- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CP-GS which is a capacity-precision coupled framework for efficient 2D Gaussian image representation. The method combines content-adaptive Gaussian reallocation, hierarchical distortion-aware quantization, and joint capacity-precision optimization to improve rate-distortion performance under storage constraints. Experiments on Kodak and DIV2K demonstrate improved reconstruction quality and compression efficiency over several existing approaches.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a meaningful problem by jointly considering Gaussian representation capacity and attribute precision under limited storage budgets.
The proposed method achieves competitive reconstruction quality and rate-distortion performance compared with existing Gaussian-based image representation methods, while maintaining relatively low optimization costs.
The paper provides comprehensive ablation studies demonstrating the effectiveness of individual components. In particular, the structured precision allocation achieves performance close to exhaustive search with substantially fewer evaluations.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient comparison under matched compression budgets. The paper emphasizes rate-distortion optimization under storage constraints. However, the main comparison in Table 1 primarily evaluates reconstruction quality under matched Gaussian counts and parameter counts, rather than actual compressed bitstream sizes. Although the authors provide rate-distortion ablations, direct comparisons with existing Gaussian-based compression methods under matched bitrates are limited. Such comparisons would better establish the practical compression advantages of CP-GS.
-
Limited justification of the proposed capacity-precision coupling. The joint optimization primarily constructs a finite candidate space with different Gaussian counts and quantization configurations, followed by rate-distortion-based selection. While the ablations demonstrate improvements over capacity-only and precision-only optimization, it remains unclear whether the proposed coupling significantly outperforms a simpler sequential optimization strategy that independently optimizes capacity and precision. A direct comparison would help clarify the methodological contribution of the proposed joint optimization.
-
Insufficient clarification of the optimization cost. The proposed method starts from an Image-GS representation and introduces additional capacity reallocation, recovery optimization, precision calibration, and candidate evaluation. However, it is not sufficiently clear how the cost of these stages is accounted for in the reported optimization times. A detailed runtime breakdown, including the initial Image-GS fitting process, would help establish the fairness of the efficiency comparisons.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide comparisons with existing Gaussian-based compression methods under matched actual bitrates? How does the proposed joint optimization compare with a sequential capacity-then-precision optimization strategy? Does the reported optimization time include the initial Image-GS fitting stage?
The authors’ response addresses most of my concerns. After considering it, I have decided to keep my original score.