- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the structural differences in the binding of five EGFR inhibitors across three generations to wild-type and T790M mutant EGFR. The authors employ conventional molecular docking (AutoDock Vina), PLIP, and PyMOL to compare docking scores, binding poses, and interaction patterns. The results suggest that docking scores poorly reflect the experimentally reported differences in resistance across inhibitor generations.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important and practically relevant problem in drug discovery, namely the mechanisms underlying EGFR inhibitor resistance. If accepted, this work may help draw more attention to this important yet relatively underexplored research area.
Critical weaknesses
-
A more comprehensive dataset could be curated, for example, by including resistance mutations in kinases other than EGFR. More computational models could also be evaluated, particularly to investigate how existing CADD and AI-based models perform in predicting mutation-induced changes in inhibitor activity.
-
The contributions of this work are minor, particularly from the perspective of the machine learning community. I am not entirely convinced that the current findings align well with the scope and research themes of ICLR, as the study primarily relies on conventional computational chemistry tools and offers limited methodological or technical contributions to the field. Overall, the work seems more suitable for a medicinal chemistry or computational chemistry journal than for a machine learning conference such as ICLR.
-
Figure 1 is of insufficient resolution and should be provided at a higher DPI to improve readability.
Questions for authors
There are multiple PDB structures available for the same EGFR mutation, and the choice of receptor structure can significantly affect docking results. How did the authors select the PDB structures used in this study? Have they evaluated whether their findings are consistent across different experimentally determined structures of the same mutant?