- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents World Action Agent (WAA), a VLM-based harness for robot manipulation combining interaction-centered views, action previews with planning feedback, and closed-loop visual corrections. It also supports multimodal skill learning and smaller-model training from interaction traces. Experiments report 75.6% average success on LIBERO-Pro using skills learned from LIBERO-90, transfer of frozen skills to robosuite, and improved performance after fine-tuning a Qwen3.5-9B main agent.
Critical strengths
-
A comprehensive and coherent system
WAA integrates multi-view observation, action rehearsal, in-view correction, and skill guidance into a unified robot-control framework. The system addresses multiple practical challenges across the manipulation workflow, giving the work meaningful engineering value.
-
Substantial gains on spatial tasks
WAA reports 80.0% and 73.3% success on the two LIBERO-Pro Spatial splits, compared with ASPIRE’s reported 51.0% and 60.0%. These improvements provide concrete evidence of the system’s value for tasks requiring precise spatial alignment.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient ablation of the core designs
The paper lacks ablations of Contact views, action rehearsal, and in-view correction. Consequently, it is difficult to identify each component’s contribution to the reported gains or assess whether all three are necessary.
-
Limited difficulty and coverage of the robosuite evaluation
The evaluation includes only cube lifting, stacking, and restacking. Lifting and stacking already achieve 100% success without learned skills. This relatively simple and narrow task set provides limited evidence for skill transfer to more diverse and challenging manipulation tasks.
Questions for authors
-
Additional evidence—core component contributions:
Can the authors provide controlled ablations of Contact views, action rehearsal, and in-view correction, keeping the backbone and skill library fixed? These results would help establish which proposed mechanisms account for the performance gains.
-
Clarification—robosuite evaluation:
How many trials were conducted, and how varied were the initial states for each task? Given that lifting and stacking already achieve 100% success without learned skills, how broadly should the reported skill-transfer results be interpreted?