- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces Roomer, a framework that combines object-grounded geometric diagnosis, a geometry-conditioned vision-language planner, deterministic search, and verification with rollback to locally repair generated 3D indoor layouts while seeking to preserve already-valid content. The authors also introduce the Roomer-CC training dataset and Roomer-Eval evaluation protocol, with experiments demonstrating reduced geometric violations and improved satisfaction of predefined spatial usability rules on held-out 3D-FRONT rooms and outputs from four external generators.
Critical strengths
S1. Clear problem formulation and a controlled local repair mechanism. The paper addresses specific violations in existing layouts by combining object-grounded diagnosis, geometry-conditioned planning, candidate search, and verification with rollback. Each edit targets an identifiable object and violation, and is checked for newly introduced hard-rule violations before being committed. This design provides a practical way to correct local errors while preserving already-valid parts of the layout. S2. A dedicated training dataset and reasonably comprehensive evaluation provide direct evidence of repair effectiveness. The authors construct a dataset of 67,550 paired repair examples and evaluate geometric validity and practical usability, supplemented by professional judgments. In particular, the paired before-and-after evaluations on outputs from four external generators retain all test scenes, providing convincing evidence that Roomer improves existing layouts within the evaluated setting.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The absence of a direct comparison with closely related recent work leaves the incremental contribution insufficiently established. SceneReVis already supports visual feedback, multi-turn object-level editing, and the repair of existing flawed layouts, making it closely related to Roomer in both task and overall workflow. Although Roomer cites this work, it provides neither a detailed methodological comparison nor a quantitative evaluation against it, and does not explicitly explain its exclusion. Consequently, the current experiments do not sufficiently establish the additional benefits of Roomer’s object-grounded diagnosis, geometry-conditioning branch, and verification mechanism over this close alternative. W2. The ablation intended to demonstrate the advantage of local editing over full-scene rewriting is confounded. Beyond changing the output scope, the Full-Scene JSON Rewrite variant removes the acceptance conditions that prohibit new hard-rule violations and preserve protected satisfied relations, and does not use the corresponding deterministic candidate fallback search. Its weaker performance may therefore reflect the removal of safeguards and search, rather than the use of full-scene rewriting itself. This comparison does not isolate the contribution of the local StatePatch representation.
Questions for authors
Q1. Could the authors compare Roomer with more recent, closely related baselines, such as SceneReVis? Q2. Given the potential generalization capabilities of the general-purpose Qwen2.5-VL backbone, could the authors evaluate Roomer beyond 3D-FRONT?