- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper describes GLORI, a method for causal orientation at a relatively low cost. GLORI uses the neighbors of each causal node to fit a regression model, then calculates the mean signed residual for each environment, then generates scores based on these residual means, and uses the scores to sort the nodes in descending order, then orients the edges in the causal graph.
Critical strengths
1.The paper’s idea is very interesting. It determines the directions of edges in a causal graph by fitting regression models. The method has a low computational cost, has practical value, and is relatively novel.
2.The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the method through sufficient experiments, and the experiments show that the method’s effectiveness is relatively evident.
3.The paper provides a rigorous theoretical proof of the correctness of the method.
Critical weaknesses
- The main problem with the paper lies in the coverage of the method. For the method in the paper, suppose there is a causal relationship X → Y. When using it, if different environments cause X to change while the mechanism generating Y does not change, then there is no particular problem. However, if Y is changed, that is, the environment causes Y to change, then when using X to predict Y, the error will vary with this change, which may cause Y to receive a higher score and be placed earlier, leading to an incorrect direction. The experiments in Table 9 of the paper also reflect this point. I think the paper could discuss this issue further. Of course, I think this is an issue related to the mechanism, and from the perspective of the paper, this flaw does not outweigh its merits.
Questions for authors
Please refer to W1