- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper discusses which factors a "world state" in a driving world model should contain, and how these factors should co-evolve, and it appends an extremely large number of experimental results (in the appendix). This is the entirety of the summary I can responsibly provide, because I am completely unable to determine what specific problem this paper starts from, nor what its experimental results actually demonstrate. The paper is extremely difficult to read. Structurally, there is almost no definition or articulation of the problem to solve anywhere in the paper, and no explanation of the research motivation.The use of notation is extremely poor: for example, Table 1 contains H6, K11 and many other opaque symbols, and none of these notations is defined anywhere earlier in the paper. The paper contains 54 tables — I genuinely do not think it is appropriate, for a conference paper with a 9-page main-text limit, to discuss a problem so over-ambitious that it requires 54 tables. On the other hand, the paper contains not a single image: every figure is a flowchart or a line plot. This highly anomalous situation leads me to suspect that the entire paper was generated by AI, and that the authors (if they have actually read it) have no idea how an academic paper should be organized. The code provided by the authors is obviously AI-generated.
Critical strengths
None.
Critical weaknesses
Please check summary.
Questions for authors
Do the authors aware that this is a ICLR submission and will be shown to the public?
Response to Reviewer A4Ay
Thank you for pointing out that the manuscript made the research question and main results difficult to find. We will state the problem at the start of the revision. When an ego vehicle considers different maneuvers, what must a driving world model preserve about nearby vehicles over a rollout, and which parts of those forecasts help select an ego trajectory?
The merge figure is complete. We have prepared an annotated figure from a recorded NAVHARD merge. The front-camera image identifies the neighboring vehicle as it approaches the ego vehicle’s downstream lane. Two bird’s-eye-view panels show the original ego proposal (K0) and its hard-braking variant (K6), along with the frozen Structured-3 model’s forecast for the same neighboring vehicle under each candidate. At 2.5 s, the predicted distance from the ego rear axle to the neighboring vehicle’s center is 2.7 m for K0 and 10.6 m for K6. The model predicts that the neighboring vehicle advances 2.4 m and 0.9 m over four seconds, respectively. The vehicle advances 15.0 m in the recorded continuation. The figure therefore shows both how the forecasts vary with the ego candidate and how substantially the model underestimates the neighboring vehicle’s forward motion in this example.
Revision plan. We will place the figure near the start of the paper and organize the main results around two questions. How do the state and transition choices affect prediction? Which predicted information helps select among fixed candidate trajectories? We will define H6 (the sixth forecast step, about 3 s) and K11 (a pool of 11 candidate trajectories) before their first use. The main text will retain one core prediction table and one core planning table. Detailed ablations and supporting results will move to the appendix.
We understand that the submission and discussion are public. The manuscript’s AI Usage Statement describes assistance with implementation, experiment orchestration and verification, result analysis, and writing. The authors take responsibility for the manuscript, code, and reported results.