- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a latent causal discovery method to infer causal relationships among latent variables who have one-to-one mapping to observed variables. The observed variables can be either continuous or ordinal (binary included). They assume both the causal mechanism and measurement mechanism are invariant across environments. Then they are able to identify the covariance of the latents and subsequently the causal DAG.
Critical strengths
The measurement model for continuous variables appears to be fully nonparametric, although the ordinal measurement seems to be parametric (probit) and causal relationship is linear Gaussian. They provide an identifiability result as well as estimation theory. The paper appears to be overall sound.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is the literature doesn't seem to be well reviewed. I am not directly working in this area, but a quick Google search finds the following two papers that appear to be very much related to this paper's topic (I'm sure there are more since I didn't search for it very extensively):
- Causal discovery with linear non-Gaussian models under measurement error: Structural identifiability results
- Independence testing-based approach to causal discovery under measurement error and linear non-Gaussian models. This is based on my understanding of the paper: the main problem the authors tried to address is the measurement problem in causal discovery. Especially for continuous variables, that's really a measurement error problem with a non-parametric error structure, right? Therefore, I think the authors should position their paper against the causal discovery methods that allow measurement errors.
Questions for authors
- What do you lose by using rank-based correlation estimator?
- Do you need to fix tau in practice? how? it looks like it is fixed at 0.2 in real data and in simulations it seems not chosen because AUC doesn't require one.
- What's the convergence rate for G?
- Are there existing mixed-data causal discovery methods or multiple-environment causal representation learning methods you can compare with (treat ordinal as continuous if necessary; for a large number of categories, ordinal data are similar to continuous data in practice)?
- Are the multi-environment assumptions reasonable in the real application and is it possible to check them?