- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on group image generation involving 5–10 individuals, rather than personalized generation for a single person or a small number of individuals. By integrating ID tokens, Representation Forcing, identity-aware Layout, CoT, and LG-ID Loss, the proposed method achieves the best Sim(Tgt) while maintaining a lower Copy-Paste score. Furthermore, the experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed LG-ID Loss.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practically valuable task. Personalized image generation involving multiple individuals, particularly five or more, remains relatively underexplored in existing research.
- The paper is well-written, clearly structured, and easy to follow.
- The main experiments include comparisons with both open-source and proprietary models, making the evaluation comprehensive and well-designed. The ablation studies are also thorough and effectively demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed LG-ID Loss.
Critical weaknesses
- Celebrities can already be specified through text prompts, and GPT-Image 2 can generate reasonably good results. What are the advantages of the proposed method in this scenario? Is the method limited to generating celebrities, or does the benchmark also include ordinary individuals?
- When an identity is specified through a reference image, can other identities still be specified through text? For example, can the method generate a photo of <ID> and Elon Musk, where one person is specified by an ID reference image and Elon Musk is specified through text?
- How is the aesthetic quality of the generated images after identity customization? Are there any quantitative metrics to evaluate this aspect?
- Which model is used to predict human keypoints? How reasonable and accurate are the predicted human structures, and has this been validated? Can the model generate anatomically plausible human bodies using only bounding boxes? A visualization-based ablation study might help clarify this.
Questions for authors
- Some implementation details are missing. Equation (3) does not explain what L_ID and L_NTP represent or provide their mathematical formulations. Similarly, the formulation of LG-ID Loss appears to be missing.
- What is the demographic distribution of the benchmark constructed from 210 real-world groups? For example, does it consist entirely of celebrities, or does it also include ordinary individuals?
- The paper does not clearly specify the backbone model or codebase used in the proposed method. Is it built upon WithAnyone? If so, are the main modifications the introduction of LG-ID Loss and Layout CoT?
- What is the difference between Sim(Ref) and Sim(Tgt)?