- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper describes a framework for spatial rendering and intelligence taking as input sparse panoramic images of multiroom panoramic environment. Authors propose a dataset for training, and a technology for arbitrary RGB-D rendering and 3D object detection in terms of bounding boxes; moreover authors demonstrate the propose method in a 3DGS trajectory through an interpolated path. The assessment is performed by comparing modern baselines on various tasks as static benchmarks.
Critical strengths
- Complete framework for spatial reasoning and intelligence: the problem setup is challenging and worth of exploration.
- Manuscript clear, and well organized; the methodology is described properly, and the system is carefully designed, even if there is no siginificant theoretical contribution.
- Estensive assessment and evaluation: various baselines are compared, and the static results appear convincing for a variety of tasks.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is the lack of dynamic assessment: while the static results appear convincing for the spatial intelligence, the claim related to rendering is not supported by adequate results.
-
For rendering, I would have expected comparisons against baselines targetting rendering like PanoSplatt3r$^1$ or PanoFloor$^2$
-
I would have expected as supplementary dynamic videos also showcasing the transition between different rooms, in a multiroom environment,
-
I would have expected results considering datasets like Matterport or Replica360, that use exactly the same setting (sparse panoramas), and provide ground truth for unseen poses.
-
The results provided consider only very short paths with consistent overlaps between the views.
-
Computational performance in inference are missing, specifically for rendering purposes.
[1] Ren, Jiahui, et al. "Panosplatt3r: Leveraging perspective pretraining for generalized unposed wide-baseline panorama reconstruction." 2025 IEEE/CVF International Conference on Computer Vision (ICCV). IEEE, 2025. [2] Pintore, G., Jashari, S., Agus, M., & Gobbetti, E. (2025, October). Panofloor: Reconstruction and immersive exploration of large multi-room scenes from a minimal set of registered panoramic images using denoised density maps. In 2025 IEEE International Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality (ISMAR) (pp. 414-424). IEEE.
Questions for authors
Provide more evidence in a dynamic setting, specifically in the context of real-time virtual tour, otherwise the claim related to spatial rendering is completely not justified.