- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors tackle the problem of SVG generation with autoregressive LLMs. A prevalent issue in this setting is the generation of coordinate values, which are usually expressed as floating-point numbers and require high precision. The authors speculate that generating these floats as tokenized sequences is suboptimal and propose a continuous-value generation subnetwork as an alternative. This subnetwork fills in placeholder tokens generated by the autoregressive model at positions where coordinate values are expected. The authors show that this approach outperforms the standard approach across a wide range of metrics.
Critical strengths
The paper is well written and easy to follow. The idea makes sense intuitively and works well in practice. The quantitative evaluation shows a large gap compared to previous methods. The findings will be useful to the broader SVG generation community.
Critical weaknesses
My biggest gripe is with the presentation of the results. I believe the results require more discussion. As it stands, the quantitative and qualitative results are presented without much explanation. For example, in lines 312f, what qualitative improvements and differences can we observe in the figures? And in lines 316f, what do the scores tell us? Looking at the results myself, I am confused because the quantitative results rank the discrete models above the standard baseline, yet in the qualitative examples, they seem to perform worse. It also seems that the continuous approach generates better SVGs overall but suffers from greater variance in the predicted coordinates. How would the authors put these observations into perspective? The paper would benefit from a discussion of these points.
Other parts of the paper could benefit from further discussion as well. For example, I couldn't find details on how the discrete baseline works. Does it introduce new tokens for a predefined range of values? Overall, I don't think the paper is ready yet for publication and believe it would benefit from further revision.
Questions for authors
The approach reminds me of a method employed by Kulits et al. (2024) for Blender code generation. What do the authors see as the major similarities and differences between the two approaches?