- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents HarnessWAM, an external agentic framework for organizing a World Action Model’s local execution capabilities into long-horizon task execution. A VLM-based Task Manager maintains scene beliefs, evidence memory, and a task graph with partially bound variables. A capability-conditioned compiler maps proposed operations to supported skills while checking represented dependencies and state constraints. During execution, progress events trigger outcome verification, task-state updates, revision of the unexecuted plan suffix, and recovery that preserves previously acquired evidence. The framework is evaluated on RoboMemArena, RoboCerebra Ideal, and two UR3 manipulation tasks.
Critical strengths
-
The framework connects evidence memory, delayed target binding, task dependencies, and recovery within a consistent execution process. This design is well motivated for partially observable tasks, where acquired evidence must remain available for subsequent planning and manipulation.
-
The same-checkpoint comparison improves full-task success from 52.5% with static planning to 64.4% with the complete framework . Results across two WAM backbones and two physical tasks further support the usefulness of the overall system, although they do not independently establish methodological novelty.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological differentiation from existing agentic frameworks. Memory-guided skill orchestration is central to Harness VLA [1], while explicit state maintenance, precondition checking, and feedback-driven planning have precedents in Statler [2], ProgPrompt [3], and Inner Monologue [4], respectively. Although [1] is described as concurrent work, these broader precedents also warrant clearer differentiation. HarnessWAM’s task graph, constrained compilation, and suffix revision are concrete design choices, but their substantive advance over established orchestration principles remains insufficiently demonstrated. It is also unclear whether deliberation exploits WAM-specific predictive capabilities or treats the WAM primarily as a generic skill controller. The paper includes agentic comparisons, notably Harness VLA [1], HPE [5], and a free-form control. However, insufficient adaptation details, differences in model configurations, and the limited structure of the free-form control make attribution difficult. A matched comparison with a faithfully adapted [1] or [5], using the same planner, controller, and comparable budgets where feasible, would better isolate the proposed mechanisms.
-
Deployment overhead and latency are insufficiently characterized. The framework introduces additional VLM calls for planning, verification, and recovery, but the available manuscript does not quantify their latency, frequency, or effect on physical execution. Event-triggered scheduling may reduce overhead, and fewer failures could offset additional computation; however, success rates under environment-step budgets do not establish this trade-off. The paper should report Task Manager latency and call counts, whether deliberation blocks execution, achieved action-update frequency, and end-to-end task time against direct WAM execution and a matched agentic baseline. These measurements are important for assessing practical responsiveness and throughput.
Questions for authors
-
What specific capability or consistency property does the proposed task graph and suffix revision provide beyond the orchestration mechanisms in [1–4]? Does high-level deliberation explicitly use WAM predictive outputs? Which components would require substantive changes if the WAM were replaced by a VLA exposing a comparable skill interface?
-
How does end-to-end execution time compare with direct WAM execution and a matched agentic baseline on the physical tasks?
References
[1] Yixian Zhang et al. Harness VLA: Steering Frozen VLAs into Reliable Manipulation Primitives via Memory-Guided Agents. arXiv:2607.08448, 2026. arXiv
[2] Takuma Yoneda et al. Statler: State-Maintaining Language Models for Embodied Reasoning. IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA), 2024. arXiv:2306.17840. arXiv
[3] Ishika Singh et al. ProgPrompt: Program Generation for Situated Robot Task Planning Using Large Language Models. Autonomous Robots, 47:999–1012, 2023. DOI: 10.1007/s10514-023-10135-3. Springer
[4] Wenlong Huang et al. Inner Monologue: Embodied Reasoning through Planning with Language Models. arXiv:2207.05608, 2022. arXiv
[5] Songhao Han et al. RoboCerebra: A Large-scale Benchmark for Long-horizon Robotic Manipulation Evaluation. NeurIPS, 2025. arXiv:2506.06677. The relevant comparator is its Hierarchical Planning and Execution (HPE) framework. arXiv
5 comments
W2. Comparison with existing methods using the same Planner and Controller
We have added comparisons with HPE and PrediMem. All three methods use the same LingBot-VA checkpoint trained on RoboMemArena subtasks and Qwen3-VL-32B-Instruct as the high-level Planner. This enables a fair comparison of orchestration methods while holding both the underlying skill model and the high-level planning model fixed.
| Orchestration method | Transfer full-task SR | Occlusion full-task SR | Counting full-task SR | Sequence full-task SR | Average full-task SR | Average subtask SR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HPE | 16.3 | 62.7 | 54.3 | 71.3 | 54.6 | 71.4 |
| PrediMem | 21.3 | 66.8 | 55.0 | 75.0 | 57.9 | 73.1 |
| HarnessWAM | 22.5 | 76.8 | 59.3 | 81.3 | 64.4 | 76.8 |
HarnessWAM achieves absolute gains in average full-task SR of 9.8% over HPE and 6.5% over PrediMem. In Occlusion, which strongly depends on evidence across stages, the three methods achieve 62.7%, 66.8%, and 76.8%, respectively. The added comparison directly examines the gains over existing structured methods, while Table 4 of the paper connects these gains to specific execution mechanisms. Together, these results show that addressing WAM task-level shortcomings requires targeted execution support, and that HarnessWAM effectively addresses these issues with the underlying model held fixed.
W3. High-level reasoning overhead and execution efficiency
We have added efficiency measurements on two real-world tasks. Compared with PrediMem + LingBot-VA, HarnessWAM reduces end-to-end task time by 15.1% on Tabletop Tidying and 14.0% on Box Exploration. The time cost of high-level reasoning is an important deployment challenge for existing robotic agent methods. HarnessWAM addresses this issue through lightweight progress estimation and event-triggered scheduling that reduce high-level calls. The following real-world comparisons directly quantify the resulting efficiency improvement.
| Real-world task | Method | Average VLM calls / episode | Average latency per VLM call (ms) | Does high-level reasoning block execution? | Achieved action-update frequency (Hz) | Average end-to-end task time (s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tabletop Tidying | Direct WAM: LingBot-VA | — | — | — | 1.01 | 337 |
| Tabletop Tidying | PrediMem + LingBot-VA | 21 | 3,814 | Yes | 0.81 | 417 |
| Tabletop Tidying | HarnessWAM | 5.3 | 3,198 | Yes | 0.96 | 354 |
| Box Exploration | Direct WAM: LingBot-VA | — | — | — | 1.02 | 405 |
| Box Exploration | PrediMem + LingBot-VA | 26 | 3,964 | Yes | 0.81 | 508 |
| Box Exploration | HarnessWAM | 8.6 | 3,695 | Yes | 0.94 | 437 |
In this real-world deployment, high-level reasoning blocks execution in both PrediMem and HarnessWAM, and each VLM call takes several seconds. Reducing the number of calls is therefore particularly important for controlling the overall time overhead. HarnessWAM reduces the average call counts on the two tasks from 21 and 26 to 5.3 and 8.6, respectively, corresponding to reductions of 74.8% and 66.9%. These results further demonstrate the role of the lightweight progress estimator: it continuously tracks execution progress and concentrates VLM calls on events requiring task-level judgment, addressing long-horizon WAM shortcomings while controlling reasoning overhead.
Q1. Consistency of the task graph and suffix revision, predictive outputs, and VLA adaptation
The task graph requires target-dependent operations to execute only after evidence-grounded binding, dependency satisfaction, and fulfillment of preconditions. Node verification outcomes determine subsequent advancement. Suffix revision follows Equation (4) in the paper, , preserving the operation definitions and dependencies of executed nodes. Scene beliefs are updated from current observations, while unexecuted operations are reorganized and projected. Executed operations and failed attempts are therefore retained as history, while future plans adapt to the actual state. This property corresponds to the recovery example and suffix ablation discussed in W1. Regarding predictive outputs, a WAM's future predictions may differ from actual execution outcomes, and planning directly from them could affect subsequent target and operation choices. The high-level system therefore combines real observations, evidence memory, the task graph, and progress signals to make decisions and update the remaining plan based on actual execution outcomes. The current implementation does not directly read WAM-predicted frames. Our experiments examine the task-level execution shortcomings that remain in a local controller with world-modeling capabilities, and how an external harness can address them.
We have connected the same harness to π₀.₅ trained on RoboMemArena subtasks, achieving a full-task success rate of 44.6% and a subtask success rate of 49.7%. The replacement is at the level of the underlying skill executor, using the same action primitives, task-switching strategy, and budgets. High-level evidence maintenance, task representation, verification, and suffix-update logic remain the same. The following table compares the original results for both controllers with their results under the same harness.
| Setting | Controller type | Full-task SR (%) | Subtask SR (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original LingBot-VA | WAM | 49.0 | 60.0 |
| LingBot-VA + same Harness | WAM | 64.4 (+15.4) | 76.8 (+16.8) |
| Original π₀.₅ | VLA | 21.5 | 38.7 |
| π₀.₅ + same Harness | VLA | 44.6 (+23.1) | 49.7 (+11.0) |
Q2. Real-world end-to-end task time compared with Direct WAM and a matched agentic baseline
As shown in the real-world efficiency table in W3, HarnessWAM takes 354 s on Tabletop Tidying and 437 s on Box Exploration, reducing PrediMem's times of 417 s and 508 s by 63 s and 71 s, respectively. Compared with Direct WAM's 337 s and 405 s, the additional times are 17 s and 32 s, corresponding to overheads of 5.0% and 7.9%. Alongside these results, the real-world success rates reported in the paper increase from Direct WAM's 30.0% and 5.0% to HarnessWAM's 95.0% and 90.0%, respectively. These results show that HarnessWAM improves WAM task completion with modest additional time costs and achieves clearly better time efficiency than PrediMem in this matched real-world comparison.
These experiments clarify the capability gaps of WAMs in long-horizon tasks and validate the harness's effectiveness in addressing them. In light of the success-rate gains with a fixed WAM and the real-world efficiency results, we respectfully ask you to reassess our contribution in terms of addressing WAM shortcomings and providing the task-level support they need.
Thank you for recognizing the consistent execution design connecting evidence memory, deferred binding, task dependencies, and recovery. Below, we address your concerns about the methodological contribution and the focus on WAMs through the properties of the framework, ablations with a fixed WAM, and additional matched experiments.
W1. Relationship to existing agentic frameworks and our contribution
Our core contribution is to identify and address the capability gap that WAMs face when moving from local prediction and action execution to long-horizon tasks. WAMs can generate local actions, but long-horizon tasks also require identifying targets from earlier observations, organizing operations under skill and state constraints, and continuing the remaining task after failure. HarnessWAM builds an external harness around these shortcomings, providing evidence across stages, executability constraints, task updates grounded in feedback, and progress-driven scheduling. Experiments with a fixed WAM examine the need for and effectiveness of this task-level support. To our knowledge, this is the first work to systematically investigate and address WAM shortcomings in long-horizon tasks through a harness.
The works you cite, Statler [1], ProgPrompt [2], Inner Monologue [3], and Harness VLA [4], provide foundations for state maintenance, precondition checking, feedback-driven planning, and memory-guided orchestration. Evaluating our work solely by whether these components have precedents would overlook the WAM problem we study and the solution we provide. Our research asks what continues to limit long-horizon tasks once a WAM has acquired local skills, and whether a harness can effectively address those limitations. Evidence-grounded binding, executable-space projection, and suffix revision that preserves history address target identification across stages, skill executability, and task continuity after failure, respectively, making these problems explicit and experimentally testable.
With the same WAM checkpoint held fixed, Static Plan achieves a full-task success rate of 52.5%, while HarnessWAM reaches 64.4%, showing that task-level shortcomings remain after initial skill decomposition. Full projection raises the normalization-only success rate from 54.0% to 64.4%, demonstrating the need to address execution constraints even after instruction expressions have been standardized. Retaining memory, binding, verification, and recovery while disabling only suffix revision reduces success to 57.1%, further demonstrating the need to adapt the remaining task to execution outcomes. Together, these experiments identify specific bottlenecks in long-horizon WAM execution and validate the harness's effectiveness in addressing them.
The lightweight progress estimator addresses the coordination needed between continuous WAM execution and high-level task decisions. It dynamically tracks subtask progress and triggers VLM decisions through execution events, reducing the number of VLM calls needed for continuous progress checking. This links task-level intervention to actual execution progress. We ask that our contribution be assessed in terms of the WAM problems identified and addressed, focusing on how the harness extends existing local prediction and action capabilities into sustained, reliable long-horizon task execution.