- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents AdaSketch, a photo-to-vector sketch generation method that aims to separate the initialized stroke capacity from the complexity of the rendered sketch. The method represents an object using a fixed closed contour and a set of detail strokes with learnable opacities. Foreground segmentation and CLIP attention maps guide stroke initialization, while coverage, uniqueness, and relevance objectives encourage the preservation of salient details and suppression of redundant strokes. A progressive contour-to-detail optimization strategy, combined with diffusion-based SDS guidance, jointly optimizes stroke geometry and visibility.
The method is evaluated against five existing approaches on 16,990 images from 85 object categories. The authors report improvements across five semantic, structural, and perceptual similarity metrics computed against XDoG edge references. Additional qualitative experiments demonstrate controllable abstraction under different stroke budgets and target-specific sketch generation in multi-object scenes.
Critical strengths
1. Reasonable motivation and structured optimization design.
The paper addresses a meaningful problem in vector sketch generation: different objects require different levels of detail, while fixed stroke budgets may lead to missing structures or redundant strokes. The contour-detail representation and progressive optimization strategy provide a reasonable framework for preserving global object structure while selectively adjusting internal details.
2. Promising visual results and relatively extensive evaluation.
The generated sketches generally preserve recognizable silhouettes and produce visually clean results. The paper evaluates the method against five baselines on a relatively large dataset of 16,990 images across 85 categories, reporting consistent improvements on the selected metrics. The qualitative examples also demonstrate controllable levels of detail and applicability to multi-object scenes.
Critical weaknesses
1. The novelty and effectiveness of the proposed adaptive stroke selection are not fully justified.
The claimed decoupling mainly relies on fixing the contour while dropping detail strokes, which is conceptually similar to the learnable stroke pruning in CLIPascene. In addition, the coverage and uniqueness losses do not explicitly reduce the number of strokes, and they may conflict with each other under soft coverage. The interaction between these two terms and their sensitivity to loss weights are not sufficiently analyzed. Controlled comparisons against sparsity-based baselines under matched settings, together with a trade-off analysis between semantic fidelity and stroke complexity, are needed to validate the method's effectiveness.
2. The reliability of the semantic guidance and the evaluation metrics requires further validation.
While the method uses foreground masks, CLIP attention, and sampled points to locate important structures, high spatial attention does not necessarily translate to stroke-level semantic contribution. The stability of these signals under imperfect segmentation and different random seeds is also left unexamined. Moreover, comparing against XDoG edges does not reliably measure semantic recognizability or the quality of visual abstraction. Additional experiments on guidance robustness and semantic recognizability would considerably strengthen the paper.
Questions for authors
Q1. Effectiveness of Coverage-based Selection
Could the authors compare coverage-based selection with sparsity-based selection (e.g., CLIPascene) under matched SDS guidance and initialization? A semantic fidelity–visible stroke count Pareto curve would help demonstrate its specific advantages if it is possible.
Q2. Reliability of Semantic Guidance
How sensitive are the selected strokes and their visibility to variations in CLIP attention, foreground masks, and guidance-point sampling? Is there evidence that the estimated spatial importance correlates with stroke-level semantic contribution?
Q3. Evaluation Robustness
Were cases with inaccurate or failed foreground segmentation or CLIP attention guidance included in the reported quantitative results? How were such failures handled, and could the authors provide a robustness analysis showing their impact on overall performance? Were comparable preprocessing and segmentation conditions used across baselines?