acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

vSkipper: Translating Dynamic Layer Skipping into LLM Serving Gains

Abstract

Dynamic layer skipping reduces LLM computation by allowing each token to execute only a subset of the model's layers. However, existing skippers rely on specialized generation loops and do not integrate with modern serving engines. As a result, fewer executed layers do not necessarily translate into lower serving latency: FlexiDepth skips 8 of Llama-3-8B's 32 layers on average, yet its standard generation loop decodes 14.6-21.0% more slowly than the base model. We present vSkipper, a virtualization layer that makes dynamic layer skippers pluggable in serving engines while preserving continuous batching, fixed-shape batches, paged KV caching, and captured decode graphs. At each routed layer, vSkipper groups tokens by the skipper's decision and uses routed execution only when it is predicted to be profitable. We implement vSkipper in SGLang and evaluate the released FlexiDepth checkpoint against upstream SGLang under identical prompts, arrivals, output lengths, and launch settings. At the knee of upstream's load curve, vSkipper reduces mean end-to-end latency by 36.8% on GSM8K and 13.6% on BBH. Under saturation, it increases request throughput by 11.3% and 7.4%. Serving adds no statistically resolved quality loss beyond the checkpoint's own. Across synthetic skip policies, two Qwen3 skippers, and three GPUs, we demonstrate reuse without workload-specific tuning. To our knowledge, vSkipper is the first system to realize serving-efficiency gains from per-token interior layer skipping within a modern LLM serving engine. The code is open-sourced as an SGLang fork at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/sglang-vskipper-7BCE.

Primary area:
infrastructure, software libraries, hardware, systems, etc.
Keywords:
LLM serving, dynamic layer skipping, continuous batching, KV cache

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_qN7ZOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how to translate computational savings from per-token dynamic layer skipping into practical performance gains in modern LLM serving systems. The authors implement vSkipper in SGLang, separating skipping policies from execution mechanisms. It executes dynamic layer skipping through a RUN/Project-Only interface, CUDA Graph-compatible GPU-side cohort execution, and profitability-aware selection between dense and routed modes, while retaining continuous batching, paged KV caching, and graph optimizations.

The main experiments use a Llama-3-8B FlexiDepth checkpoint on a single A100, covering GSM8K, BBH, and CoQA. They evaluate end-to-end performance with matched output lengths, saturated throughput, task quality, and mechanism ablations. Additional generality experiments use synthetic skipping policies, two Qwen3 skippers, and H100 and RTX A6000 GPUs.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses a practically relevant systems problem: reducing FLOPs through dynamic layer skipping does not necessarily improve serving performance. The authors integrate token-dependent execution paths with continuous batching, paged KV caching, and CUDA Graphs. With matched output lengths, mean end-to-end latency near the load knee decreases by 36.8% on GSM8K and 13.6% on BBH, while saturated request throughput increases by 11.3% and 7.4%, respectively.

  2. The experimental design carefully separates execution efficiency from model behavior. The authors control each request's output length, report natural-stopping results separately, and use a four-way comparison of base model versus skipping checkpoint and native versus serving execution to distinguish the checkpoint's quality changes from additional changes introduced by serving. This helps clarify the scope of the performance and quality conclusions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The incremental benefits of the core execution design have not been isolated. Table 3 and Appendix H primarily ablate prefill/decode routing and mode switching, without directly quantifying the benefits of the cohort execution and CUDA Graph-compatible execution design in Section 3.1 over a simpler layer-skipping implementation. It is therefore difficult to identify which execution mechanisms are critical to the speedup.

  2. Evidence for joint quality–latency benefits under natural stopping remains limited. Table 11 reports knee-point latency increases from 22.4 s to 38.2 s on GSM8K and from 21.9 s to 31.9 s on BBH. Tables 17–18 provide encouraging results for a Qwen3-8B checkpoint with an accuracy point estimate close to the base model and lower matched-work latency. However, the quality and natural-stopping evaluations use different generation limits, leaving the joint trade-off under a common protocol unclear. This limits the demonstrated deployment benefit without invalidating the execution speedups under matched workloads.

Questions for authors
  1. Regarding Weakness 1: With the same checkpoint, skipping decisions, and output workload, how much overhead do cohort execution and CUDA Graph-compatible execution each remove relative to a simpler layer-skipping implementation?

  2. Regarding Weakness 2: For the Qwen3-8B checkpoint at step 18.75k in Tables 17–18, could you compare task quality and end-to-end latency with the base model under the same natural-stopping protocol and output limits? This would clarify whether its matched-work gain translates into a deployment gain at comparable quality.

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 1: Cohort execution and CUDA Graph capture

We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing that our work addresses a “practically relevant systems problem” and that our experimental design “carefully separates execution efficiency from model behavior”.

Regarding Weakness 1: With the same checkpoint, skipping decisions, and output workload, how much overhead do cohort execution and CUDA Graph-compatible execution each remove relative to a simpler layer-skipping implementation?

We isolate grouping and graph capture using the same checkpoint, router and output workload:

Packed cohorts group rows by route and execute selected branches. vSkipper’s default is hybrid: packed cohorts, decode CUDA graphs and cost-based dense/routed switching.

Always-route keeps the same cohorts and decode graphs, disabling only switching.

Full-width computes both MLP and projector on every row before selecting by route.

Simple reads every row’s KV, masks attention output and gathers rows per layer, without packing or decode CUDA graphs.

Capture refers to decode CUDA graphs. No-capture keeps cohorts but disables decode CUDA graphs. Both simple and no-capture use dense prefill and always-route decode.

Decode steps. Fixed batch, context, checkpoint, router and output length. Three repetitions. Times in ms. Rows = batch tokens, context = prompt tokens per request. The full-width and captured-cohort columns use always-route decode.

rows × contextUpstreamUpstream, no captureSimpleCohorts, no captureFull-width, capturedCohorts, captured
32 × 1k15.4917.4529.5232.8617.5517.65
128 × 1k27.9828.6540.2733.1228.8229.44
256 × 1k48.1748.5657.4947.8946.1547.06
64 × 4k35.8536.3549.2635.0333.9334.19

The decode microbenchmarks show that performance depends on batch size and context length. Captured cohorts substantially outperform the simple implementation, while their per-step latency is comparable to full-width execution in the tested configurations (e.g., 17.65 vs. 17.55 ms at 32 × 1k, and 47.06 vs. 46.15 ms at 256 × 1k).

The end-to-end results show the benefit of packed execution over the full-width implementation across the complete serving workload. Under matched output lengths, the hybrid configuration improves latency by 12.4–39.2% on GSM8K and 3.6–14.5% on BBH.

Matched-work serving: equal output lengths per request, three repetitions, with 95% t-intervals. All values are percentage changes relative to the reference specified for each table. Negative latency changes indicate faster execution. Latency columns show mean end-to-end latency at the stated arrival rates. Throughput is measured over the arrival window at 1.25×Q∗. Q∗ follows the shared setup.

Table 1. Cohorts versus full-width execution.

Each row compares cohorts with full-width execution using the same router, mode and decode graphs.

ConfigurationDatasetLatency at 0.75×Q∗Latency at 0.95×Q∗Latency at 1.25×Q∗Output tokens/secondCompleted requests/second
HybridGSM8K−12.4±1.1−39.2±3.0−32.6±2.6+13.1±0.6+13.8±0.7
HybridBBH−3.6±1.1−14.5±7.2−9.0±1.1+4.7±2.0+4.4±2.2
Always-routeGSM8K−20.1±0.8−53.8±1.1−32.9±1.2+13.2±0.5+14.0±0.4
Always-routeBBH−3.2±1.7−13.0±6.0−7.9±2.1+4.0±2.0+4.7±2.3

Table 2. Uncaptured configurations versus upstream SGLang without decode graphs.

Both configurations use dense prefill and always-route decode. No-capture retains cohorts. Simple does not use cohort packing.

ConfigurationDatasetLatency at 0.75×Q∗Latency at 0.95×Q∗Latency at 1.25×Q∗Output tokens/secondCompleted requests/second
SimpleGSM8K+76.3±2.7+35.1±1.8+3.2±2.0−1.3±0.5−1.1±0.5
SimpleBBH+13.1±1.7+1.8±2.0−1.1±2.2+2.1±0.4+3.6±1.3
No-captureGSM8K+38.7±3.9+3.4±0.5−6.2±1.3+2.1±0.6+2.4±0.7
No-captureBBH−4.0±6.4−10.3±15.5−11.3±2.0+6.4±4.1+8.5±4.7

On GSM8K, simple increases mean end-to-end latency by 76.3% and 35.1% at 0.75×Q∗ and 0.95×Q∗, compared with upstream SGLang without decode graphs. With the same reference, no-capture cohorts reduce these increases to 38.7% and 3.4%, and reduce latency by 6.2% at 1.25×Q∗. On BBH, no-capture reduces latency by 4.0%, 10.3% and 11.3% across the three rates, showing a workload-dependent effect. Overall, the ablations highlight the complementary roles of packed execution and graph capture in the end-to-end serving pipeline.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 2: Natural stopping and output quality

Regarding Weakness 2: For the Qwen3-8B checkpoint at step 18.75k in Tables 17–18, could you compare task quality and end-to-end latency with the base model under the same natural-stopping protocol and output limits? This would clarify whether its matched-work gain translates into a deployment gain at comparable quality.

We evaluate the base model and vSkipper on GSM8K with identical arrivals, 8,192-token limits and natural stopping. Task quality is measured in the same runs as latency. Results use three repetitions with 95% t-intervals. Latency changes are percentages relative to upstream SGLang. Quality changes are percentage-point differences.

Step 18.75k, the checkpoint evaluated in Tables 17–18:

rateUpstream latency (s)Hybrid latency change (%)Hybrid quality change (percentage points)Always-route latency change (%)Always-route quality change (percentage points)
0.75×Q∗7.07+0.6 ± 0.5%+0.03 ± 1.86+17.0 ± 13.9%-5.10 ± 0.95
0.95×Q∗23.11-1.8 ± 2.2%-0.86 ± 1.23-20.4 ± 6.4%-5.94 ± 1.04
1.25×Q∗67.46-0.8 ± 1.2%-1.16 ± 1.20-17.6 ± 1.4%-4.65 ± 2.28

Step 15k, the checkpoint in the paper's cross-model table, using the same protocol:

rateUpstream latency (s)Hybrid latency change (%)Hybrid quality change (percentage points)Always-route latency change (%)Always-route quality change (percentage points)
0.75×Q∗7.60-7.3 ± 4.8%+0.03 ± 0.47+10.8 ± 22.7%-12.66 ± 1.54
0.95×Q∗22.75-3.7 ± 4.9%-5.26 ± 2.56-26.3 ± 2.5%-13.72 ± 0.19
1.25×Q∗67.54-2.8 ± 0.5%-3.49 ± 0.19-23.7 ± 1.3%-12.51 ± 0.19

Mean output tokens per answer on GSM8K. Ranges span the three load means. The 15k hybrid values are listed in rate order: 0.75, 0.95 and 1.25 × Q∗.

checkpointUpstreamHybridAlways-route
Qwen3-8B 15k152–154150/159/159150–153
Qwen3-8B 18.75k152–153151–154141–148

For the 18.75k hybrid, mean end-to-end latency changes are +0.6 ± 0.5%, −1.8 ± 2.2% and −0.8 ± 1.2% across the three rates, with quality changes within the reported uncertainty. At 1.25 × Q∗, p99 latency improves by 3.2 ± 1.1%. The 15k hybrid reduces mean latency by 7.3 ± 4.8% at 0.75 × Q∗, with a quality change of +0.03 ± 0.47 percentage points. At the two higher rates, its quality decreases by 5.26 ± 2.56 and 3.49 ± 0.19 percentage points.

The 18.75k hybrid stays close to the base model’s mean output length. At the two higher loads, the 15k hybrid generates less than 5% more tokens and has about five additional output-limit hits per 3,600-request run (an increase of 0.13–0.15 pp). These results complement the matched-work evaluation by measuring quality and latency together under natural stopping.

We also measure output lengths with D³ and evaluate repetition penalty as a way to control generation length, with a quality trade-off. DAyT Posts 1–2 give these results and further analysis of natural stopping.

Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The ablations in Post 1 largely address my concern about the execution mechanisms, and the joint evaluation in Post 2 directly addresses my request for a common natural-stopping protocol. I also appreciate the low-load benefit of the 15k hybrid and the p99 improvement of the 18.75k hybrid.

One remaining concern is that the demonstrated deployment gains at comparable quality are modest and load-dependent. The 18.75k hybrid shows little improvement in mean latency, while the larger always-route speedups at higher loads come with quality loss. This leaves uncertainty about how broadly the matched-work gains translate into practical benefits at comparable quality. Please incorporate the new results and clarify this limitation in the revised paper.

I also see the scale of the evaluated deployments as a limitation. The H100 and RTX A6000 experiments provide useful evidence of hardware transfer, but the serving evaluation remains confined to single-GPU deployments. I acknowledge that distributed serving is listed as future work; performance and scalability under multi-GPU serving therefore remain unestablished, limiting the demonstrated deployment scope.

Reviewer_DAyTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents vSkipper, a serving framework that integrates FlexiDepth layer skipping into SGLang. It introduces graph-compatible token routing, cohort-based execution, and profitability-aware switching to translate computational savings into actual serving speedups. Experiments show that vSkipper maintains the quality of FlexiDepth, has e2e speedup and could work for different models / GPUs.

Critical strengths
  1. The system design is technically interesting, particularly its compatibility with CUDA Graphs, continuous batching, and KV caching
  2. The evaluation is relatively thorough, with controlled experiments, ablations, and results across multiple GPUs and model sizes
Critical weaknesses
  1. The implementation appears heavily tailored to FlexiDepth. The evaluation does not include independently developed layer-skipping methods, making it unclear whether the proposed framework can generalize (RandomSkip is just naive baseline)
  2. In Appendix G, FlexiDepth has 3x tokens in decoding compared to vanilla model, which means this can't achieve the goal of speed up. Although this may be a limitation of the underlying FlexiDepth checkpoint, it raises concerns about whether the reported matched-work speedups translate into actual serving speed benefits
Questions for authors

Please check the weaknesses.

6 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 1: Independent D³ policy integration and serving performance

Thank you for the careful review and thoughtful feedback. We address your concerns below.

“The implementation appears heavily tailored to FlexiDepth. The evaluation does not include independently developed layer-skipping methods, making it unclear whether the proposed framework can generalize”

We demonstrate generality by integrating D³ [1], an independently developed, training-free layer-skipping policy, with about 130 lines of policy code and 70 supporting lines. The integration reuses vSKIPPER’s executor and K/V paths as vSKIPPER separates which layers to execute from how the resulting rows are served. A policy supplies per-row decisions: RUN executes the layer, while Project-Only follows the projection path without full attention and MLP computation. Static-depth and RandomSkip are simple examples of this interface. D³ provides an independently developed policy. For D³, we follow its original reported evaluation settings: three-shot lm-eval, no chain-of-thought, and output limits of 200 tokens for BBH and 1,024 for GSM8K. The Llama-2 settings reproduce the layer counts reported by D³. For Llama-3, we select fixed PyTorch settings before serving, targeting the maximum skipping level within the released FlexiDepth checkpoint’s native quality loss.

Table 1. Natural-stopping accuracy.

Upstream = base-model SGLang. Hybrid = default with switching, cohorts and decode graphs. Always-route disables switching. Gaps (pp versus base) use unrounded scores. Upstream/Always-route ranges span 0.75/0.95/1.25×Q∗ means (n=3 each). Hybrid: 0.95×Q∗ only, n=3, paired 95% t-intervals. BBH scoring removes one leading space in both systems.

D³ decay/start by row: 0.9/0.6, 0.9/0.2, 0.9999/0.2, 0.9999/0.8. Start = starting-layer fraction.

Model/taskOur PyTorch base/D³ (%)PyTorch gapUpstream (%)Always-route (%)Always-route gapHybrid (%)Hybrid gap
Llama-2-7B/BBH32.74/31.14−1.5932.73–32.7731.15–31.18−1.63 to −1.5532.75−0.02±0.04
Llama-3-8B/BBH46.37/41.55−4.8346.35–46.3641.51–41.59−4.84 to −4.7746.34−0.01±0.03
Llama-2-7B/GSM8K13.12/10.61−2.5013.34–13.4710.36–10.44−3.06 to −2.9113.44+0.10±0.22
Llama-3-8B/GSM8K75.74/72.71−3.0375.82–76.0273.24–73.29−2.73 to −2.5875.66−0.15±0.19

Table 2. Mean answer tokens and generation-limit hits.

Loads as Table 1. PyTorch counts tokens retained after lm-eval stops, serving counts generated tokens.

Model/taskOur PyTorch base/D³UpstreamAlways-routeHybridLimit hits: Upstream/Always-route
Llama-2-7B/BBH4.6/10.16.612.06.643/249
Llama-3-8B/BBH4.2/10.24.5–4.610.1–10.24.533–34/172–179
Llama-2-7B/GSM8K241.3/271.9243.9–246.0273.2–274.2243.6192–196/232–234
Llama-3-8B/GSM8K97.6/98.299.7–99.898.2–99.499.72/4–6

The always-route results are within 0.6 percentage points of the corresponding PyTorch D³ quality gaps, demonstrating that the integration preserves the policy’s behavior. At the tested natural-stopping load, hybrid selects dense execution for all four model/task pairs. Always-route exercises the routed D³ path.

Table 3. Fixed-output performance versus upstream SGLang.

Changes: %, n=3 paired, 95% t-intervals. E2E = mean end-to-end latency. Throughput: arrival window at 1.25×Q∗. All systems generate 200/1,024 BBH/GSM8K tokens (ignore_eos). Q∗: calibrated reference, not fixed-output capacity: 19/37/2/5 requests/s in Table 1 row order.

Model/taskModeE2E: 0.75×Q∗E2E: 0.95×Q∗E2E: 1.25×Q∗TPSRPS
Llama-2-7B/BBHHybrid−68.8±1.4−72.2±1.7−61.4±2.2+35.2±2.4+37.3±5.0
Llama-2-7B/BBHAlways-route−69.6±1.2−73.2±1.1−61.8±1.1+35.6±2.0+37.8±3.7
Llama-3-8B/BBHHybrid−47.7±0.7−70.0±1.3−72.0±6.5+40.8±9.3+84.9±7.1
Llama-3-8B/BBHAlways-route−52.6±1.6−71.0±2.7−75.5±3.8+43.3±11.1+91.8±11.4
Llama-2-7B/GSM8KHybrid−15.6±2.1−6.0±0.4−5.9±0.6+3.2±0.9+2.3±4.3
Llama-2-7B/GSM8KAlways-route−16.6±1.0−6.9±1.5−5.5±1.2+3.0±1.0+3.8±4.6
Llama-3-8B/GSM8KHybrid+1.7±0.2−1.3±0.5−4.2±0.1+0.5±0.2+2.3±1.3
Llama-3-8B/GSM8KAlways-route−0.4±0.2−2.3±0.2−2.4±3.5+0.5±0.3+2.1±0.2

For matched-work serving, we use these fixed output lengths to match the average executed layer counts reported by D³ for Llama-2-7B. The fixed-output results show substantial end-to-end improvements on BBH (47.7–75.5%). For Llama-2-7B, D³ [1] reports 1.64× FLOPs reduction on BBH (Table 6), and 1.12× wall-clock speedup over Hugging Face on GSM8K (Table 7). For Llama-2 BBH, upstream SGLang is already near capacity at 0.75 × Q∗ (approximately 97%) and exceeds capacity at higher rates. vSKIPPER correspondingly improves completion time. Llama-3 BBH shows a similar trend, while GSM8K skips fewer layers and achieves smaller gains. These results show that vSKIPPER serves an independent skipping policy, with gains depending on skip rate and workload.

[1] Fan et al. Position-Aware Depth Decay Decoding (D³). Findings of ACL 2025.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 2: Natural stopping and output quality

"In Appendix G, FlexiDepth has 3x tokens in decoding compared to vanilla model, which means this can't achieve the goal of speed up. Although this may be a limitation of the underlying FlexiDepth checkpoint, it raises concerns about whether the reported matched-work speedups translate into actual serving speed benefits"

Matched-work experiments isolate execution efficiency by giving both systems the same output length. Natural-stopping performance additionally depends on generation length and output quality, so we evaluate these metrics separately. This is also standard performance benchmarking practice in SGLang [1] and vLLM Spyre [2].

In the original Llama-3-8B GSM8K experiment at 0.95 × Q∗, FlexiDepth generates substantially longer outputs than the base model, contributing to higher end-to-end latency. The repetition experiment in Appendix G.1 using the released FlexiDepth authors' native PyTorch implementation also observes repeated generations (2.2% of sampled outputs, compared with none for the base model), indicating that this behavior is not specific to vSKIPPER's serving implementation.

Mean output tokens/answer. Slashes follow 0.75/0.95/1.25×Q∗. Ranges span those loads.

FlexiDepth checkpointTaskUpstreamHybrid (vSkipper)Always-route
Llama-3-8BGSM8K116/116/116126/330/271297–302
Llama-3-8BBBH255–262394–405408–420
Llama-3-8BCoQA164–166125–16183–86
Qwen3-8B 15kGSM8K152–154150/159/159150–153
Qwen3-8B 18.75kGSM8K152–153151–154141–148

We additionally evaluate Qwen3-8B under natural stopping with three repetitions, using identical arrivals and an 8,192-token budget, with quality measured in the same runs as latency. For the 18.75k checkpoint, mean end-to-end latency changes are +0.6 ± 0.5%, −1.8 ± 2.2%, and −0.8 ± 1.2% at 0.75, 0.95, and 1.25 × Q∗, respectively. The corresponding quality changes are within the reported uncertainty. At 1.25 × Q∗, p99 end-to-end latency improves by 3.2 ± 1.1%.

Qwen3 quality and latency compared with upstream SGLang. Rates are multiples of Q∗. Quality gaps are in percentage points (pp). Intervals are 95% t-intervals.

Checkpoint train StepRateUpstream E2E sHybrid E2E gap %Hybrid quality gap ppAlways-route E2E gap %Always-route quality gap pp
15k0.757.60−7.3±4.8+0.03±0.47+10.8±22.7−12.66±1.54
15k0.9522.75−3.7±4.9−5.26±2.56−26.3±2.5−13.72±0.19
15k1.2567.54−2.8±0.5−3.49±0.19−23.7±1.3−12.51±0.19
18.75k0.757.07+0.6±0.5+0.03±1.86+17.0±13.9−5.10±0.95
18.75k0.9523.11−1.8±2.2−0.86±1.23−20.4±6.4−5.94±1.04
18.75k1.2567.46−0.8±1.2−1.16±1.20−17.6±1.4−4.65±2.28

The 15k checkpoint shows a different trade-off: at 0.75 × Q∗, mean end-to-end latency decreases by 7.3 ± 4.8%, while quality remains within the reported uncertainty. At higher rates, quality drops by approximately 3.5–5.3 percentage points. The 18.75k checkpoint in hybrid mode keeps mean output length within 1.5% of the base model across tested rates, whereas the 15k checkpoint generates approximately 4.6% more tokens at the two higher rates and reaches the output limit more often. Our native PyTorch D³ runs also roughly double output length on BBH.

The repetition-penalty results on the main FlexiDepth Llama checkpoint further illustrate the interaction between generation behavior, quality, and latency: some higher-load settings improve latency or TPOT alongside quality reductions, while both GSM8K and BBH are slower at 0.75 × Q∗. Repetition penalty is 1.15 on both systems. vSkipper uses hybrid. We report six repetitions with 95% t-intervals and changes relative to upstream with the same penalty. TPS and RPS are measured over the arrival window of 1.25 Q* rate excluding drain, same as the paper definition. Together, these results show why matched-work execution efficiency and natural-stopping deployment performance are complementary metrics, and why checkpoint and workload characteristics matter.

TaskRate / Q∗Mean E2E changeTPOT changeTPSRPSQuality: upstream → vSkipper
GSM8K0.75+4.4±3.3%−1.5±2.4%75.97% → 73.58%
GSM8K0.95−1.0±1.8%−16.1±0.9%75.50% → 67.39%
GSM8K1.25−2.7±0.7%−17.0±0.6%+20.2±0.8%+1.18±0.16%75.60% → 67.59%
BBH0.75+8.9±5.2%+0.7±1.4%57.50% → 49.59%
BBH0.95−6.4±3.0%−6.5±0.4%56.75% → 48.53%
BBH1.25−6.3±2.3%−7.0±1.0%+3.74±0.52%+7.67±0.68%56.53% → 48.81%

[1] SGLang Team. Achieving Faster Open-Source Llama3 Serving with SGLang Runtime (vs. TensorRT-LLM, vLLM). 2024.

[2] SenDNN Inference Plugin (vLLM Spyre). Benchmarking and Performance.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 3: Improving FlexiDepth Natural-Stopping Performance with GRPO

In addition to the natural-stopping results discussed above, we explored a further way to reduce repetition and over-generation in the released FlexiDepth checkpoint. The paper focuses on serving pluggable layer-skipping checkpoints and uses matched work to separate serving efficiency from model-dependent generation behavior. Improving the checkpoint or skipping algorithm itself was outside our original scope. Our earlier repetition-penalty and Qwen experiments showed positive natural-stopping results without training, with different quality–performance trade-offs. In response to both reviewers' interest in further end-to-end deployment evidence, we now explore GRPO post-training of the released FlexiDepth checkpoint to reduce repetition and over-generation, as supplementary evidence for Appendix G.

We used GRPO to post-train the router and projector of the released FlexiDepth checkpoint on GSM8K, keeping the backbone frozen. The reward encourages correct answers and skipping while penalizing repetition and excessive length. A separate loss discourages reduced skipping. Training took 108 iterations on four A100-40GB GPUs, with 500 held-out training-split questions for development.

We evaluated natural stopping on A100-80GB GPUs using three repetitions of 3,600 requests. Quality is measured using marker-composite accuracy on the 1,319 GSM8K test questions. The remaining requests provide load and were excluded from training. Performance changes are relative to upstream and reported as paired means ± 95% t intervals. TPS and RPS use the arrival window at 1.25×Q∗, as in the paper.

Rate/Q∗Mean E2E (%)p99 E2E (%)Mean TTFT (%)p99 TTFT (%)Mean TPOT (%)p99 TPOT (%)TPS (%)RPS (%)
0.75+3.0±3.2−1.9±5.2−5.8±5.4−2.3±32.4−3.0±2.0−4.3±3.6——
0.95−12.5±3.8−12.6±3.8−29.0±10.7−43.6±30.1−15.5±1.7−12.9±1.6——
1.25−20.0±1.3−16.2±2.7−29.4±2.0−31.2±1.7−9.8±0.5−10.0±0.6+11.5±0.8+8.0±0.8

Quality and mean output tokens below are reported in the order upstream / released FlexiDepth / GRPO. Mean output tokens cover all 3,600 requests.

Rate/Q∗Quality (%) [Upstream / FlexiDepth / GRPO]Mean output tokens [Upstream / FlexiDepth / GRPO]
0.7577.84 / 77.63 / 77.38116.5 / 125.3 / 124.2
0.9577.86 / 74.80 / 76.98117.2 / 302.9 / 125.0
1.2577.84 / 74.83 / 74.85117.2 / 271.6 / 134.5

At 0.95×Q∗, the released checkpoint generates 302.9 tokens on average versus 117.2 for upstream, while the GRPO-tuned checkpoint reduces this to 125.0 tokens. At 1.25×Q∗, the corresponding lengths are 271.6, 117.2 and 134.5 tokens. Thus, the excess over upstream falls from 185.7 to 7.8 tokens and from 154.4 to 17.3 tokens, respectively. The GRPO-tuned checkpoint achieves comparable or higher quality than the released FlexiDepth checkpoint at these two loads (76.98% vs. 74.80%, and 74.85% vs. 74.83%). These results show that checkpoint improvements can translate into natural-stopping performance gains while retaining vSkipper's pluggable serving design. Also, this is a proof of concept developed with limited data and training time. We believe that further post-training and tuning, or alternative approaches such as pluggable LoRA adapters, could improve the quality–performance trade-off on GSM8K and potentially extend these gains to other datasets.

Together with the D³ integration in our earlier response, does this address your remaining concerns about support beyond FlexiDepth and over-generation under natural stopping? We welcome any further questions or feedback. We will incorporate these results into the revised manuscript and release the accompanying code and data.

Reviewer_TQABOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents vSKIPPER, a serving virtualization layer that integrates per-token interior layer skipping into modern LLM serving engines (specifically SGLang) while preserving key systems optimizations such as continuous batching, paged KV caching, fixed-shape captured decode graphs, and prefix reuse. The core contributions are a reusable RUN/Project-Only skipper interface, a route-guided cohort execution mechanism that supports mixed-depth execution within captured graphs, and a profitability-aware mode switch derived from a roofline model to decide when to route. Under controlled, matched-work experiments across three workloads, multiple skippers/models, and three GPUs, vSKIPPER converts FLOP savings from layer skipping into consistent serving gains (e.g., up to 36.8% lower mean E2E latency at the knee on GSM8K and 13.6% on BBH, with increased saturated throughput and no serving-induced quality loss beyond the checkpoint’s own trade-off).

Critical strengths

Technical novelty and innovation

  • Introduces a clean, pluggable RUN/Project-Only skipper interface that decouples policy from execution while maintaining engine invariants.
  • Clearly articulated correctness invariants: every layer writes its own KV and all row-dependent maps are recomputed on-device per step, addressing common pitfalls in dynamic-depth serving.
  • Profitability-aware mode switching grounded in a roofline-inspired model with device- and model-aware constants; provides generalizable thresholds and hysteresis that demonstrably prevent regressions in low-skip regimes.

Experimental rigor and validation

  • Statistical reporting with paired-difference means and t-based 95% intervals; repeated trials (typically n=6) for main cells and transparent n for ablations.
  • A 2×2 difference-in-differences design isolates serving effects from checkpoint-induced quality changes; serving adds no statistically resolved quality loss.
  • Evaluations span varied workloads (GSM8K, BBH, CoQA), hardware (A100/H100/RTX A6000), and policies (FlexiDepth, Qwen3 skippers, and synthetic RandomSkip), demonstrating broad applicability.

Significance of contributions

  • Provides a general, reusable abstraction that other skippers and models can adopt without rearchitecting schedulers or KV managers.
  • Demonstrates that the widely observed disconnect between FLOP savings and serving performance can be overcome in practice with principled systems design.
Critical weaknesses

Experimental gaps or methodological issues

  • Some mechanism ablations use n=1, which limits statistical confidence for those components.
  • The evaluation focuses on single-GPU throughput/latency; there is no exploration of interactions with speculative decoding, continuous batching variants, or other popular optimizations (e.g., FlashAttention variants beyond Triton attention).

Clarity or presentation issues

  • The Project-Only semantics are described succinctly; a more explicit mapping from skipper semantics (e.g., FlexiDepth) to the Project-Only path could help readers verify equivalence, especially regarding attention outputs and adapter mixing.
  • Kernel-level details are mostly delegated to appendices; a brief complexity and overhead breakdown (router evaluation, route tape construction, cohort maps) in the main text would clarify where the fixed per-step cost τ\tau originates.

Missing related work or comparisons

  • Early-exit serving systems (DREX, Apparate) are discussed, but a deeper comparison of design trade-offs (e.g., KV semantics, captured-graph compatibility) would contextualize vSKIPPER’s advantages for interior layer skipping.
  • Recent practical systems for dynamic compute (e.g., budget-driven depth routing or informed routing) are cited in spirit via related categories, but a more explicit comparison in serving feasibility and wall-clock impact at scale would benefit readers.
Questions for authors
  1. Can you provide a quantitative breakdown of routed mode’s fixed per-step cost (e.g., route tape build, cohort mapping, conditional graph nodes, extra kernel launches), and how this cost scales with batch size and number of routed layers?
  2. How sensitive are the profitability thresholds to skewed skip distributions (e.g., many tokens skip in only a few layers or vice versa)? Have you considered estimating an effective s weighted by live KV context to improve threshold accuracy?
  3. For Project-Only rows, attention reads are masked but own-layer KV is still written. Could you clarify how precisely this matches FlexiDepth’s training semantics (e.g., is “emit zero” for attention output faithful across all adapter/router variants)?
  4. How does vSKIPPER interact with speculative decoding or chunked prefills (e.g., Sarathi/Sarathi-Serve), given the separate prefill vs decode switching regimes? Any pitfalls or preliminary results?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 1: Mechanism and overhead

We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing our “clean, pluggable RUN/Project-Only skipper interface” and “correctness invariants”. We appreciate the detailed writing suggestions and thoughtful questions on context-weighted thresholds and speculative decoding. These comments motivate further exploration. We also extended vSkipper to support distributed serving and present the results below.

W1: "Some mechanism ablations use n=1, which limits statistical confidence for those components."

The main matched-work results use six paired repetitions, and the component ablations below use three paired repetitions. We additionally provide kernel-level profiling and skip-distribution measurements to characterize the execution overhead and routing behavior.

Mean end-to-end latency and arrival-window throughput changes (%), with 95% t-intervals. TPS and RPS are measured at 1.25×Q∗ on the arrival window excluding drain.

ComparisonDatasetE2E 0.75×Q∗E2E 0.95×Q∗E2E 1.25×Q∗TPSRPS
Hybrid cohorts vs full-widthGSM8K−12.4±1.1−39.2±3.0−32.6±2.6+13.1±0.6+13.8±0.7
Hybrid cohorts vs full-widthBBH−3.6±1.1−14.5±7.2−9.0±1.1+4.7±2.0+4.4±2.2
Always-route cohorts vs full-widthGSM8K−20.1±0.8−53.8±1.1−32.9±1.2+13.2±0.5+14.0±0.4
Always-route cohorts vs full-widthBBH−3.2±1.7−13.0±6.0−7.9±2.1+4.0±2.0+4.7±2.3
Simple vs upstream, no captureGSM8K+76.3±2.7+35.1±1.8+3.2±2.0−1.3±0.5−1.1±0.5
Simple vs upstream, no captureBBH+13.1±1.7+1.8±2.0−1.1±2.2+2.1±0.4+3.6±1.3
Cohorts vs upstream, no captureGSM8K+38.7±3.9+3.4±0.5−6.2±1.3+2.1±0.6+2.4±0.7
Cohorts vs upstream, no captureBBH−4.0±6.4−10.3±15.5−11.3±2.0+6.4±4.1+8.5±4.7

The ablations compare cohorts with full-width execution in hybrid and always-route modes, and compare simple and uncaptured-cohort execution with upstream SGLang without decode graphs. Packed cohorts improve end-to-end latency over full-width execution across the reported GSM8K and BBH settings, while the simple implementation incurs substantial overhead in several configurations. Without graph capture, cohorts reduce GSM8K latency relative to the simple implementation at all three loads.

W4: "Kernel-level details are mostly delegated to appendices; a brief complexity and overhead breakdown (router evaluation, route tape construction, cohort maps) in the main text would clarify where the fixed per-step cost τ\tau originates."

Q1: "Can you provide a quantitative breakdown of routed mode’s fixed per-step cost (e.g., route tape build, cohort mapping, conditional graph nodes, extra kernel launches), and how this cost scales with batch size and number of routed layers?"

The roofline model uses a measured aggregate fixed routed cost of 2.67 ms for A100 with 16 routed layers. The timing measurements below use the same router and three repetitions, with spread at most 0.13 ms. Context is prompt tokens per request.

Rows × context tokens/rowUpstream SGLang (ms)Cohorts, 16 routed layers (ms)Difference (ms)
32 x 1k15.4917.65+2.16
64 x 1k18.9921.01+2.02
128 x 1k27.9829.44+1.46
256 x 1k48.1747.06-1.11
32 x 4k25.6125.73+0.12
64 x 4k35.8534.19-1.66
512 x 51269.4164.97-4.44
768 x 25684.3578.12-6.23
1,024 x 128106.0497.75-8.29

We profile 128 rows with 1,024 context tokens per row over 40 decode steps, one run per configuration. All times are milliseconds, and launch counts are per step.

ConfigurationDecode step (ms)All kernels (ms)Launches per stepAttention (ms)Matrix multiplication (ms)Framework / routing (ms)
Upstream SGLang27.9827.3237311.9714.190.26
Cohorts, 16 routed layers29.4428.659429.8216.201.86
Cohorts, 8 routed layers27.9227.0173210.1414.851.22
Cohorts, 4 routed layers28.4127.6262811.2114.650.92
Cohorts, 16 routed layers, no capture33.1228.358399.8415.891.82

In the 128-row, 1k-context profile, routing reduces attention time by 2.15 ms, while GEMM and framework/route work add 2.01 ms and 1.60 ms, respectively. The profile also shows the increase in kernel launches, which scales with the number of routed layers. CUDA Graph capture reduces host launch overhead, while the aggregate routed overhead is increasingly amortized at larger batch and context sizes. We will incorporate this breakdown and scaling behavior into §3.3.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 2: Chunked prefill and serving compatibility

Q4: "How does vSKIPPER interact with speculative decoding or chunked prefills (e.g., Sarathi/Sarathi-Serve), given the separate prefill vs decode switching regimes? Any pitfalls or preliminary results?"

We evaluate chunked prefills with 8,192-, 2,048- and 1,024-token chunks, using the same chunk size for upstream SGLang and vSkipper. These GSM8K/FlexiDepth Llama-3-8B measurements use three repetitions, with matched work as in the main paper. The mode is selected using whole prompts per admission round and remains fixed across chunks.

Performance gap from upstream to vSkipper under different chunk size

Chunk tokensArrival rate / Q∗Mean E2E (s)Mean E2E(%)P99 E2E (%)Mean TTFT(%)Mean TPOT(%)
8,1920.755.69 to 5.45-4.2±1.4-5.5±3.3-5.9±2.2-4.4±1.6
8,1920.9517.84 to 14.94-16.2±6.1-17.6±6.5-14.6±8.9-16.8±6.4
8,1921.2558.74 to 43.49-26.0±2.0-19.8±1.7-46.8±4.0-10.1±0.7
2,0480.755.75 to 5.61-2.5±0.4-4.0±3.1-4.2±2.4-2.6±0.6
2,0480.9519.46 to 17.36-10.8±3.4-11.1±5.3-8.9±7.1-11.0±3.2
2,0481.2562.86 to 53.53-14.8±0.3-12.5±0.7-25.4±0.6-6.0±0.1
1,0240.756.21 to 6.32+1.6±0.3+2.8±1.6+0.6±1.0+1.7±0.3
1,0240.9531.01 to 27.57-11.1±2.6-12.1±4.3-41.4±2.2-10.0±2.7
1,0241.2573.79 to 69.72-5.5±0.2-4.8±0.7-7.9±0.3-3.0±0.1

Throughput changes at 1.25×Q∗, measured over the arrival window with three repetitions:

Chunk tokensOutput tokens/second (%)Completed requests/second (%)
8,192+9.2±0.5+10.3±0.7
2,048+5.6±0.4+5.8±0.5
1,024+1.9±0.6+2.3±0.5

At 8,192-token chunks, vSKIPPER reduces mean end-to-end latency across the tested rates, with smaller improvements at 2,048 tokens. At 1,024 tokens and 0.75×Q∗, latency changes by +1.6 ± 0.3%. With 1,024-token chunks, each admission round contains only one prompt, so no round reaches the 1,536-token prefill-routing threshold, and at this low load decode remains dense. This illustrates how chunk size and admission concurrency determine the opportunity for prefill routing.

W2: "The evaluation focuses on single-GPU throughput/latency; there is no exploration of interactions with speculative decoding, continuous batching variants, or other popular optimizations (e.g., FlashAttention variants beyond Triton attention)."

We support and evaluate vSkipper with tensor parallelism and disaggregated prefill/decode. GSM8K measurements use the default hybrid configuration, six repetitions, equal output lengths. Tensor parallelism uses two or four A100-SXM4-40GB GPUs. The two-GPU configuration has the same total GPU memory capacity (80 GB) as the single-GPU setup in the main table. Disaggregation uses two (1P1D) or four (2P2D) A100-80GB GPUs. Rates are multiples of each layout’s Q∗. All changes are percentages. Throughput is measured over the arrival window at 1.25×Q∗.

layout (Q∗)rateE2ETTFTTPOTTPSRPS
TP2 (19 req/s)0.75-2.0±0.4-2.7±1.9-2.1±0.4
0.95-2.4±4.9-6.8±3.5-2.6±5.1
1.25-16.7±0.4-30.5±0.7-6.4±0.2+5.6±0.4+6.1±0.2
TP4 (36 req/s)0.75+2.5±0.6-1.7±5.4+2.6±0.8
0.95-5.3±2.2-3.8±3.9-5.4±2.4
1.25-6.3±0.6-14.6±1.7-3.5±0.4+2.9±0.9+3.8±1.3
1P1D (14 req/s)0.75-2.1±0.8-14.6±3.4+0.2±0.2
0.95-8.7±0.8-32.6±2.0+0.5±0.1
1.25-57.5±0.7-64.6±0.7+3.3±0.1+10.0±0.1+9.6±0.1
2P2D (26 req/s)0.75-0.9±0.8-6.4±1.2-0.1±1.1
0.95-5.7±2.1-24.6±7.2+0.3±0.3
1.25-66.2±10.3-74.9±11.5+3.1±1.1+14.5±6.4+14.1±6.1

At 1.25×Q∗, vSkipper reduces mean end-to-end latency by 16.7±0.4% and 6.3±0.6% under two-way and four-way tensor parallelism. In disaggregated serving, prefill savings reduce queueing and completion time while time per output token increases slightly. Decode remains dense below its threshold. The decode-side load log reports about 22k–30k key/value tokens at 0.95×Q∗.

SGLang’s Triton backend uses FlashAttention-style prefill and Flash-Decoding-style decode. We also evaluate FlashInfer, SGLang’s default attention backend for A100, with its FlashAttention-2 prefill path in both systems. Both systems use FlashInfer for dense decode. Row-masked decode with FlashInfer is feasible but requires additional development, which we leave to future work. This GSM8K experiment uses an A100-80GB GPU, six repetitions, equal output lengths and Q∗=12 requests/second. Only prefill routes.

rateE2Ep50 E2Ep99 E2ETTFTTPOT
0.75 (9 req/s)-5.8±0.4-5.3±0.4-8.4±1.2-7.0±1.0-6.0±0.5
0.95 (11.4 req/s)-29.3±1.4-30.2±1.7-28.6±1.7-44.3±2.6-28.9±1.5
1.25 (15 req/s)-20.4±0.4-21.0±0.4-17.4±0.3-34.1±0.7-8.0±0.2

At 1.25×Q∗, arrival-window output tokens/second increase by 7.9±0.2% and completed requests/second by 8.4±0.2%. These results demonstrate compatibility with multiple serving configurations and attention backends.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Post 3: Skip distribution, semantics, and related work

Q2: "How sensitive are the profitability thresholds to skewed skip distributions (e.g., many tokens skip in only a few layers or vice versa)? Have you considered estimating an effective s weighted by live KV context to improve threshold accuracy?"

With the same overall skip fraction, RandomSkip produces similar performance when we swap the fractions of tokens and layers skipped. At skip fractions of 3/16, 1/8 and 3/8, the corresponding mean E2E changes versus upstream are +1.4% vs −0.3%, +12.6% vs +12.9%, and −38.8% vs −42.9%, respectively. These are single-run, always-route measurements from the submitted paper.

We also compute the skip fraction weighted by each token’s KV context length on 200 GSM8K and 200 BBH chain-of-thought requests. The unweighted and weighted fractions are 0.499 vs 0.500 on GSM8K and 0.503 vs 0.506 on BBH. Thus, the unweighted fraction is a close approximation for these traces. But context weighting may be useful when skip decisions differ substantially between long and short contexts. This requires evaluation on datasets with such differences.

W3: "The Project-Only semantics are described succinctly; a more explicit mapping from skipper semantics (e.g., FlexiDepth) to the Project-Only path could help readers verify equivalence, especially regarding attention outputs and adapter mixing."

Q3: "For Project-Only rows, attention reads are masked but own-layer KV is still written. Could you clarify how precisely this matches FlexiDepth’s training semantics (e.g., is “emit zero” for attention output faithful across all adapter/router variants)?"

In the FlexiDepth integration, a Project-Only row still computes and writes its own-layer key/value entries. During decode, it skips attention and the feed-forward network, using the checkpoint’s existing projector weights. During prefill, attention is computed and the skipped row’s attention contribution is masked. We will clarify this execution flow in the paper.

W5: "Early-exit serving systems (DREX, Apparate) are discussed, but a deeper comparison of design trade-offs (e.g., KV semantics, captured-graph compatibility) would contextualize vSKIPPER’s advantages for interior layer skipping."

W6: "Recent practical systems for dynamic compute (e.g., budget-driven depth routing or informed routing) are cited in spirit via related categories, but a more explicit comparison in serving feasibility and wall-clock impact at scale would benefit readers."

Apparate reduces response latency via early-exit predictions while continuing full-model execution to obtain accuracy feedback. In contrast, vSkipper bypasses selected interior-layer computations to directly reduce total execution work.

Dr.LLM learns static per-sequence routing decisions (skip, execute, or repeat) and groups sequences into per-layer microbatches, whereas vSkipper supports fine-grained, dynamic per-token routing across both layers and decoding steps.

Informed Routing selectively executes or approximates attention and FFN components individually per token, whereas vSkipper performs whole-layer skipping guided by a pluggable router module.

Furthermore, prior dynamic compute approaches are generally not integrated into modern LLM serving engines, leaving critical continuous batching and KV cache management mechanisms unaddressed.

DREX and vSkipper represent two systems built natively on modern LLM serving frameworks. DREX targets suffix-only early exits using cross-batch dynamic rebatching in Sarathi-Serve. Its throughput-oriented configuration reports 11.4% higher throughput and 3× p95 request completion time than its Consensus policy (§7.3, Figure 12). Conversely, vSkipper supports arbitrary per-token interior-layer skipping while maintaining active batch shapes and the CUDA Graph execution model, yielding simultaneous improvements in tail latency and throughput.

We thank the reviewer for the detailed writing suggestions and will incorporate them in the revised version.

Speculative decoding (Q4, continued from Post 2).

Speculative decoding complements vSkipper but requires coordination with routed execution and key/value state. Verification and rollback must account for skipped interior layers. Draft & Verify [1] verifies skipped-layer drafts, and LayerSkip [2] reuses prefix key/value state and exit activations. We leave integration to future work.

[1] Zhang et al. Draft & Verify: Lossless Large Language Model Acceleration via Self-Speculative Decoding. ACL 2024.

[2] Elhoushi et al. LayerSkip: Enabling Early Exit Inference and Self-Speculative Decoding. ACL 2024.

Thank you again for the detailed questions and suggestions. The revised manuscript incorporates our responses to your concerns:

  1. §3.1 clarifies the Project-Only prefill and decode semantics.
  2. §3.3 and Appendix N.1 report the routed-step overhead breakdown.
  3. Appendix D includes the context-weighted skip analysis.
  4. Appendix N.2 adds three-repetition cohort and graph-capture controls.
  5. §4.5 and Appendix O cover tensor parallelism, prefill–decode disaggregation, FlashInfer, and chunked prefill.
  6. §5 expands the comparison with related dynamic-compute systems, and §6 discusses speculative decoding as future work.

We have also updated the supplementary material with the code, model links, and experimental results.

We would welcome any further feedback on the revised explanations and measurements. Thank you again for your suggestions, which have helped us improve the paper.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of the revision and discussion

Thank you all for the feedback. We revised the manuscript to address four questions raised in the reviews:

  1. Does vSkipper generalize beyond FlexiDepth? We integrated D³, an independently developed, training-free skipping policy, in about 200 lines using the existing executor, graph builder, packed-row kernels, and KV paths. At fixed output lengths, vSkipper reduced mean end-to-end latency on BBH by 47.7–75.5% across the tested models, modes, and loads. In separate natural-stopping runs, always-route serving reproduced the native PyTorch accuracy gaps within 0.6 percentage points (§4.5).

  2. What does the execution path save? We clarified Project-Only in prefill and decode, added a per-step overhead breakdown and context-weighted skip analysis, and ran repeated cohort and CUDA Graph controls. With the same checkpoint, router, and decode graphs, packed cohorts cut mean end-to-end latency by 39.2% at the GSM8K knee compared with full-width execution (§§3.1, 3.3, and 4.5).

  3. Does it work with other serving configurations? We added tensor parallelism, prefill/decode disaggregation, FlashInfer, and three prefill chunk sizes. Across the four multi-GPU layouts, completed-request throughput rose by 3.8–14.1% at overload compared with upstream in the same layout (§4.5). We also expanded the related-work comparison and discuss speculative decoding in §§5–6.

  4. What happens under natural stopping? We now measure latency and accuracy in the same runs. We observed repetition in the released FlexiDepth checkpoint’s native PyTorch implementation. On GSM8K, the only workload with 3X more generation pointed by reviewer DAyt, post-training only the router and projector with GRPO reduced repetition without changing vSkipper’s runtime. At overload, the resulting checkpoint served with vSkipper achieved 20.0% lower mean latency and 8.0% higher completed-request throughput than upstream, with an accuracy differences of 2.98 percentage points when overloaded (§4.5) , within raw flexidepth checkpoint 's 3.26%. So, we shows by well post training, it is feasible to address the over generation issues of trained skipper with quality improvment, while the major motivation of this work still kept as efficiently serving the checkpoint itself.

We updated the supplementary code, model links, and experimental results to accompany the revision. We appreciate the suggestions that helped improve the paper.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.