- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2(+1)
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TITAnD, a supervised framework for multi-month trajectory anomaly detection that unifies dense GPS trajectories and sparse stay-point sequences through a Hyperspectral Trajectory Image (HTI) representation. The key idea is to reorganize long-term trajectories into a two-dimensional day × time-of-day grid, where each cell encodes spatial, semantic, temporal, and kinematic information. To efficiently model this representation, the authors introduce a Cyclic Factorized Transformer (CFT), which alternates intra-day and inter-day attention to capture within-day movement patterns and recurring behavioral routines across days, while reducing the computational complexity of standard self-attention.
Critical strengths
S1. The proposed HTI representation provides a unified framework for detecting anomalies in both dense GPS trajectories and sparse stay-point sequences.
S2. The CFT effectively captures intra-day and inter-day behavioral patterns while significantly reducing computational costs compared to standard Transformers.
S3. TITAnD achieves competitive performance across four benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The proposed HTI representation and CFT architecture share substantial similarities with existing period-based time-series models and axial attention mechanisms. Although these connections are discussed, the paper lacks direct experimental comparisons with closely related methods, making it difficult to establish the novelty and distinct benefits of the proposed approach.
W2. Lack of evaluation on real-world trajectories. All four benchmarks rely on simulated trajectories or synthetically injected anomalies.
W3. The paper reports training and validation splits but does not clearly establish a test set. The appendix states that the reported results use checkpoints selected by validation performance.
W4. The superiority of full CFT over single-axis attention does not establish that the specific cyclic alignment is essential, as opposed to the general benefits of factorized attention.
W5. The proposed HTI is essentially a structured day x time-of-day feature tensor rather than an image in the conventional sense. Referring to it as a "hyperspectral image" may be misleading, as its channels represent learned trajectory features rather than spectral information. The authors should better justify this terminology.
W6. Insufficient comparisons with trajectory anomaly detection baselines, which are widely studied in the community. In particular, the paper explicitly distinguishes dense and sparse trajectory anomaly detection, the trajectory-specific baselines considered are limited to sparse methods.
W7. The experimental section is not well structured, making it difficult to follow the evaluation protocol and interpret the results. A clearer organization and more systematic analysis would improve readability and strengthen the experimental discussion.
Questions for authors
NA
5 comments
Thank you for the detailed rebuttal. I appreciate the efforts made to strengthen the paper. These new results and clarifications have addressed several of my major concerns and improved my confidence in the technical soundness of the work. I have therefore raised my Soundness score. I have one additional suggestion regarding the revised manuscript: it would be helpful if the authors could highlight the changes made in response to the reviewers' comments, so that reviewers can more easily identify and assess the revisions.
We thank the reviewer for the positive follow-up and are glad that the additional experiments and clarifications have addressed several of the major concerns.
Following the suggestion, we have uploaded a revised manuscript with all changes highlighted in blue. The main revisions are:
- Held-out Test evaluation for every benchmark, with disjoint Train, Validation, and Test agents (Sec. 4.1, Table 3, Appendix H).
- Comparisons with TimeMixer++ and GM-VSAE (Sec. 4.2, Appendix I).
- Distinction from axial attention (Sec. 3.3, Appendix G).
- Calendar-alignment, history-length, and label-efficiency studies (Sec. 4.3, Appendix J).
- Detection of unseen anomaly groups (Appendix K).
- Results on the public SF-TPAD benchmark (Appendix L).
We appreciate the reviewer's constructive feedback, which has helped strengthen the paper
Reply to R-WxxM (Part 1 of 1)
Reply to R-WxxM
We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback. The concerns about novelty and comparisons with closely related methods (W1), simulated data (W2), the independent test set (W3), and cyclic alignment (W4) are addressed in the General Response, Sections 2–3, 5, 1, and 4, respectively. Below, we address the remaining concerns.
1. Dense trajectory baselines
To address this concern, we added a supervised adaptation of GM-VSAE [1], a dense trajectory anomaly detection method, using its released trip encoder. Existing dense trajectory anomaly detection methods, such as iBAT, GM-VSAE, DeepTEA [2], and FOTraj, primarily focus on detecting anomalies within individual trips. Our task differs as we detect and localize anomalies over an agent's multi-month trajectory, including behavior outside trips. In Dense Tokyo, only 16–18% of anomalous 5-minute slots occur within trips.
We evaluated GM-VSAE in two configurations: its original trip-only formulation and an extension that also considers stay-points. Both were trained using the same supervision as the other baselines. Further implementation details are provided in the supplementary material.
All methods are evaluated on the same 15-minute slots for a fair comparison.
GM-VSAE achieves meaningful agent-level detection performance (0.79 AUC-PR), but struggles with temporal localization. This reflects a limitation of trip-based methods when applied to complete multi-month behavioral histories, where many anomalies occur outside individual trips. CFT, in contrast, localizes anomalous behavior across the full trajectory.
2. The term "hyperspectral"
We use "hyperspectral" as an analogy to the multichannel image structure of HTI, rather than to imply that its channels represent optical spectra. Each pixel encodes learned spatial, semantic, temporal, and kinematic features. We will clarify this terminology in Sec. 3. If the reviewer still finds the term inappropriate, we are open to changing it and would appreciate any suggestions.
3. Structure of the experimental section
We appreciate the reviewer's feedback on the experimental organization. In the revised paper, Sec. 4.1 now gives the train, validation, and test sizes of every benchmark and states that all metrics are computed only over the evaluation period; Table 3 reports the held-out Test results; and each ablation in Sec. 4.3 states the question it answers before its result. We would be glad to clarify any further experiments, tables, or explanations the reviewer found unclear.
References
[1] Y. Liu et al. Online Anomalous Trajectory Detection with Deep Generative Sequence Modeling. ICDE 2020.
[2] X. Han et al. DeepTEA: Effective and Efficient Online Time-dependent Trajectory Outlier Detection. PVLDB 2022.