- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OIC-GS, an omnidirectional Gaussian splatting codec based on a hierarchical HEALPix primitive grid. Primitives are anchored at predefined spherical locations, so coordinates need not be coded, and a lightweight entropy model estimates the rate of each primitive. A rate-distortion adaptive primitive selection mechanism removes primitives whose coding cost is not justified, and a rendering-conditioned context model improves entropy coding. A single bitstream supports full-sphere, viewport-dependent, and progressive decoding. Experiments show significant BD-rate reductions over evaluated GS codecs, with real-time viewport rendering.
Critical strengths
The paper presents a well-motivated approach with convincing results. The proposed OIC-GS achieves significant BD-rate reductions over all evaluated GS codecs, and the overall pipeline is logically coherent. The combination of HEALPix-based hierarchical representation, rate-distortion adaptive primitive selection, and rendering-conditioned context is technically sound, and the experimental validation on both the main benchmark and SUN360 supports the main claims. The viewport-dependent and progressive decoding capabilities are practically relevant for immersive VR applications.
Critical weaknesses
Neither the abstract nor the introduction explicitly states "omnidirectional image compression" or "GS-based image compression." Given that the paper's core task is compression, this omission weakens the positioning and may mislead readers into thinking this is a rendering/representation paper.
Weak connection between Figure 1 and Figure 2. Figure 1 lacks any variable or visual cue linking it to Figure 2. For example, pass 2 outputs h, but h does not appear in Figure 1, and there is no arrow or annotation guiding the reader from Figure 1 to Figure 2. It is difficult to quickly establish the correspondence between the two figures.
In Figure 2 caption. RCC stands for "rendering-conditioned context," not "rendering-conditioned entropy model.". In the "spherical Gaussian rendering" part of Figure 1, the last row should be F6
From Equation (9) onward, it is hard to connect the equations to the content of Figure 2, and it is unclear which part of the pipeline these equations correspond to. The paper would benefit from clearer textual linking between equations, figures, and the encoding/decoding workflow.
Questions for authors
How did you come up with Equation (10)? Is there any reference or rationale behind it?
I'm curious whether RCC and RDPS need to be enabled at all levels. Table 14 shows level 4 has a selection ratio of 71.9–78.6% while level 6 only has 6.3–18.2%, and Table 3 shows removing level 4 from the checkerboard only costs +0.4%. This suggests different levels play very different roles. Could you discuss the trade-off of not enabling RCC or RDPS at the coarser levels? An ablation would help.