acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Logically Redundant, Behaviorally Different: Omitting Derivable Information in LLM Agents

Abstract

LLM agents use tools over multiple steps, accumulating observations, tool outputs, and memory as they act. Existing work therefore compresses or omits observations and interaction history to manage growing context. Logically, information derivable from what remains can be omitted without loss. However, how such omission affects agent behavior remains underexplored. This paper uses paired Explicit and Derivable conditions to study this question in multi-step tool-use tasks. Explicit provides selected derived information directly in the current state representation, while Derivable omits the same information only when it remains exactly derivable from retained facts and rules. In TextWorld, Explicit improves task success by 61.7 percentage points, completing 58/60 tasks compared with 21/60 under Derivable. The effect grows as more derived conclusions are stated, is not reproduced by repeating retained premises, and also appears in next-action choices from the same environment state. The difference weakens or disappears when additional reasoning or preparation is available before action and also varies across executors. Derivability alone does not guarantee behavioral preservation. Whether omission preserves behavior depends on the executor, inference settings, and pre-action processing.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
LLM agents, behavioral sufficiency, information interfaces, agent evaluation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 2 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_7WusOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates: when an LLM agent omits derived conclusions that remain exactly derivable from retained facts and rules in the current-state representation of a multi-step tool-use task, how does this affect agent behavior? The paper defines two symmetric conditions: Explicit (derived conclusions are directly provided in the state representation) and Derivable (those conclusions are omitted when they remain exactly derivable). Crucially, omitted information under the Derivable condition is formally verified to be reconstructible via an exact reconstruction check, ensuring the experiment directly answers the titular question rather than testing information loss. Key findings: in TextWorld, the success gap is 61.7%; in ALFWorld, 16/100 vs 1/100. Content controls show the effect comes from the derived conclusions themselves, not from extra text or repeated premises. Action-level analysis from shared states finds all 31 first divergences in TextWorld favor Explicit. The gap weakens or disappears when the model has sufficient pre-action computation (thinking mode or free-form notes). System-side deterministic derivation achieves 58/60 tasks with approximately 60% of the tokens and half the calls, representing the efficiency-optimal design.

Critical strengths
  1. Precise problem definition with formal guarantees.

The exact reconstruction check (Equation 2) is the paper's core methodological contribution: a task-state pair enters the behavioral comparison only when the Derivable interface can be deterministically rebuilt into the Explicit interface using retained facts and a fixed public rule set. This formally operationalizes the distinction between "logically derivable" and "actually omitted," making the experimental conclusion directly address the paper's question rather than confounds.

  1. Large and robust effect size.

61.7% points in TextWorld is a highly significant effect, which holds across content controls: neutral fillers (P0–P50) do not reproduce it, and repeated premises (P_REPEAT) do not reproduce it, isolating the source to the derived conclusions themselves rather than token count or context length.

  1. Complete multi-level analysis from task to action.

The paper uses deterministic transitions at temperature zero in TextWorld to analyze the first action divergence from shared starting states (all 31 favor Explicit), and uses pre-selected shared states in ALFWorld to show the effect does not require prior trajectory divergence. This multi-granularity analysis substantially strengthens the causal story.

  1. Insightful pre-action processing experiment.

The preparation experiment in Section 5 (free-form notes C vs. complete reconstruction R vs. direct action D) reveals an interesting asymmetry: under the same preparation budget, free-form notes outperform requiring explicit complete reconstruction. This finding goes beyond a binary "provide or not" comparison and delivers practical guidance on how to exploit derivable information.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Environments are highly controlled.

TextWorld and ALFWorld are gamified text and simulation environments whose "derivation rules" form a pre-specified, fully formalized, deterministic rule set. In real-world agent tasks such as code execution, database queries, API calls, the scope of derived information, the completeness of the rule set, and whether the "exactly derivable" condition holds at all are far less clear than this paper assumes. Whether the exact reconstruction check is even verifiable in real deployments is an important question the paper does not address.

  1. Narrow model coverage with inconsistent configurations across experiments.

The main quantitative results come from Qwen3.8-27B with thinking disabled. ALFWorld adds Gemma and DeepSeek for action-level comparisons, but task-level success comparisons cover only two models, and the thinking mode is toggled differently across experiments. Without systematic control over model scale, training data, and instruction tuning, the conclusion that "the effect varies across executors" is hard to bound.

  1. No analysis of which derivations are hardest.

The paper focuses on the binary presence or absence of derived conclusions, but does not analyze which properties of a derivation (such as chain depth, number of premises, counter-intuitive rules) predict failure under the Derivable condition. Such analysis would substantially deepen understanding of why LLMs fail to perform these derivations on demand, and would create a more direct connection to the rule-reasoning literature the paper cites (Clark et al., 2020; Dziri et al., 2023).

  1. ALFWorld experiments are asymmetric with TextWorld.

TextWorld provides complete task success rates, action-level analysis, and preparation experiments. ALFWorld provides only task-level success rates for two models and action-level comparisons for three models, with no preparation experiment. This asymmetry weakens the cross-environment generalization and leaves open whether the preparation-experiment findings extend beyond TextWorld.

  1. Uneven statistical reporting.

TextWorld results use exact sign tests; ALFWorld action-level results include paired tests with confidence intervals; but some results, particularly for Gemma and DeepSeek in ALFWorld and for Qwen with thinking enabled, are reported as point estimates only with qualitative uncertainty labels such as "uncertain." For a paper whose primary contribution rests on precise experimental control, the statistical reporting should match that standard throughout.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the pass rate of the exact reconstruction check? How many tasks or states were excluded because they did not pass it, and what were the predominant causes of failure (rule ambiguity, incomplete state, other)? This number directly bounds the scope of the conclusions.

  2. Appendix C.3 notes that all 60 TextWorld tasks have the same maximum derivation depth. Does the derivation complexity vary at all across those tasks? If all derivations are single-step, how should readers interpret the paper's generalizability to deeper derivation chains?

  3. In the preparation experiment, conditions C and R share the same "preparation budget." How is this budget operationalized, eg, in tokens, reasoning steps, or something else? And how many reconstruction steps can C complete within that budget on average? If C cannot complete a full reconstruction within the budget, then C < R may simply reflect that full reconstruction is more expensive than free-form notes, rather than that partial reconstruction is worse.

  4. Qwen3.8-27B with thinking disabled is the primary executor for the main results. Was this configuration chosen specifically because the effect disappears with thinking enabled? If so, does this imply that the effect is largely absent in modern reasoning models under their default settings?

  5. The paper's core condition "exact derivability" is verified offline with a deterministic checker. Is this check feasible at inference time in real systems? For cases that are "mostly derivable" or "approximately derivable," how should practitioners apply this paper's conclusions?

2 comments

Thanks for the detailed responses. The clarifications address some of my questions, but the results with thinking enabled further suggest that the effect is largely mitigated by sufficient reasoning computation, which limits the practical significance of the findings. I will maintain my original score.

Thank you for the follow-up. We agree that with thinking enabled both conditions reach ceiling on the TextWorld tasks (60/60 vs. 59/60 at 4K, 59/60 vs. 59/60 at 16K), and the revised paper states this.

Two results in the updated PDF bear on practical significance. First, the mitigation is paid for in generated tokens. On the same tasks, Explicit without thinking completes 57/60 and Derivable with thinking 59/60, while Derivable generates about 35 times the completion tokens per task (8,691 vs. 246 at the 16K limit) and 1.24 times the total tokens. Stating the values adds about 6% to the first prompt. Second, reasoning was not always sufficient. At the first ALFWorld decisions with thinking enabled, Derivable ran out of tokens before returning an action in 39 of 100 states, against 9 for Explicit, at 16K, and in 22 against 5 at 32K. In BabyAI at 8K, 19 Derivable and 10 Explicit executions stopped before returning an action.

Omission was therefore safe only when the executor reasoned and its generation limit did not bind, which is known only at run time (Section 6, Appendices C.6 and C.9).

Reviewer_f3zeOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates a specific question: if certain information—which could otherwise be accurately deduced from the provided facts and rules—is removed from an agent’s input, will the agent’s behavior still change?

The authors construct paired interfaces: an "Explicit" (E) interface, which directly presents the derived conclusions, and a "Derivable" (D) interface, which provides the facts and rules necessary for deduction but omits the conclusions themselves. The study compares task success rates and action selections under identical states across TextWorld, BabyAI, and ALFWorld. It also incorporates various controls, such as neutral padding, the repetition of premises, the partial disclosure of conclusions, pre-action preparation, and constraints on "reasoning budget."

The primary findings indicate a significant disparity: in TextWorld, using the Qwen model without a "thinking" (reasoning) process, the E configuration achieved 58/60 successes, compared to 21/60 for the D configuration; in ALFWorld, the results were 16/100 versus 1/100. However, this gap is highly dependent on the specific model and configuration. When the "thinking" process is enabled in TextWorld, both conditions reach 60/60 success; similarly, in BabyAI, with a 16K reasoning budget, both E and D configurations achieve 55/60. Consequently, the paper’s most compelling conclusion is that formal reconstructibility—the theoretical possibility of deriving information—is insufficient to guarantee consistent behavior under specific execution configurations.

Critical strengths
  • The research questions and interventions are clearly defined. Unlike direct comparisons between differently compressed texts, the E/D (Elimination/Deletion) design explicitly specifies what has been removed; by employing a deterministic reconstruction check, it mitigates the risk that a failure might be attributed to the loss of essential facts. (Section 3, Appendix A)
  • The primary results are robust and supported by various controls. In TextWorld, the performance gap reaches 61.7 percentage points. Analyses involving neutral padding, repeated premises, and state-preserving actions further demonstrate that the explicit presentation of conclusions—rather than mere differences in text length—is the driving factor.
  • The statistical treatment is rigorous. The study employs task-paired analysis, nests repeated experimental trials within tasks, and applies multiple-comparison corrections to the primary family of statistical tests. Furthermore, the authors transparently acknowledge that certain inverse estimates, budget-related interactions, and null results cannot be interpreted as evidence of harm or equivalence.
  • The supplementary material offers genuine value for auditing. I independently verified the success counts for TextWorld—21/60, 60/60, 42/60, and 58/60 for the D, C, R, and E conditions, respectively—and cross-checked the primary figures for ALFWorld and BabyAI. By recalculating the states preceding 1,521 archived actions—using the publicly available base predicates and rules—I found that the derived results align with the archived data. While this confirms internal consistency, it does not constitute an independent replication of the model itself.
Critical weaknesses
  • The claim of "deducibility" relies on formal semantics, yet the mechanistic explanation remains insufficient. As noted on page 4 and in Appendix A, the direct action prompts in TextWorld do not explicitly provide the full procedure for computing the least fixed point under the Closed-World Assumption (CWA)—a process that is, however, included in the C/R (Chain-of-Reasoning) preparation phase. While this does not invalidate the findings regarding deterministic reconstruction, it limits the extent to which performance gaps can be attributed solely to a "lack of deductive computation." A supplementary experiment using an explicit procedure yielded a score of 20/60, offering some support; however, because this experiment employed reformulated instructions and was executed independently of the historical context, it fails to fully disentangle the impact of prompt phrasing from that of additional computation.
  • Claims that increasing the "budget" (compute/token limit) "eliminates the gap" should be interpreted with caution. In the BabyAI experiments, the precise test for the difference between the 8K and 16K settings yields p≈0.093p \approx 0.093, with a confidence interval of [−31.7,+1.7][-31.7, +1.7] percentage points—a range that includes zero. Furthermore, 35 out of the 39 failures occurred before the generation of the next action, suggesting that the results are heavily influenced by output truncation rather than a genuine improvement in deductive reasoning capabilities (see Appendix C.7). Although the authors acknowledge these limitations, the generalizations presented in the abstract may lead readers to overstate the strength of the evidence.
  • The task structure and interface design constrain external validity. The 60 tasks in the TextWorld dataset share identical parameters—specifically, the maximum deduction depth, the number of derived predicates, and the number of rules—while the interface employs opaque action identifiers. Although the positive results from ALFWorld extend the scope of environments, the absolute success rate in the E (experimental) condition remains only 16%. Consequently, these findings cannot be readily extrapolated to scenarios involving natural language tool outputs, the compression of long interaction histories, or real-world workflows.
  • The P50 metric fails to isolate the effect of pure information volume. Because it represents a single, pre-selected subset (the median 50%), the progression from P0 to P50 to E alters both the quantity and the specific identity of the conclusions reached. A more robust demonstration of a general "dosage" relationship would require testing across multiple random subsets, varying the positions of conclusions, and controlling for task-specific correlations (see Sections 3.3 and 5.2).
  • The chain of evidence and the conclusions regarding cost remain subject to significant limitations. For some results, only aggregated category counts or condensed action logs are available; the original requests and responses are not included. Furthermore, certain service configuration records are incomplete. While the existing materials allow for the verification of many statistical metrics, they do not provide a comprehensive basis for auditing the sources of the model's responses. Additionally, since costs vary based on success rates and trajectory lengths, the total token count cannot be directly interpreted as an efficiency advantage for achieving an equivalent success rate.
Questions for authors
  • Could you provide a controlled comparison—maintaining consistent phrasing and formal semantics—that isolates the individual effects of "displaying derived values," "explaining the derivation process," and "adding preparatory tool calls"?
  • Could the experiments be repeated across multiple randomized P50 subsets, while varying the derivation depth, the number of rules, and the placement of key conclusions, in order to disentangle the contribution of information volume from that of the specific content?
  • Could the interaction between the computational budget and the E/D (explanation/derivation) ratio be re-examined in a setting where action return rates are relatively uniform and truncation is minimized—while reporting task success and successful action returns separately?
  • Could you incorporate more natural tool interfaces and utilize more challenging tasks—designed to avoid "ceiling effects" in reasoning patterns—to test the generalizability of your conclusions?
  • Could you provide anonymized raw request/response data along with the full service configuration, and report the token usage, number of tool calls, and latency required to achieve comparable success rates?

Comments on the paper

5 comments
Area_Chair_vy96OpenReview ↗

Reviewer comments

Summary: This paper studies whether removing information changes an LLM agent’s behavior even when that information remains exactly derivable from the retained facts and rules.

Strengths: The paper offers a useful systems lesson while acknowledging its limits. When derived information is inexpensive to compute, supplying it directly can avoid an additional model preparation call. On the TextWorld tasks completed by both approaches, this uses fewer tokens and model calls. Reporting the thinking-enabled results, mixed outcomes across models, and truncation issues also helps readers understand where this lesson applies and where further evidence is needed.

The main finding is substantial and supported by repeated comparisons. In the main TextWorld experiment, providing derived information raises success from 21/60 to 58/60. Large gains also appear in a separate precision configuration and the shared-format experiment. The paired statistical analysis strengthens confidence that the effect is reliable within these settings.

Weaknesses:

One of the biggest issues of this work is that the practical significance remains unclear. The largest gains occur with thinking disabled. With thinking enabled, the main TextWorld gap nearly disappears even at the original token limit, while the cost results are mixed. Cross-model comparisons also use different or incompletely documented reasoning settings. The paper establishes that omission can matter, but provides limited guidance/evidence on when it matters or offers a consistent practical advantage.

The novelty needs better and clearer positioning against prior work. StateAct already examines reasoning, state tracking, and the drawbacks of imposing a JSON representation. State Design Matters studies how state representations affect sequential decisions beyond information availability. The authors should better highlight the specific contributions of their work and position it accurately with the current literature. The exact-reconstruction check provides a useful distinction, but the paper should explain what additional insight it offers beyond these findings.

Also, it seems that the reconstruction errors complicate the preparation comparison. It will be better if the authors can clarify on this aspect. Free-form notes outperform mandatory reconstruction, but the generated registries contain errors that could explain the performance difference. Even the later 91% registry accuracy does not rule this out across a full episode. Correcting registries throughout complete trajectories would clarify whether free-form preparation has an advantage beyond producing more accurate intermediate information.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Practical Significance

Thank you for the careful assessment. We answer the three weaknesses in two comments. This comment covers practical significance, and the next covers positioning and the preparation comparison, including the registry correction you suggested.

Practical significance. We agree that the largest gains come from runs with thinking disabled, that with thinking enabled the TextWorld success gap closes even at the original 4K limit, and that within thinking-enabled runs the completion-token comparisons point both ways (third case of the guidance table). Success within one configuration, however, understates what omission costs when the system could have stated the values. Two new analyses and one new run on the same tasks and states measure it.

Cost across configurations. On the same 60 TextWorld tasks, Explicit without thinking completes 57/60 and Derivable with thinking 59/60 (Derivable minus Explicit, +3.33 pp [−3.33, 10.00]). To reach this, Derivable uses 8,445 more completion tokens per task at the 16K limit [8,148, 8,746], including reasoning output, with 415 calls in each condition. Mean completion tokens per task were 246 for Explicit without thinking, against 8,691 and 8,439 for Derivable with thinking at 16K and 4K, about 35 times as many. Total tokens are 1.24 times those of Explicit, because prompts make up most of the total. With the values stated, the executor acts without thinking and comes within two tasks of the thinking run, without spending those completion tokens.

First ALFWorld decisions with thinking. For the first decision from 100 fixed states, we re-analyzed the 16K run in the paper and reran the same 200 requests at a 32K limit (on different hardware).

LimitTruncated (E / D)Applicable action within the limit, post hoc (E / D)Mean completion tokens (E / D)Returned actions, rescues / reverse
16K9 / 3991 / 57 (+34 pp [24, 44])4,887 / 11,0154 / 0
32K5 / 2294 / 74 (+20 pp [11, 30])5,244 / 16,0384 / 0

The post hoc endpoint counts a truncated output as a failure. At 32K, Derivable is still truncated in 22 states and uses about three times the completion tokens of Explicit. For the action itself, the returned-action estimate of Table 2 is +4 pp in both runs (exact p = .125). Bounds on the same difference over all states, with actions extracted from truncated outputs where possible, are [−4, +31] pp at 16K and [+3, +7] pp at 32K. With thinking, omission in ALFWorld costs completion tokens and truncations, and its effect on the chosen action is not significant in either run.

Together with the results in the paper, these give the following guidance.

Executor before actingEffect of omissionEvidence
No reasoningLower successTextWorld with thinking off (E/D 58/21, 57/18, 47/25 with FP8, 42/0 with readable tool calls), ALFWorld 16/1, same-state gains for Qwen (+8 pp) and Gemma (+10 pp)
Reasoning, and the generation limit bindsMore decisions end without an actionALFWorld first decisions at 16K and 32K (above), BabyAI at 8K (19 Derivable vs. 10 Explicit executions)
Reasoning, and the limit does not bindBoth conditions near ceiling, completion-token difference inconsistent in signTextWorld at 4K and 16K (Derivable +1,840 per task at 16K, +27%), padding control on another sample (Explicit +764)

Which of the last two cases applies is settled only at run time, and omission makes a binding limit more likely, since Derivable needed two to three times the completion tokens of Explicit at the first ALFWorld decision.

When the system can compute the derived state, stating it matched or improved Qwen's success in every configuration tested. In TextWorld the stated values add about 6% to the first prompt. When the system cannot compute it, the executor has to compute it before acting, through thinking or a preparation call. Describing the derivation procedure alone gives no measurable gain (+3.33 pp [−5.00, 13.33]). Because the effect of omission varied with the executor and its inference settings, an omission checked for one executor has to be checked again when either changes.

Settings across models. Every statement about executors rests on estimates that pair Explicit and Derivable within one executor and one setting, and the cross-configuration cost above stays within Qwen. DeepSeek and GLM ran with thinking enabled (Table 1 and Appendix B.2 will state this). Their point estimates favor Derivable (BabyAI 57/60 vs. 60/60 and 53/60 vs. 58/60, and 33/100 vs. 39/100 for DeepSeek in ALFWorld, all exact p ≥ .070). This matches Qwen with thinking in TextWorld, where stating the values also brings no gain in success.

In the revised PDF, Section 6 will add the cross-configuration cost and the three cases above, Section 5.4 the ALFWorld truncation counts and the post hoc endpoint, and Appendix C.9 the cross-tabulation, token use, and the 32K run with its hardware.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Positioning and the preparation comparison

Positioning against StateAct and State Design Matters. Both works show that the way state is represented affects agent performance. In StateAct, the agent writes its goal and state in its own output at every step, and an appendix ablation on ALFWorld finds that a JSON format lowers its success (77.0% to 58.5% with gpt-3.5). State Design Matters holds model parameters fixed, varies the granularity, structure, and spatial grounding of the state, and finds natural language the most robust format across models. Mandatory structured reconstruction fell short of free-form notes in our runs, which points the same way as both, and the correction run below measures how much of that shortfall comes from errors in the generated registry.

Both works vary how the state is encoded or have the agent write it itself. What our exact-reconstruction check adds is a comparison in which the representation stays fixed and only logically redundant content is removed, namely conclusions exactly derivable from the retained facts and rules. A deterministic checker verifies this redundancy at every visited state, so no condition loses information. Under this control, four findings follow.

  1. An omission that is lossless by construction still changes behavior with thinking disabled, so derivability alone does not guarantee behavioral preservation.
  2. The effect comes from the stated conclusions. Neutral padding, repeated premises, and five balanced masks that state half of the conclusions fall short of full exposure, and success rises with the number of conclusions stated.
  3. It appears in a single decision from the same state (31 direct rescues and 0 reverse cases in TextWorld, and gains for Qwen and Gemma on fixed ALFWorld states).
  4. Describing the derivation procedure gives no measurable gain, while computation before acting closes the gap on these TextWorld tasks (interaction between thinking and condition −65.00 pp [−78.33, −51.67]). Stated conclusions and model-side reasoning can therefore substitute for each other in task success on these tasks, and the cost figures in our previous comment price this substitution.

State Design Matters likewise attributes the advantage of text-based spatial encodings to the construction they require of the model, and StateAct observes that thoughts and goal reminders help its state tracking. Both fit the fourth finding, whose other side is that stated conclusions let the executor act without that computation.

Registry errors and the preparation comparison. We agree that registry errors matter, and we ran the full-trajectory correction you proposed. On the same 60 tasks, R keeps its preparation call at every decision, and a deterministic evaluator then replaces the generated registry with the correct one before the action is chosen. All other inputs and settings follow the shared-format R run, and comparisons with the shared-format arms pair tasks across separate executions.

R registries fully correctR successRun
51% (202/395)42/60submitted comparison
91% (373/409)54/60shared-format comparison
100% (corrected at every decision)56/60new run

R rises with registry accuracy across the three runs (42, 54, and 56 of 60), and the largest step, from 42 to 54, coincides with the change of action template. In the shared-format run, Explicit completes 57/60 and free-form preparation (C) 60/60. Corrected R differs from uncorrected R by +3.33 pp [−3.33, 10.00] (exact McNemar p = .625), from Explicit by −1.67 pp [−8.33, 5.00] (p = 1), and from C by −6.67 pp [−13.33, −1.67] (p = .125, Holm .375). The four tasks that still fail received a correct registry at every decision, so registry errors do not explain them, and C solves all four.

In the uncorrected shared-format run, episodes with every registry correct succeed in 38 of 40 cases and episodes with an error in 16 of 20.

With correct registries, mandatory reconstruction completes 56/60 and stating the values directly 57/60, while free-form preparation completes four more tasks (exact p = .125, Holm .375). One of those four tasks succeeded in the uncorrected run, and the correction itself raised R by a net two tasks (p = .625). In answer to your question, any advantage of free-form preparation beyond accurate intermediate information is limited to these four tasks. With correct content, the mandatory format performs close to stating the values directly, which fits the account in Section 6 that the executor needs correct derived values when it chooses the action.

In the revised PDF, Sections 5.3 and 6 and Appendix C.6 will report these results in place of the statement that free-form notes serve the executor better than a complete registry, and C.6 will add the corrected run and the per-episode audit. Sections 2 and 5.3 will cite both works. We will post the locations in this thread once the updated PDF is uploaded.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.