- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript presents AffectAgent, a planner–executor–evaluator framework for affective image editing. It introduces Knowledge-Grounded Multi-Plan Exploration (KGME), which constructs multiple editing plans using an external Emotional Knowledge Bank, and Memory-Calibrated Preference Optimization (MCPO), which adjusts preference supervision based on historical outcomes from similar affective transitions. Experiments demonstrate improved valence and arousal accuracy compared with existing image editing methods. The problem of controlling image affect while preserving semantic content is relevant, and the reported improvements in affective accuracy are promising. However, the methodological novelty is limited, as the proposed framework primarily integrates established knowledge retrieval, multi-plan generation, and preference optimization techniques. The distinct technical contributions beyond these existing components are not sufficiently established.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a relevant problem in affective image editing by explicitly exploring multiple editing strategies and considering differences across affective transitions.
- The experiments cover three datasets and include comparisons with existing editing methods, alternative optimization strategies, ablation studies, and human evaluations. The results demonstrate consistent improvements in target-affect accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
- The methodological novelty of KGME is limited. Its core procedure combines existing vision-language models, semantic clustering, heuristic knowledge retrieval, and prompt-based editing plan generation. Although this provides a structured exploration process, the individual components are largely established techniques, and their integration does not introduce a substantially new planning or learning mechanism.
- The proposed framework has considerable conceptual overlap with prior work. In particular, EmoAgent has already explored planning, editing, and evaluation agents with emotion-factor knowledge retrieval and strategy exploration. The manuscript does not sufficiently clarify how its knowledge-grounded planning differs fundamentally from such existing approaches.
- The methodological contribution of MCPO is relatively incremental. Its formulation relies on nearest-neighbor retrieval of similar affective transitions, statistical normalization of evaluation scores, covariance-based scaling, and preference distribution matching. These operations are closely related to established normalization and preference optimization techniques.
Questions for authors
MCPO mainly combines transition-based memory retrieval with statistical normalization and adaptive preference scaling. What makes this formulation fundamentally different from applying task-conditioned reward normalization to existing preference optimization methods, and which individual calibration components are essential to its effectiveness?