- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces specificity optimization, a task that aims to improve the binding preference of existing molecules toward intended targets over known off-targets while preserving their structural similarity and drug-like properties. To support this task, the authors construct a ChEMBL-derived benchmark of 1,848 compounds with annotated targets and off-targets. They then propose SpecOpt, an LLM-based framework that uses residue-aware contact differences to guide molecular edits, followed by similarity, ADMET, and docking-based filtering. Experiments on 915 compounds show improvements in docking-predicted specificity gaps for 84.8% of the compounds.
Critical strengths
- The paper formulates a practically meaningful task of improving the binding specificity of existing molecules and proposes a dedicated agentic framework to address it.
- The residue-aware contact difference is an intuitive and interpretable signal for guiding molecular edits, and the overall framework is clearly presented.
- The authors construct a ChEMBL-derived benchmark and demonstrate promising results on 915 compounds, improving the docking-predicted specificity gap for 84.8% of them.
- The paper provides useful case studies, ablation experiments, and implementation details that support reproducibility.
Critical weaknesses
- Missing AI use statement. The paper does not include the mandatory AI use statement required by ICLR 2027. This should be flagged for consideration of a potential desk rejection.
- Reliance on Vina for both optimization and evaluation. The method uses Vina-predicted poses to guide molecular edits and Vina scores to select and evaluate candidates, raising concerns about overfitting to docking artifacts. Independent validation using additional scoring functions (e.g., GNINA) and pose-validation tools (e.g., PoseBusters) would strengthen the reported improvements.
- Insufficient baseline comparisons. The paper lacks direct comparisons with existing or simpler docking-guided optimization methods under matched conditions, such as fragment enumeration or LLM editing without contact guidance. It is therefore unclear how much improvement comes specifically from the proposed reasoning mechanism.
- Limitations of the key ablation. Removing residue identities causes the system to terminate without making edits, leading to zero improvement on all 29 compounds. Since the ablated system does not perform a comparable search, this result alone does not fully establish the benefit of residue-aware contact guidance.
Questions for authors
My main questions are covered in the weaknesses above.
I have read the authors’ response and appreciate the efforts that went into improving the paper. As the manuscript stands, I do think maintaining the score is more proper than not.