acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

BridgeSTOP: Bridging Streaming Tokenization and LLM Prefill

12 views

Abstract

Streaming computation has been increasingly adopted across LLM serving to improve efficiency. However, existing streaming methods mainly optimize individual serving stages, while the tokenization-to-prefill path remains limited by batch-bounded inter-request execution, insufficient bridging between the two stages, and transient efficiency mismatch across them. We propose , a framework that bridges streaming tokenization and LLM prefill to improve, preserve, and propagate streaming tokenization efficiency downstream and ultimately translate it into end-to-end serving gains. first introduces batch-free asynchronous parallel tokenization, which extends streaming tokenization from intra-request processing to inter-request execution to reduce batch-bounded synchronization waiting and improve tokenization efficiency. We then establish a token pool that continuously collects streaming token outputs and controls when and how many available tokens are released to downstream prefill, preserving and propagating streaming tokenization efficiency. When upstream tokenization temporarily falls behind, we introduce speculative tokenization as a fast replenishment mechanism to replenish transient token deficits and prevent downstream prefill starvation, while the longest-match speculation strategy improves speculation accuracy and reduces rollback overhead. Experiments on Qwen3-8B across five diverse workloads show that consistently improves sustainable serving capacity and reduces latency, effectively translating streaming tokenization efficiency into end-to-end serving gains.

Primary area:
infrastructure, software libraries, hardware, systems, etc.
Keywords:
Streaming, Tokenization, LLM Prefill, LLM Serving Efficiency

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_wfpbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

BridgeSTOP connects streaming tokenization with prefill through asynchronous workers, a token pool, and speculative replenishment. Speculative tokens are verified and mismatched suffixes recomputed before decoding. Experiments measure serving capacity across five workloads on Qwen3-8B.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper evaluates end-to-end serving rather than tokenizer speed alone. Table 1 includes useful comparisons within a fixed tokenizer configuration.

  2. The verification barrier prevents decoding from unchecked speculative tokens. Appendix B also appropriately limits the CPU scheduling argument rather than extending it directly to GPU execution.

Critical weaknesses
  1. I am not yet convinced that the Stream2LLM [S26] comparison isolates the contribution. Appendix C.2 implements fixed-byte-chunk overlap, whereas [S26] also includes streaming-aware scheduling and preemption. Please clarify which mechanisms are retained and compare equally asynchronous pipelines with the same tokenizer and prefill budget. The positioning should distinguish token delivery from chunked-prefill scheduling [SS24], memory-aware admission [W25], and KV-growth-induced congestion and eviction [CG26]. Faster token delivery alone does not establish stable end-to-end throughput.

  2. The evaluation needs clearer correctness and component checks. The retrained zip2zip model and vocabulary adapters complicate cross-tokenizer comparisons: recovering the same text does not establish equal model behavior. Table 3 shows 71.5 versus 70.0 QPS with and without speculation on MMLU, where only 5% of requests trigger it; its benefit elsewhere and run-to-run variability remain unclear.

The problem is useful, but the additional benefit over a matched streaming baseline is not yet clear. Clarifying this comparison and checking model behavior could change my assessment.

Questions for authors
  1. Which [S26] mechanisms are implemented, and can both systems use the same asynchronous tokenizer? Relative to [SS24, W25, CG26], please distinguish token-pool control from scheduling and admission, and clarify how KV-memory pressure, eviction, and recomputation enter the capacity measurements.

  2. Have final prompt-token equality and generation quality been checked against the corresponding non-speculative pipeline? Please provide existing no-speculation results beyond MMLU and repeated-run variability.

[S26] Bachkaniwala, R., Luo, C., So, R., Mahajan, D., and Rong, K. (2026). Stream2LLM: Overlap Context Streaming and Prefill for Reduced Time-to-First-Token (TTFT). arXiv:2604.16395. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.16395.

[SS24] Agrawal, A., Kedia, N., Panwar, A., Mohan, J., Kwatra, N., Gulavani, B., Tumanov, A., and Ramjee, R. (2024). Taming Throughput-Latency Tradeoff in LLM Inference with Sarathi-Serve. Proceedings of the 18th USENIX Symposium on Operating Systems Design and Implementation, 117–134. https://www.usenix.org/conference/osdi24/presentation/agrawal.

[W25] Ao, R., Luo, G., Simchi-Levi, D., and Wang, X. (2025). Optimizing LLM Inference: Fluid-Guided Online Scheduling with Memory Constraints. arXiv:2504.11320, revised June 2026. https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.11320.

[CG26] Ao, R., Dong, J., Luo, G., and Simchi-Levi, D. (2026). Service-Induced Congestion in Memory-Constrained LLM Serving. arXiv:2606.15555. https://arxiv.org/abs/2606.15555.

5 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Weakness 1

We thank the reviewer for the helpful comments. We will add additional details and experiments discussed during the rebuttal to the revised paper.


Response to W1:

1. Retained Stream2LLM mechanisms: We reproduce Stream2LLM on vLLM, retaining its original mechanisms for incremental prefill, streaming-aware scheduling, and preemptive KV-cache management under FCFS. We adapt our static inputs to Stream2LLM’s append-mode interface, so that Stream2LLM's original mechanisms can be reproduced unchanged. Appendix C.2 (page 19) explains details of the workload differences and how this input adaptation enables reproduction.

2. Asynchronous comparison: BAPT improves tokenization efficiency while changing how upstream token outputs are released, requiring compatible downstream handling through BridgeSTOP’s token pool. Sarathi and Stream2LLM lack this interface and cannot directly consume BAPT’s token outputs, although Stream2LLM supports streaming. Hence, BAPT’s benefits cannot translate into their serving gains, so we only ablate BAPT from BridgeSTOP.

We set the prefill token budget to 512 for Stream2LLM, Sarathi, and BridgeSTOP to ensure a fair comparison.

3. Distinguish from SS24 W25 CG26: SS24 improves prefill–decode coordination through chunked prefill and batching, while BridgeSTOP improves tokenization–prefill efficiency transfer through token-pool control. Their target stages, objectives, and mechanisms differ. W25, CG26, and BridgeSTOP all optimize scheduling. However, W25 and CG26 address memory pressure caused by KV-cache growth during decoding, while BridgeSTOP addresses upstream efficiency translation to downstream prefill. Thus, despite optimizing scheduling, they target different serving stages and solve different core problems.

4. That tokenization cannot guarantee throughput is what we address: Faster tokenization alone cannot guarantee stable end-to-end throughput because downstream prefill may not effectively translate such upstream efficiency. This is precisely the main problem our paper aim to address. For example, IncreBPE (ICML 2026 Spotlight) proposes an efficient streaming tokenization method, but its evaluation focuses on tokenization, without end-to-end serving evaluation because it lacks effective bridging to downstream prefill. These upstream benefits require compatible downstream mechanisms to translate into serving gains. We therefore propose BridgeSTOP to preserve and propagate upstream tokenization efficiency.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Weakness 2:

Response to W2:

1. Cross-tokenizer comparisons: To evaluate cross-tokenizer effects, we report token counts, prefill and decode times, downstream quality, and serving capacity across tokenizers. 4-shot GSM8K results are presented in Table D below. Full results and analysis including 5-shot MMLU are provided in Appendix D.7 (page 26) of the updated PDF.

 1.1. Token count correlates with times but not capacity: Different tokenizers produce different token counts, thus affecting prefill and decode times. On GSM8K, token count correlates strongly with prefill and decode times (all Pearson Corr > 0.96). But, token count correlates weakly with capacity (Pearson Corr 0.099, Spearman Corr 0.051). Hence in our experiments, token count only has limited effects on our assessment of serving capacity values and rankings, thus not affecting advantages of BridgeSTOP in capacity.

 1.2. Retrained zip2zip model: Model weights can affect output quality and decode workload. On GSM8K, zip2zip achieves 83.4% accuracy versus 89.5% for native Qwen3 BPE, whose decrease is acceptable. zip2zip's average decode time is 30.2 ms over 31.5 ms from BPE, thanks to fewer token outputs. Given zip2zip’s shorter decode time, IncreBPE + BridgeSTOP still achieves higher serving capacity than the zip2zip baselines, supporting our reported advantage.

 1.3. Model behavior and downstream quality: Different token IDs can affect model behavior, i.e. downstream quality. Some tokenizers even trade quality for efficiency like zip2zip. But, the quality variations 83.1%-89.5% remain acceptable for our evaluation and thus do not change our assessment of serving capacity and latency.

Table D: Cross-tokenizer comparisons of token counts, latency, capacity, and output quality on 4-shot GSM8K. Prefill and decode times use batch size 1.

MetricLoPTzip2zipMAGNETIncreBPESPEAK
Total tokens126665119625122422126665120294
Relative to BPE100.0%94.4%96.7%100.0%95.0%
Avg. prefill (ms)31.530.231.131.530.4
Avg. decode (ms)6658.36533.86606.46658.36582.4
Capacity (QPS) #rank8.5 #49.5 #37.5 #515.0 #114.0 #2
Output quality (%)89.583.483.189.586.9

2. Vocabulary adapters: MAGNET and SPEAK use vocabulary adapters with the unchanged Qwen3 model. Although they do not exactly reproduce Qwen3 BPE, only OOV tokens require adaptation, which is reported as 0.1% tokens in Appendix C.2. Hence, such a negligible fraction is unlikely to alter tokenization quality or efficiency, thus imposing limited effects on serving capacity.

3. Speculated requests are fewer but longer: Across five workloads, 5.2–12.0% of requests trigger speculation, but their mean input lengths are 1.16×–1.82× over the dataset averages, indicating these requests are longer and engage more tokens.

Full statistics and analysis are provided in Appendix D.4 (page 24) of the updated PDF.

4. Speculation offers larger benefits under memory constraints: To examine its benefit elsewhere, we evaluate speculation on MMLU under tighter memory constraints. Longest improves capacity over Waiting by 10.9% (23->25.5) under the 20GB memory constraint, higher than the original 2.1% (70->71.5) under the 32GB memory constraint. The speculated request ratio increases from 5.2% to 12.0%. These results demonstrate larger serving benefits under memory constraints.

Full results and analysis are provided in Appendix D.5 (page 25) of the updated PDF.

5. Run-to-run variability: We performed 3 repeated runs with different seeds on MMLU. Waiting consistently satisfied the SLOs at 70.0 QPS and failed at 70.5 QPS, while Longest satisfied them at 71.5 QPS and failed at 72.0 QPS. These results confirm the reported capacity values.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Question 1-2

Response to Q1:

1. Retained Stream2LLM mechanisms: See response to W1, point 1.

2. Asynchronous comparison: See response to W1, point 2.

3. Distinguish from others: See response to W1, point 3.

4. KV-memory pressure, eviction, and recomputation: Capacity is measured end to end under the configured GPU-memory budget and SLO constraints. Any waiting, eviction, and recomputation caused by KV-memory pressure are reflected in measured serving latencies and therefore in the maximum sustainable request rate. Verification and rollback recomputation costs are also included.


Response to Q2:

1. Final prompt-token equality and generation quality: Speculation does not change the final token outputs. Speculative tokens are verified against exact tokenization outputs, and mismatches trigger rollback and re-prefill from the first mismatch onward. This preserves the exact prompt tokens and corresponding KV states. Generation therefore uses the same verified prompt-token input, model, and decoding settings as the non-speculative pipeline. Hence, we do not need this check.

2. No-speculation results and run-to-run variability: Table E below compares Waiting, i.e. the non-speculative pipeline, with our Longest-match speculation across all five workloads. Longest consistently outperforms Waiting. All reported capacity points satisfied the SLOs in 3 repeated runs, while the next tested request rate for each configuration violated the SLOs in all 3 runs.

Table E: Serving capacity of IncreBPE + BridgeSTOP with longest-match speculation and waiting for exact tokens across five workloads. Relative gain = (Longest / Waiting − 1) × 100%.

Capacity (QPS)ShareGPT4MMLUGSM8KLongBenchCLongEval
Longest1.2571.519.50.15250.2025
Waiting1.2070.018.50.13750.1925
Relative gain4.17%2.14%5.41%10.91%5.19%
Reviewer_FfZDOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

BridgeSTOP links streaming tokenization to LLM prefill through asynchronous tokenizer scheduling, a token pool, and speculative tokenization with verification and rollback. Experiments use Qwen3-8B on an RTX 5090 across five workloads and two streaming tokenizer backends. Table 1 reports serving-capacity gains of up to about 22% over corresponding Stream2LLM configurations, supported by latency measurements and selected component ablations.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper studies a practical gap between tokenizer speed and overall serving performance. Its token pool addresses the tension between releasing tokens early and maintaining efficient prefill workloads.

  2. Five workloads, including long inputs and Chinese text, and two streaming tokenizer backends provide useful coverage. Within-tokenizer capacity comparisons and TTFT/TBT measurements offer evidence beyond tokenizer-only speedups.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The comparisons do not isolate the proposed bridge from asynchronous tokenizer scheduling. Table 1 removes BAPT from BridgeSTOP but does not add equivalent scheduling to Sarathi or Stream2LLM. Appendix C.2 also leaves the retained Stream2LLM mechanisms unclear. Comparisons across tokenizer backends change token sequences and, for zip2zip, model weights, without reporting actual token counts or downstream quality. These confounds weaken attribution of the serving gains.

  2. The speculation ablation covers only MMLU, where capacity rises from 70.0 to 71.5 QPS, about 2.1%, without uncertainty across repeated runs. The comparison omits immediately prefilling available exact tokens. Sections 3.2 and 3.3 also leave the policy for completed inputs below the 512-token target and complete KV invalidation after a mismatch unclear. Both the performance benefit and correctness need stronger evidence.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the serving capacity when Sarathi and Stream2LLM use the same asynchronous tokenizer workers and prefill budget? Which original Stream2LLM scheduling and cache-management mechanisms were retained?

  2. For the adapted MAGNET and SPEAK configurations, what are the actual prompt lengths and downstream quality relative to native Qwen3 tokenization?

  3. How does rollback handle byte alignment and invalidate all affected KV states? What happens when the pool is empty or completed inputs contain fewer than 512 tokens?

  4. How does speculation compare with immediate partial prefill across the five workloads, including verification and recomputation costs? Please report variability across repeated measurements.

  5. Please specify the serving engine, precision, output settings, arrival process, run duration, and backlog checks used to establish sustainable capacity.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Weakness 1-2

We thank the reviewer for the helpful comments. We will add additional details and experiments discussed during the rebuttal to the revised paper.


Response to W1:

1. Ablation of BAPT for Sarathi and Stream2LLM: BAPT improves tokenization efficiency while changing how upstream tokens are released, requiring compatible downstream handling through BridgeSTOP’s token pool. Sarathi and Stream2LLM lack this interface and cannot directly consume BAPT’s outputs, although Stream2LLM supports streaming. Hence, BAPT’s benefits cannot translate into their serving gains, so we only ablate BAPT from BridgeSTOP.

2. Retained Stream2LLM mechanisms: We reproduce Stream2LLM on vLLM, retaining its original mechanisms for incremental prefill, streaming-aware scheduling, and preemptive KV-cache management under FCFS. We adapt our static inputs to Stream2LLM’s append-mode interface, so that Stream2LLM's original mechanisms can be reproduced unchanged. Appendix C.2 (page 19) explains details of the workload differences and how this input adaptation enables reproduction.

3. Token count and downstream quality: Different tokenizers change token counts and downstream quality. Table B in our response to 1st reviewer Kxkf’s Q2&3 reports these results together with prefill and decode times and serving capacity on GSM8K, with full results in Appendix D.7 (page 26) of the updated PDF. IncreBPE and LoPT reproduce native Qwen3 BPE token sequences, so relative to them is just to BPE.

We find that token count correlates with prefill&decode time, and quality (all Pearson Corr > 0.83), but weakly with serving capacity (Pearson Corr 0.099, Spearman Corr 0.051). Meanwhile, although some methods like zip2zip trade quality for efficiency, we consider the observed quality variations 83.1%-89.5% acceptable. Hence, both token count and quality only have limited effects on our assessment of serving capacity values and rankings, thus not affecting advantages of BridgeSTOP in capacity.

4. zip2zip changes model weight: Model weights can affect output quality and decode workload. On GSM8K, zip2zip achieves 83.4% accuracy versus 89.5% for native Qwen3 BPE, whose decrease is acceptable. zip2zip's average decode time is 30.2 ms over 31.5 ms from BPE, thanks to fewer token outputs. Given zip2zip’s shorter decode time, IncreBPE + BridgeSTOP still achieves higher serving capacity than the zip2zip baselines, supporting our reported advantage.

Summary: Our ablation setting, baseline reproduction, and tokenizers' effects have no problem in our method's advantage in serving efficiency.


Response to W2:

1. Repeated runs: In LLM serving, most studies search for maximum sustainable capacity use a single fixed random seed, like Sarathi (OSDI 2024), Splitwise (ISCA 2024). Accordingly, all our experiments use the same fixed random seed for capacity searches.

Additionally, we performed 3 repeated runs with different seeds. Waiting consistently satisfied the SLOs at 70.0 QPS and failed at 70.5 QPS, while Longest satisfied them at 71.5 QPS and failed at 72.0 QPS. These results confirm the reported capacity values.

2. Across all datasets, including direct prefill: We extend the Longest vs Waiting comparison to all five datasets and add Direct prefill, displayed in Table C below. We find that direct prefill frequently executes small GEMMs with few available tokens, reducing GPU utilization and increasing execution overhead. Its capacity is apparently lower across all five datasets, while Longest consistently outperforms Waiting.

Table C: Full ablation of speculative tokenization. Relative gain = (Longest / Waiting − 1) × 100%.

Capacity (QPS)ShareGPT4MMLUGSM8KLongBenchCLongEval
Longest1.2571.519.50.15250.2025
Waiting1.2070.018.50.13750.1925
Direct prefill1.1066.015.50.12000.1525
Relative gain4.17%2.14%5.41%10.91%5.19%

3. Completed input below 512: This is a simple Python implementation, thus not discussed in the paper. The solution is simply to send the remaining tokens directly to prefill. Actually, last input request sends a flag, with another flag when the tokenizer finishes this request, together confirming that all tokens have been emitted. Then the pool directly prefills the remainder, even below 512 tokens.

4. Complete KV invalidation: The paper clearly states that, when speculation is incorrect, all tokens from the first mismatch onward undergo rollback and re-prefill (page 6, lines 289–291). Because KV computation during prefill follows autoregressive dependencies, everything from the first incorrect token onward must be recomputed.

Summary: The capacity gains are reproducible and consistent across datasets, with correct handling of remaining tokens and KV rollback.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Question 1-5

Response to Q1:

1. Asynchronous for Sarathi and Stream2LLM: See response to W1 point 1.

2. Prefill budget of Sarathi and Stream2LLM: With Stream2LLM’s 2048-byte input chunks, the reported mean chunk lengths range from 427 to 595 tokens for 5 workloads, consistent with our expectation of close to 512 tokens. We set the prefill token budget to 512 for Stream2LLM, Sarathi, and BridgeSTOP to ensure a fair comparison.

3. Retained Stream2LLM mechanisms: See response to W1 point 2.


Response to Q2:

See our response to W1, point 3.


Response to Q3:

See our response to W2, points 3&4.


Response to Q4:

See our response to W2, point 1&2.


Response to Q5:

1.Serving engine: Sarathi and Stream2LLM use their respective original serving engines. Our method is built upon the Sarathi engine, with modifications to support BridgeSTOP and BAPT. 2. Precision: Qwen3-8B uses BF16. 3. Output settings: We use greedy decoding with predefined per-request output lengths, ignoring EOS. MMLU generates one token per request. 4. Arrival process: Capacity search uses a fixed-seed Poisson arrival generator with inter-arrival times capped at 3/λ, where λ is the configured QPS. This aligns with Sarathi's implementation. 5. Run duration: Each run processes a predefined request list until all requests finish, excluding warm-up. Duration varies with the workload and request rate and is recorded for each run. 6. Backlog checks: We require all submitted requests to complete. No separate threshold on backlog growth or the number of unfinished requests is imposed.

Thank you for your responses that address my concerns. Neithertheless, notice that high pearson correlation doesn't always imply that there is a correlation (see the Anscombe quartet dataset : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anscombe%27s_quartet).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to 1st Follow-Up

We thank the reviewer for the reminder. We further inspected the actual scatter distributions and supplemented the analysis with Spearman to verify whether the correlation coefficients accurately reflect the associations in the data.


1. Inspecting scatter distributions to avoid summary coefficients obscuring actual data patterns.

GSM8K data are provided in Table B of our Response to Q2&3, points 1–2, to the 1st reviewer Kxkf. Full results, including MMLU, are provided in Appendix D.7 (page 26), Table 10 of the updated PDF.

We inspected the scatter distributions of token count against prefill time, decode time, output quality, and serving capacity. Prefill and decode times increase consistently with token count, output quality shows an overall positive trend, while serving capacity shows no consistent increasing or decreasing trend.

Conclusion: The scatter patterns agree with our reported directions and strengths of association, and we found no cases where the actual data patterns contradicted these assessments. Therefore, these correlation assessments are supported by the actual data distributions.


2. Combining Pearson and Spearman to reduce the risk of misinterpretation caused by a single correlation coefficient.

Pearson measures linear association between the original numerical values, while Spearman measures monotonic association between ranks. Using them together allows the data relationships to be cross-checked from two perspectives. Our original response already used both Pearson and Spearman to analyze serving capacity. We now additionally report Spearman for the other metrics. Calculated from the values listed in Table 10:

The correlation between token count and MMLU prefill time is Pearson Corr 0.993 and Spearman Corr 1.000. The correlations between token count and GSM8K prefill time and decode time are Pearson Corr 0.964 and Spearman Corr 1.000, and Pearson Corr 0.961 and Spearman Corr 1.000, respectively. The correlation between token count and output quality is Pearson Corr 0.877 and Spearman Corr 0.895 on MMLU, and Pearson Corr 0.786 and Spearman Corr 0.684 on GSM8K. The correlation between token count and serving capacity is Pearson Corr 0.174 and Spearman Corr 0.051 on MMLU, and Pearson Corr 0.099 and Spearman Corr 0.051 on GSM8K.

Conclusion: The values of the two coefficients are generally close, and their assessments of the directions and strengths of association are consistent: both indicate strong associations with execution times, positive associations with output quality, and weak associations with serving capacity.


Summary

To address the Anscombe issue highlighted by the reviewer that summary coefficients may obscure actual data relationships, we combined scatter distribution inspection with Pearson and Spearman cross-checks, confirming that our original assessments are correct.

Reviewer_KxkfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

LLM serving computations are increasingly being run in a streaming fashion. Gaps in the tokenization-to-prefill interface introduce are currently the cause of streaming overheads, which BridgeSTOP aims to reduce. The paper consists of three main components. BAPT, a first come first served queue shared across workers, enables workers to pull from the queue and let each request being released as soon as they finish, instead of relying on fixed batches. Next, a token pool buffers streamed tokens and passes the token to chunked prefilling once a fixed amount is reached. Third, speculative tokenization enables BridgeSTOP to submit a pool of tokens plus speculated tokens up to the pool size, and rolls back the speculated work in case of mismatch.

The evaluation runs Qwen3-8B on a RTX 5090 over 5 workloads, and shows a 1.22× higher SLO-bounded capacity and lower TTFT/TBT curves compared to the combination of the matching tokenizer and Stream2LLM.

Critical strengths
  • The end-to-end tokenizer improvement evaluation with slo-bounded capacity (instead of just tokenizer throughput) is the right evaluation lens, and the tp interface has been an underexplored part of the serving stack.
  • The evaluation setup is broad and thorough: 5 workloads, RTok and LTok, two prefill baselines, ablation without BAPT, and the Stream2LLM chunk sweep
Critical weaknesses
  • The end to end serving gains seem inconsistent with the tokenization time-scale: tokenization per-request on short workloads take approximately 0.5 to 2.5 ms according to Table 2, but the time to first token is 400ms, so it's unclear how the tokenizer choice, together with BridgeSTOP, are able to shift capacity by the stated 20-100%
  • The paper does not provide through evaluation to triangulate where the e2e gains come from.
  • According to table 5, the choice of tokenizer can significantly affect the decode times (the P99 time between tokens changes, and so does which SLO fails first). This is a counterintuitive result since tokenization should barely affect decoding times, as very few tokens need to be tokenized. The authors should evaluate whether this is expected and, if so, clearly explain why.
  • For a 8B model running on a RTX5090, the baseline capacities appear too low. Was there any GPU or CPU contention between tokenizer workers and the serving engine?
  • Speculative tokenization appears to be used for only about 5% of requests and, according to table 3, it improves QPS by only 1.5 points (70 to 71.5), but with a 39.7% rollback rate despite 89% token accuracy. Is the extra complexity justified?
Questions for authors
  • Can you break down time to first token per request into tokenization, queueing, prefill, any idle time / pool wait? The breakdown would help us evaluate whether prefills starve and how streaming tokenization translates to serving gains
  • Different tokenizers not only produce different token ids, but also different token counts, so the prefill and decode workloads will differ; in addition, capacity differences mix segmentation length with execution efficiency. Can you provide an analysis/ablation of how this affects your results?
  • I couldn't find an experiment checking the output quality, even though the unmodified Qwen3 receives non-native segmentations, resulting in potentially different output. I was surprised to see SPEAK output requiring adaptation in less than 0.1% of the tokens. How is this possible? Does SPEAK essentially exactly reproduce the Qwen3 bpe tokenizer or am I missing something? Can you provide an output quality comparison, e.g. on MMLU, GSM8K?
2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Weakness 1-5

Response to W1:

1. Different time-scale: Table 2 measures tokenization latency with batchsize=64. TTFT includes tokenization, prefill, scheduling, resource contention, and queueing delays, under configured request rate. Their different time scales are therefore expected.

2. Capacity gain: According to Kingman’s formula, near saturation, small time changes in the system can lead to disproportionately large changes in queueing delay. In our serving pipeline, BridgeSTOP improves how upstream output reaches downstream stages. These improvements can have amplified effects on downstream stages, thus largely affecting TTFT, TBT, and serving capacity.

Our results are consistent with this theory: Figures 3&4 show small latency benefits far from saturation (low request rates) and substantially larger benefits near saturation (high request rates). Capacity measures the maximum sustainable request rate near SLO saturation, so our improvements can yield substantial capacity gains.

Summary: Time-scale differences and large capacity benefits are reasonable.


Response to W2:

See response to Q1.


Response to W3:

Table 5 reports which SLOs are violated above maximum capacity. It cannot isolate tokenizer's effects on decode time.

1. Tokenizer affects decode time: Different tokenizers can produce different token sequence lengths for the same request, changing KV cache lengths after prefill. These differences can affect decode time and thus TBT, which includes decode time. Table B in our response to Q2&3 reports tokenizer's effects on decode time.

2. Tokenizer cannot dominate TBT SLO failure: Table 5 shows that changing the tokenizer mostly leaves the first violated SLO unchanged. For example, on ShareGPT4, the first violated SLO remains unchanged across tokenizers. Hence, although tokenizer choice affects decode time and TBT, it cannot dominate whether TBT SLO fails first.

3. “Very few tokens need to be tokenized”: There may be a wording mistake, since tokens do not need to be "tokenized" again. We assume the reviewer refers to “detokenized”. But the number of tokens to detokenize depends on the dataset and is not always “very few”. For example, MMLU detokenizes only 1 token, while others require hundreds or thousands of tokens.

Summary: Tokenizers can affect decode time and TBT, with little relation to TBT SLO failure.


Response to W4:

1. GPU memory limits our performance: We use a RTX 5090 32GB GPU memory, while Sarathi uses an A100 80GB GPU and Stream2LLM uses two H100 80GB GPUs. GPU memory limits concurrent requests and their KV caches. Given that our SLO settings are similar with Sarathi, such memory differences mainly contribute to lower capacities than other papers report.

Our memory constraint experiment in response to W5 point 3, confirms that reducing memory lowers capacity.

2. No OOM error ensures correctness: We observe no OOM errors, indicating no unexpected contention. All configs were evaluated correctly on the same platform.

Summary: The lower baseline capacity stems from less GPU memory, not serving errors or unexpected contention.


Response to W5:

1. Speculated requests are fewer but longer: Across five workloads, 5.2–12.0% of requests trigger speculation, but their mean input lengths are 1.16$\times$–1.82$\times$ over the dataset averages, indicating these requests are longer and engage more tokens.

Full statistics and analysis are provided in Appendix D.4 (page 24) of the updated PDF.

2. Ablation justifies the extra rollback cost: Table 3 shows that speculation reduces waiting but incurs extra rollback cost, requiring evaluation of whether the time saved surpasses this cost. The e2e serving capacity ranking “our accurate speculation > waiting > less accurate speculation” shows that our more accurate speculation still benefits capacity with consideration of rollback cost.

3. Speculation offers larger benefits under memory constraints: To test whether the benefit extends beyond the modest 1.5 QPS gain, we run MMLU with a lower GPU memory limit. We hypothesize that slower request input and reduced tokenization-side efficiency would increase the need for speculation. Longest improves capacity over Waiting by 10.9% (23->25.5) under the 20GB limit, higher than the original 2.1% (70->71.5) under 32GB limit. The speculated request ratio largely increases (5.2%->12.0%) as expected. This demonstrates a larger benefit in this memory constrained setting.

Full results and analysis are provided in Appendix D.5 (page 25) of the updated PDF.

Summary: Speculation yields capacity gains despite rollback, with larger gains under memory constraint.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Responses to Question 1-3

Response to Q1:

1. Breakdown of the serving pipeline: We compare IncreBPE with different prefill methods on GSM8K at 15 QPS and MMLU at 50 QPS, reporting detailed time-related metrics in Table A below. Results show that BridgeSTOP improves tokenization, prefill, and scheduling&queueing efficiency, lowering TTFT and TBT. BAPT further reduces tokenization latency and slightly reduces scheduling&queueing time, with little change in prefill time. Decode time changes modestly, suggesting it is not the main source of capacity gains.

2. Overlap tokenization and prefill via streaming: Stream2LLM and BridgeSTOP enable TP overlap by prefilling available tokens before tokenization finishes. BridgeSTOP’s finer streaming granularity further increases total TP overlap time, improving serving efficiency.

3. Reduce prefill starvation via speculation: Speculation replenishes tokens when exact tokens are insufficient, reducing prefill waiting as reflected by lower idle time. BAPT further improves token supply. Together, these mechanisms reduce prefill interruptions and idle waiting, improving serving capacity.

Table A: Breakdown of time-related metrics of the serving pipeline on GSM8K at 15 QPS. All values are in ms. Full results with MMLU at 50 QPS are provided in Appendix D.6 (page 25) of the updated PDF.

GSM8K: IncreBPE +SarathiStream2LLMBridgeSTOP w/o BAPTBridgeSTOP
P50 TTFT357.950302.646110.42673.860
P99 TBT185.000186.708124.18698.900
P50 tokenization latency2.4702.4592.4450.460
P50 prefill time95.60368.86239.49339.185
P50 decode time5260.6335042.5444995.0094917.763
P50 scheduling&queuing time796.327605.229300.950284.639
Total TP overlap time0.0003107.7906693.7067134.744
Total prefill idle time602.318511.573238.453186.269

Summary: BridgeSTOP improves serving capacity through faster tokenization and prefill, reduced scheduling and idle waiting, and greater TP overlap.


Response to Q2&3:

1. Analysis of token count on serving capacity: Different tokenizers produce different token counts, affecting prefill and decode times. Table B below reports these results together with prefill and decode times and serving capacity on GSM8K, with full results in Appendix D.7 (page 26) of the updated PDF. We find that token count correlates strongly with prefill and decode times (both Pearson Corr > 0.96), but weakly with capacity (Pearson Corr 0.099, Spearman Corr 0.05). Hence, token count only has limited effects on our assessment of serving capacity values and rankings, thus not affecting advantages of BridgeSTOP in capacity.

2. Analysis of output quality on serving capacity: Different token IDs can affect downstream quality, and some tokenizers trade quality for efficiency. But, the quality variations 83.1%-89.5% remain acceptable for our evaluation and thus do not change our assessment of serving capacity and latency.

Table B: Token counts, latency, capacity, and output quality on 4-shot GSM8K. Prefill and decode times use batch size 1. Full results including 5-shot MMLU are provided in Appendix D.7 (page 26) of the updated PDF.

MetricLoPTzip2zipMAGNETIncreBPESPEAK
Total tokens126665119625122422126665120294
Relative to BPE100.0%94.4%96.7%100.0%95.0%
Avg. prefill (ms)31.530.231.131.530.4
Avg. decode (ms)6658.36533.86606.46658.36582.4
Capacity (QPS) #rank8.5 #49.5 #37.5 #515.0 #114.0 #2
Output quality (%)89.583.483.189.586.9

3. Explanation of SPEAK: SPEAK does not exactly reproduce Qwen3 BPE. Only OOV tokens require adaptation. In-vocab tokens map directly to existing IDs despite different segmentation boundaries. For example, [abcd] and [ab, cd] require no adaptation if all three tokens exist in the vocab. Thus, <0.1% measures OOV frequency, not segmentation disagreement. SPEAK’s paper describes “proxy signal initialization” (page 14) using tokenizers like Unigram. We initialize SPEAK with BPE and observe that training retains many BPE boundaries, with most output tokens remaining in-vocab.

Summary: In our experiments, acceptable variations of token count and output quality from different tokenizers cannot change our assessment of reported serving capacity.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Summary for AC

We summarize the concerns raised by the three reviewers during the rebuttal to facilitate the AC’s decision.


1. Scope of the reviewers’ concerns

The three reviewers raised 9 Weaknesses and 10 Questions in total. After consolidating five Questions with the corresponding Weaknesses from the same reviewer, 9 Weaknesses and 5 Questions remain. The table counts each retained item in every category it addresses, so the row counts may overlap.

CategoryWeaknessesQuestions
Introduction / Related work0/90/5
Method0/90/5
Main experiments3/90/5
Ablation experiments2/90/5
Appendix explanation and additional experiments6/95/5

About half of the Weaknesses (5/9) and none of the Questions (0/5) concern the main text. The reviewers raised no direct concerns about the paper’s background, motivation, or core method design. The main-text concerns focus on the experiments and primarily ask for more detail on the reported results, comparison settings, and ablations. We added supplementary experiments to the appendix to address these concerns. The main serving experiments and their reported results remain unchanged.

Most Weaknesses (6/9) and all Questions (5/5) focus on appendix explanations and additional experiments. They mainly concern Stream2LLM reproduction, cross-tokenizer comparisons, serving-pipeline time breakdowns, repeated runs, and experimental configurations. We responded to them and provided more detailed explanations and the requested additional experiments in the updated appendix.

Summary: Few comments directly questioned the paper’s introduction, core method, or main experimental results. The reviewers’ concerns focused more on the experimental evaluation and mostly asked for further details or supporting experiments. We provided these in our rebuttal and updated PDF.


2. Common concerns across reviewers

The common concerns include the following 3 points.

2.1 Stream2LLM reproduction and fair comparisons

The 2nd and 3rd reviewers both asked about the baseline, i.e. Stream2LLM, reproduction and comparison settings. We clarified the serving engines used by each method, the shared prefill budget, and the retention of Stream2LLM’s original FCFS scheduling and preemption mechanisms. We adapt the input format of our static workloads to its append-mode interface without modifying these mechanisms. These clarifications and wording corrections do not change the reported serving capacity and latency results.

2.2 Cross-tokenizer comparisons and downstream quality

All three reviewers raised concerns about the effects of different tokenizers on downstream quality, with some additionally asking about token counts, execution times, and vocabulary adapters. We provided complete comparisons, explicitly reported quality differences, and aligned the thinking settings between quality evaluation and serving. The quality corrections do not change the measured serving capacity and latency, and the additional analyses support our assessment of the original serving results.

2.3 Ablation, correctness, and reproducibility of longest-match speculation

All three reviewers raised concerns about the benefits of speculation. We added Longest–Waiting comparisons across five workloads, a Direct prefill baseline, and three repeated runs, and explained the handling and costs of verification, rollback, and recomputation. The additional results further support the benefits of speculation with its additional costs included. The third reviewer has explicitly acknowledged the ablation evidence and the explanation of prompt-token equality.

Summary: These common concerns mainly request clearer reproduction details, additional control analyses, and stronger component validation. These concerns have little relation with the research motivation, core mechanisms, and main serving results. We responded them to further support the paper’s main conclusions.


3. Reviewer follow-ups

At the time of writing, approximately 16 hours remain before the rebuttal deadline.

  • Reviewer 1 (Kxkf): No response till now.
  • Reviewer 2 (FfZD): The only follow-up was a concern about the reliability of using Pearson correlation to demonstrate correlation. We inspected our data and additionally integrated Spearman coefficient for correlation validation. Both checks supported our original assessment. We have yet to receive a further response.
  • Reviewer 3 (wfpb) confirmed that the additional experiments and explanations addressed their concerns. They then asked for two issue clarifications. We responded to both and look forward to their further feedback.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.