.57.

MethodConstruction Time per Sampled Candidate ViewScore
3D-Mem2.47 s/frame0.45
Flat Retrieval1.10 s/frame0.51
VTEM (Ours)1.10 s/frame0.57

Token Counts, Peak GPU Memory, and Query Latency. We compare VTEM with Flat Retrieval in terms of token counts, peak GPU memory, and query latency to evaluate the efficiency of our retrieval framework. As shown below, VTEM reduces total token counts (9,256.50 vs. 9,960.00), peak GPU memory (17.46 vs. 18.45 GiB), and query latency (7.76 vs. 8.77 s), while improving the score from 0.51 to 0.57. These results demonstrate that VTEM achieves more efficient retrieval and question answering while improving reasoning performance.

MethodInput TokensOutput TokensTotal TokensPeak GPU MemoryQuery LatencyScore
Flat Retrieval9947.8412.169960.0018.45 GiB8.77 s0.51
VTEM (Ours)9090.88165.629256.5017.46 GiB7.76 s0.57

These results demonstrate that VTEM achieves substantially faster memory construction than 3D-Mem while reducing query latency, token counts, and peak GPU memory usage compared with Flat Retrieval. We will include these results and corresponding experimental details in the revised manuscript.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
Area_Chair_njciOpenReview ↗

Urgent Reminder: Discussion Period Ends November 18

Dear Reviewers,

The discussion period will end on November 18, 2026. Please carefully review the authors' responses and actively engage in discussions.

If you have not yet initiated a discussion, please do so immediately. Reviewers are expected to address the authors' rebuttals, provide constructive follow-up comments, and update their evaluations when appropriate.

Please also ensure that your reviews reflect independent human judgment and that any AI assistance is properly documented in accordance with the review guidelines.

Active participation is an essential reviewer responsibility and is critical to ensuring a rigorous and fair review process.

Thank you for your cooperation.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.