- Rating
- 4(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper notes that when prompts use numerical identifiers to refer to reference images (e.g., "image 2 on the left"), multi-reference image generators often correctly identify the subject but place it in the wrong location. The authors quantified this issue across five backbones by conducting counterfactual audits using cyclic redistribution and input permutation. They proposed a training-free method called AddrBind: an MLLM planner determines which reference image belongs in which slot, and the attention mechanism among reference patches is redistributed according to this assignment while keeping the total reference attention constant. Slot accuracy across all five backbones surpassed that of the baseline generation methods.
Critical strengths
- The analysis is quite thorough. Separating "who is in the image" from "who is at which location" constitutes a useful protocol (Tables 1, 5).
- The performance gains hold true across five vastly different backbones and two benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
-
A few simple baselines are missing. Fig. 2(b) shows that appearance-based descriptions remain effective, whereas ID-based references fail; Table 1 demonstrates that, using the FLUX backbone, a canonical input order significantly outperforms a shuffled order. This naturally suggests two simple fixes: having the planner rewrite IDs as descriptions or reordering the inputs. Neither approach was tested. Furthermore, aside from MS-Diffusion and SIGMA-GEN, newer multi-subject models such as UNO and DreamO were neither compared against nor cited.
-
The layout component has not been proven effective. According to the caption for Table 2, the "Oracle plan" and "static GT-region routing" utilize the same set of ground-truth (GT) regions and assignments. Yet, across both FLUX backbones, static routing performs noticeably better (Table 2: 0.871 vs. 0.800, 0.901 vs. 0.832; Table 4: 0.896 vs. 0.842). While the two methods tie on OmniGen2, the Oracle plan actually performs better on SDXL and Qwen. Consequently, for FLUX, the explanation provided in Sec. 4.2 fails to account for this performance gap; the layout-feedback stage might even be detrimental to performance.
-
The cost in image quality is understated. On FLUX-4B, the BG-Sim score drops from 0.320 to 0.087 (Table 8), yet Sec. 4.3 describes this decline as "only slight." Across 152 routed MultiBanana tasks, the baseline evaluator's Instruction Alignment score drops by 0.58 on a 1–10 scale—with a confidence interval excluding zero (Table 12)—a fact completely omitted from the main text. Plotting a trade-off curve against the shift bound would make this cost much clearer.
Questions for authors
- How does AddrBind compare to prompt rewriting via a planner and to direct input reordering?
- On the FLUX backbone, why does the oracle plan underperform static GT routing when both have access to the same GT information?
- Are the main results based on a single seed?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer etqD (2/2): Execution, trade-offs, and seeds
W2 / Q2: Oracle versus static GT routing.
Both controls receive the same GT plan, but their execution differs: Oracle retains scout-based soft spatial responsibilities and gating, while Static directly routes within hard GT regions and preserves the original allocation elsewhere. Their comparison therefore measures the combined effect of these execution choices. In Table 4, Oracle and Static obtain Slot .842 and .896, respectively; we have corrected Section 4.2 to distinguish their execution paths.
The added 40-task comparison shares predicted plans across routed conditions (Appendix G.2, Table 14). Prior-only removes scout evidence while retaining the spatial prior, gating, and executor; Planner-static uses predicted hard regions. Slot is .6875 for Native, .8667 for Prior-only, .8375 for Planner-static, and .8875 for AddrBind. These results support the value of executing reference allocation; the complete executor achieves the highest point estimate, with paired difference intervals touching or crossing zero against the simplified controls.
W3: Content preservation and the shift-bound trade-off.
We have replaced the “only slight” characterization with a description of backbone-dependent quality trade-offs. On FLUX.2-klein-4B, BG-Sim changes from .320 to .087 (Table 8); among 132 valid pairs from 152 routed MultiBanana tasks, Instruction Alignment changes by −.58 (95% CI [−1.01, −.15]; Table 12).
The requested trade-off curve is now Figure 5 in Appendix G.3. On 40 fixed two-/three-person tasks with the FLUX.2-klein-4B bounded executor, only D varies:
| Configuration | Slot ↑ | BG-Sim ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| Native | .5625 | .3596 |
| AddrBind, D = 2 | .8208 | .2380 |
| AddrBind, D = 4 | .8417 | .0684 |
| AddrBind, D = 8 | .8417 | .0633 |
| AddrBind, default D ≈ 27.63 | .8417 | .0637 |
D = 2 retains most assignment gains over Native while improving background similarity relative to the default, with a slightly lower Slot point estimate. This provides an adjustable assignment–background balance within the same allocation mechanism. The default D = ln(10¹²) follows the original implementation’s numerical scale.
Q3: Random seeds.
The main results in the original submission are averaged over three random seeds.
These clarifications and additions are marked in blue in the revised manuscript, with the new evidence in Tables 13–14 and Figure 5.
We hope these clarifications address your concerns and would be happy to discuss any remaining questions.
Paper version update
Dear Reviewer,
We have revised the main text and appendices to address your comments. All changes are highlighted in blue.
Sincerely
Response to Reviewer etqD (1/2): Baselines
Thank you for recognizing our diagnosis and cross-backbone improvements. We have added the suggested comparisons and shift-bound analysis, and clarified execution strategies.
W1 / Q1: Prompt rewriting, input reordering, and additional models.
We evaluated both input-side baselines on the same 50 four-person and 50 five-person CogCanvas tasks. Rewriting uses planner-generated appearance descriptions of the input references; reordering follows the predicted spatial plan and updates image indices consistently. AddrBind preserves the original prompt and reference order and executes the requested identity–position assignment during generation.
Automatic rewriting helps. AddrBind improves Slot over rewriting by .100 at both cardinalities, with paired 95% intervals above zero (Appendix G.1). Exact point estimates are also higher; the five-person Exact difference interval crosses zero. Rewriting has higher five-person coverage, highlighting the distinction between recovering identities and placing them correctly. The tested reordering rule did not improve mean Slot.
Native, input-side baselines, and AddrBind use FLUX.2-klein-4B. UNO and DreamO use their released FLUX.1-dev backbones for cross-system comparison, receiving all nine references on the four-person tasks. DreamO uses official person/object IP preprocessing and a full-image background-input adaptation. These comparisons and the formal UNO/DreamO citations are included in Appendix G.1, Table 13, and Section 4.1.