- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
ProScene generates indoor scenes through a box, cuboid, mesh hierarchy. Coupled layout and cuboid denoisers exchange features, while box- and cuboid-level violation energies guide training and late sampling. A cuboid-conditioned TRELLIS model then generates individual meshes. Experiments show reduced mesh collisions and room-boundary violations across three initial layout generators.
Critical strengths
- Cuboids provide a useful bridge between efficient scene planning and detailed mesh synthesis, enabling finer collision reasoning than a single box while supporting retrieval-free generation.
- Jointly evolving layout and object structure is well motivated: geometry can inform placement, and scene context can inform shape. The interaction and guidance ablations support this design across a modular pipeline.
Critical weaknesses
- False-positive box penalties remain in the objective. Equations 11–15 directly penalize box overlap even when the corresponding cuboids do not collide. This can discourage the valid interleaving used to motivate finer geometry. Combined guidance improves results in Table 4, so the design may be a useful robustness trade-off, but its effect on valid overlaps needs explanation.
- Existence-weighted guidance permits a structural shortcut. Collision energy can decrease by suppressing cuboids instead of moving them (Eq. 10). Appendix A.3 acknowledges this and uses smaller cuboid updates, applied in only the final two steps; denoising priors also provide safeguards. These mitigate the risk, but completeness or cuboid-coverage measurements would clarify whether it occurs. Top-down semantic FID is a limited check on missing object parts.
Questions for authors
- How does direct box-overlap penalization affect valid interleaving, and why is it preferable to using boxes only to select cuboid candidate pairs?
- How do occupancy, residual collisions, and cuboid coverage change from before guidance to the cuboid output and then the final meshes?
3 comments
Follow-up on Author Response and Further Discussion
Dear Reviewer DmEm,
Thank you for your time and constructive feedback. We have provided detailed responses and additional results addressing your questions and concerns.
As the author-reviewer discussion period is closing soon, we would be grateful if you could take a look at our clarifications. We hope they have addressed your concerns; if anything remains unclear, we would be very happy to discuss further.
Thank you again for your time.
Best regards,
The Authors
Official Comment by Authors
Dear Reviewer DmEm,
Thank you again for your thoughtful comments on our paper. We have provided detailed responses and additional experiments to address the concerns raised in your review.
As the discussion period is now nearing its end, we would be happy to clarify any remaining questions or concerns. If you find our responses satisfactory, we would be grateful if you could take them into account when finalizing your assessment.
Best regards, The Authors
Response to Reviewer DmEm
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the motivation for using cuboids as an intermediate structural representation and the benefit of bidirectional layout-cuboid evolution. We address the concerns below.
(W1 & Q1). Effect of box-overlap penalization on valid interleaving. We analyze this effect on bedroom scenes, following the setting of our ablation study. In general, box-level guidance encourages overlapping boxes to move farther apart, including valid interleaving pairs. Thus, direct box guidance can in principle discourage valid interleaving. However, object pairs with actual geometric collisions, identified by colliding cuboids, are pushed farther apart than valid interleaving pairs, with a 27.6% larger average center separation. In practice, we control its strength through the guidance hyperparameters, and under the setting used in our experiments, all valid-interleaving pairs are preserved, although their box penetration is slightly reduced by the box-collision penalty.
We keep the box-collision term because it provides a complementary coarse correction signal and leads to better results, as supported by the ablation study in Table 4 (main paper). Since we constrain each cuboid to lie within its parent box, cuboids from different objects can collide only if their parent boxes overlap. Therefore, we use box overlap to identify candidate object pairs for cuboid-level spatial violation assessment, avoiding the need to check all cuboid pairs and improving efficiency.
(W2 & Q2). Structural shortcut and geometry preservation. We evaluate whether guidance reduces spatial violations by suppressing cuboids. The table below reports the average number of active cuboids per object, occupied volume, box-occupancy ratio, and spatial violations before and after guidance, together with statistics of the final generated meshes.
With the small cuboid guidance step size ηC=0.002 used in our experiments, the average number of active cuboids remains unchanged at 2.972 per object (close to the average of 2.956 cuboids per object computed from the ground-truth cuboid labels). Cuboid volume decreases by only 0.3%, whereas cuboid-level VBL decreases by approximately 2.5%. Therefore, the reduction in spatial violations is not achieved by suppressing cuboids. The generated meshes are also consistent with the final cuboid structures: 95.86% of the generated mesh volume is covered by the predicted cuboids. Together, these results show that the improvement in spatial validity is obtained while preserving the predicted object structure through the cuboid output and subsequent mesh generation.