- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces WorldExpand, a multi-view panoramic image generation and 3D fusion framework, aiming to synthesize an explorable panoramic world. The authors propose Coverage-Guided View Selection and Joint Panoramic Diffusion to determine which panoramas are to be generated, and finally reconstruct them into a world through depth alignment.
Critical strengths
The writing is easy to follow and the supplementary video is high-resolution.
Critical weaknesses
-
The motivation of this paper is problematic. The authors claim that dense panoramic video generation is redundant; however, this so-called "redundancy" is actually necessary to simultaneously capture spatio-temporal continuity. What the authors describe as sparse prediction, in fact, discards critical dynamic information and focuses only on spatial aspects, which is essentially a step backward rather than an improvement. For instance, how does this method model dynamic objects, such as moving vehicles? As shown in a scene in the supplementary material, the water flow appears completely static, which is a significant limitation.
-
Following up on the previous point, if the authors' intention is to explore static 3D world generation rather than panoramic video generation, then WonderJourney, WonderWorld, and LayerPano3D appear to be more scalable and reasonable solutions. Unfortunately, the authors overlook these works and fail to cite them.
-
The experiments are insufficient. Why are comparisons made only with GenEx and Matrix-3D? Why are WorldExplorer and OmniRoam not included?
-
Joint Pano is not particularly novel; many prior works, such as VideoPanda, ViewPoint, and CubeComposer, share similar ideas. The authors merely extend this idea from a single panorama to multiple panoramas.
[1] Wonderjourney: Going from anywhere to everywhere. CVPR 2024.
[2] Wonderworld: Interactive 3d scene generation from a single image. CVPR 2025.
[3] LayerPano3D: Layered 3D Panorama for Hyper-Immersive Scene Generation. SIGGRAPH 2025.
[4] WorldExplorer: Towards generating fully navigable 3d scenes. SIGGRAPH Asia 2025.
[5] OmniRoam: World wandering via long-horizon panoramic video generation. SIGGRAPH 2026.
[6] VideoPanda: Panoramic Video Diffusion with Multi-view Attention. arxiv 2504.11389.
[7] ViewPoint: Panoramic video generation with pretrained diffusion models. NeurIPS 2025.
[8] CubeComposer: Spatio-Temporal Autoregressive 4K 360 Video Generation from Perspective Video. CVPR 2026.
Questions for authors
- What is the range of scenes to which N=4 applies (e.g., geometric complexity, number of rooms, topological connectivity)?
- Why are HY-World 2.0, WorldExplorer, and OmniRoam not included for comparison?
Thank you for your response, I raise my rating to 2. And, can you provide some video results on the comparison?