- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how moving a fixed-size microphone array changes the identifiability and estimation error of a room sound field. Under a known-mode linear Gaussian model, it establishes a rank obstruction for a static array, derives the asymptotic Bayes risk of a moving array, and relates uniform conditioning to geometric coverage.
Critical strengths
- The separation of the three issues is clear.
- It provides the quantitative risk characterization as well as the interpretable geometric result.
- Overall it provides a theoretical foundation to understand the mobile sound field estimations.
Critical weaknesses
-
Proposition 1 assumes that both the coefficient vector and the observation operator at a fixed position remain unchanged across snapshots. Repeated measurements then cannot increase rank. A model with known modal dynamics, varying excitation, or cross-frequency constraints could yield different equations over time even with a stationary array. The impossibility claim should be tied explicitly to the physical measurement setting for which this observation model is appropriate.
-
Proposition 2 concerns the worst-conditioned direction over all modal dimensions, whereas the risk constant in Theorem 1 depends on a spectral trace at a particular (K). A small uncovered region can destroy the uniform guarantee without necessarily causing a large error in the frequency range of interest. The paper should state more precisely what follows when the coverage condition fails, especially for finite (K).
-
The Neumann modes can represent wave behavior associated with boundaries included in the assumed room geometry. The real-room reconstruction, however, uses a rigid-box modal basis that omits the furnishings. Diffraction, scattering, or boundary-condition errors arising from unmodeled features may produce position-dependent residuals rather than the independent noise assumed in Theorem 1. The paper should discuss whether such residuals create a non-vanishing reconstruction bias and which part of the claimed (1/T) error decay survives model mismatch.
-
Can you elaborate on a practical procedure to estimate B and d_eff directly from data when the room modes are not known, e.g., via sample Gram matrices across positions or random probing?
Questions for authors
See above.
3 comments
Thanks for your prompt reply. After reading the responses, I am largely satisfied with the authors’ responses to my concerns and will maintain my positive rating.
Thank you for reading our response and for the constructive review. Your questions on finite K and on model mismatch made the paper clearer. We appreciate your time and effort!
Reviewer Ri8T
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading. Changes in the revised PDF are mint, or sky blue when another reviewer shares the concern.
W1 Scope of the impossibility claim. Agreed. The physical setting is a steady field from a fixed source, so the coefficients stay constant during recording. Proposition 1 needs those coefficients free in ℝ^K and the same spatial operator at every snapshot. With known dynamics, a known excitation model, or cross-frequency constraints, the bound need not apply. Sections 3 and 4 now say so. (also mentioned in Reviewer i9Us, W1.1)
W2 When coverage fails at finite K. At finite K, the limit in Theorem 1 still holds. Every room where the array fits has γ_B(K) < 1 (Lemma 2), so the constant is finite. What fails is a bound on γ_B that holds for all K at once. The horizon factor (1 - γ_B)⁻² then has no uniform bound. In Table 10 the rise in d_eff grows with the uncovered volume. Room 13 fails the coverage test. Its γ_B still sits inside the range of covered rooms at all three tested K (Table 7). A 45° rotation of the array removes coverage in every room of Table 10. There, d_eff rises by 4% in the faithful-scale box, with 0.05% uncovered. It rises by 78% in the cube, with 2.1% uncovered. A remark after Proposition 2 now says this. The abstract and Section 8 now say that γ_B bounds the constant.
W3.1 Bias from unmodeled features. Yes, it does not vanish. The estimator explains part of the unmodeled field with the modeled modes, and more data does not undo that. In a synthetic check the risk levels off at the predicted floor. Details are in W3.2. (also mentioned in Reviewer eD6R, W1, and Reviewer i9Us, Q5)
W3.2 What survives of the 1/T decay. The noise part decays as 1/T with the constant of Theorem 1. The unmodeled modes add a second term, which decays to a nonzero floor. The total error stops at that floor. A synthetic check, which is not in the paper, confirms this. With 50 modeled and 110 true modes, the moving risk levels off at 0.444, against a predicted floor of 0.445. It also shows a cost. With unmodeled energy at 12% of the modeled energy, the moving array has higher risk than the best static position at T = 500 snapshots. It has lower risk on every path from T = 2000 on. Section 8 now states the floor and this early-time cost.
Q1 Estimating B and d_eff from data. A procedure exists for a covered room, with sample Gram matrices as the reviewer suggests. The procedure has three steps.
With the modes hidden in a synthetic box room, 200 fields and noise, single runs recover d_eff to within 0.8% and γ_B to within 0.04 at 20000 snapshots. The procedure needs K as an input and sees nothing inside an uncovered set. The real-room data hold too few positions for it, so we leave it as future work. (also mentioned in Reviewer eD6R, W1)