- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper observes medical image super-resolution and proposes the Frequency-Aware Representation Enhancer (FARE), a plug-and-play module designed to improve mid- and high-frequency representations. The method integrates frequency-specific enhancement with adaptive fusion to improve reconstruction quality. Experiments across multiple medical imaging datasets, SR backbones, and task settings demonstrate generally positive improvements, supported by additional ablation.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed FARE framework provides a reasonable frequency-aware design that explicitly enhances mid- and high-frequency representations for medical image super-resolution.
-
The experiments across multiple datasets and backbones demonstrate generally positive improvements. The extensive ablation studies and additional evaluations further support the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is somewhat limited. The proposed framework mainly combines existing frequency decomposition, structural guidance, and cross-frequency gating techniques, while its technical differences from prior work are not sufficiently clarified.
-
The performance improvements on several strong backbones are relatively marginal. Although the Appendix provides statistical significance analysis in one setting, the reliability of these improvements across independent training runs remains insufficiently evaluated.
-
The computational overhead is relatively substantial. As shown in Appendix Table 6, FARE significantly increases the parameters, FLOPs, and inference latency, while the performance gains on several strong backbones are modest. Further experimental verification is required.
-
The validation of the core frequency-selection and fusion mechanisms remains insufficient. The Gaussian mask in AMFD is formulated using spectral magnitudes rather than explicit frequency coordinates, and the ablation studies do not isolate the contribution of FusionGate from the combined HFSA and AMFD modules.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify how the Gaussian mask in Equations (4)–(5) selectively isolates mid-frequency components and provide visualizations of the learned frequency masks?
Could the authors provide an ablation combining HFSA and AMFD without FusionGate, combine with a computation-matched comparison, to better isolate the contribution of the fusion mechanism?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer bmgv (2/2)
W4/Q1. "Could the authors clarify how the Gaussian mask in Equations (4)–(5) selectively isolates mid-frequency components and provide visualizations of the learned frequency masks?"
The Gaussian acts on the spectral magnitude by design, and it isolates mid frequencies in three steps. First, feature spectra are dominated by low frequencies, so magnitude decays with radial frequency on average. Second, the largest magnitudes therefore form the low-frequency core, and the smallest form the high-frequency noise floor. Third, a Gaussian centered at intermediate magnitudes suppresses both ends and passes the band in between.
The magnitude domain also adds adaptivity. Since (w, b) is predicted per patch, the band follows each patch's content. Since each coefficient is weighted by its own magnitude, the band is also not confined to a radially symmetric ring. A coordinate-based mask with the same per-patch parameters is confined to one. We verify this with a controlled test (ATD, blind ×4; now in Table 4):
| AMFD spectral mask | In-house PSNR / SSIM / LPIPS | Kvasir PSNR / SSIM / LPIPS |
|---|---|---|
| Uniform, M ≡ 1 (no spectral selection) | 29.43 / 0.7491 / 0.1400 | 34.69 / 0.8770 / 0.1108 |
| Coordinate-based Gaussian | 29.49 / 0.7529 / 0.1377 | 34.77 / 0.8770 / 0.1107 |
| Magnitude-based Gaussian (ours) | 29.54 / 0.7541 / 0.1359 | 34.81 / 0.8774 / 0.1105 |
Without spectral selection, FARE falls to the HFSA-only level (29.43 vs. 29.42 dB, in-house). The coordinate-based mask recovers only part of the gain, and the magnitude-based mask is best on every metric and on both datasets. We report this test instead of a mask visualization, because a visualization shows where a mask acts but not whether the selection matters.
W4/Q2. "Could the authors provide an ablation combining HFSA and AMFD without FusionGate, combine with a computation-matched comparison ...?"
Yes. As requested by the reviewer, we replace FusionGate (Eq. 7–8) with plain addition of the HFSA and AMFD outputs and keep all else fixed. The two variants differ only by the two 1×1 convolutions of Eq. (7) per block, so their computation is essentially matched (ATD, blind ×4; now in Table 4):
| Variant | In-house PSNR / SSIM / LPIPS | Kvasir PSNR / SSIM / LPIPS |
|---|---|---|
| HFSA only | 29.42 / 0.7492 / 0.1402 | 34.67 / 0.8770 / 0.1108 |
| AMFD only | 29.44 / 0.7502 / 0.1392 | 34.77 / 0.8774 / 0.1108 |
| HFSA + AMFD, addition | 29.47 / 0.7523 / 0.1385 | 34.76 / 0.8772 / 0.1108 |
| HFSA + AMFD, FusionGate (ours) | 29.54 / 0.7541 / 0.1359 | 34.81 / 0.8774 / 0.1105 |
FusionGate beats addition on every metric and on both datasets. With addition, the combined model barely improves on the better single branch: +0.03 dB in-house and no gain on Kvasir (34.76 vs. 34.77 dB). With FusionGate, the gain is 0.10/0.04 dB. FusionGate therefore contributes on its own.
We hope these results address the reviewer's concerns, and we would be grateful if the reviewer would consider raising the score.
As the rebuttal deadline approaches, We greatly look forward to hearing back from you. If there are additional questions or points that require further elaboration, we welcome them and will do our best to respond promptly and effectively before the deadline.
Response to Reviewer bmgv (1/2)
We thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of our design and experiments, and for the constructive suggestions. Table and figure numbers refer to the revised PDF.
W1. "The methodological novelty is somewhat limited ... technical differences from prior work are not sufficiently clarified."
FARE is built on a principle that prior frequency-aware SR does not address. In medical images, mid frequencies carry contextual tissue textures, whereas high frequencies carry sharp boundaries (Appendix G.1). Their balance also varies strongly across images (Fig. 1). Prior methods contrast low with high frequencies or treat all high frequencies as one pool. FARE instead separates the two bands, adapts the mid band per patch, and lets the bands gate each other. Each difference is tested (PSNR, in-house/Kvasir):
The two branches are also non-redundant: the NMI between their responses is only 0.0747 ± 0.0016 (Appendix G.2).
W2. "The performance improvements on several strong backbones are relatively marginal. ... the reliability of these improvements across independent training runs remains insufficiently evaluated."
W3. "The computational overhead is relatively substantial."
We report the overhead openly (Table 6: 65 → 96 ms per image for ATD). It is justified on three counts.
References